Dylan Redwine Case Discussion Thread/Dylan's Remains Found, #2

[Mitsana]

Originally Posted by Lordeebee
"I did everything I could to keep him out of the middle of it."

This sounds like a confession to me.

I asked:
Are you making a reference to Middle Mountain Road?

No, the statement was in regard to the problems between the parents I believe.

The reason I asked is that I thought you might be thinking it was an instance of leakage, which doesn't seem completely impossible to me.

 

[Money Girl]

How could they know without witnesses?

As far as I know, LE has not specifically released how they know, but I could be wrong as I have not read every article.

My personal POIs have changed somewhat. This is just in my opinion only.

Mark Redwine, Deputy Sutter, someone Dylan got into a car with for a ride, someone who knew Dylan was there alone to include locals, friends, other family members.

Again, this is just my personal opinion after all the events that have transpired to this point that I am aware of.

 

[Money Girl]

I doubt LE noticed/ tested a cereal bowl on the first day and taking it ten days later would not be of any use, unless it had remained unwashed.

Didn't they take several items on the initial search of MR's house that he willing allowed? That was prior to the formal search warrant. I don't remember seeing cereal bowl on the list of items taken. I personally think they would have taken it initially.

 

[Lordeebee]

I asked:
Are you making a reference to Middle Mountain Road?



The reason I asked is that I thought you might be thinking it was an instance of leakage, which doesn't seem completely impossible to me.

Yeah, saying that he did EVERYTHING HE COULD to prevent Dylan having to face the parents' problems is what I meant and imo could definitely be leakage. I hadn't thought of your idea about Middle Mountain (or the middle of the woods?) but very interesting too!

 

[nao]

who ever got Dylan to where is remains were found, had to have a road worthy auto, that they trust to get up there and back.
When we (my child and i) lived rural like that it was common if people saw you walking that they would stop and offer a ride. i used to pick up kids i did'nt know and drive them closer to where they were heading, and if my auto was down i got offered rides while walking. jmo moo

 

[Linda7NJ]

Maybe the cereal bowl confirmed he was there? Is MR the only one who mentioned the cereal bowl? Did LE ever say it was there, existed, taken for testing?

IMO Marks own words about Dylan sitting on the end if the sofa texting was challenged by LE. Mark said he argued and argued and argued about that.

That tells me they do not believe him or his story. IMO

 

[Ghostwheel]

Yeah, saying that he did EVERYTHING HE COULD to prevent Dylan having to face the parents' problems is what I meant and imo could definitely be leakage. I hadn't thought of your idea about Middle Mountain (or the middle of the woods?) but very interesting too!

BBM: That's pretty creepy. Thank you for that thought.....:sigh:

 

[Linda7NJ]

"I did everything I could to keep him out of the middle of it."

This sounds like a confession to me.

Sounds like deflecting to me and demanding he alone isn't to blame for ANYTHING ever. IMO

 

[Lordeebee]

Didn't they take several items on the initial search of MR's house that he willing allowed? That was prior to the formal search warrant. I don't remember seeing cereal bowl on the list of items taken. I personally think they would have taken it initially.

Do you remember what they took on the initial search? So long ago I don't recall ... also do you know who gave out the information?

 

[Linda7NJ]

I'll put this out there - not to judge, but to help anyone who may be going through a divorce with children involved.

IMO, ideally, each parent will teach their children to respect their ex. In spite of everything, that person is their parent. With divorce being an upheaval outside the child's control, this is the best thing we can do for them IMO. It's a rule of thumb - never speak ill of your ex in front of your children.

If a child is in the middle of a war between parents, he/she doesn't want to be there but was put there by the warring parties. Heck, the child didn't even ask to be born.

In writing this, I do know that there are truly some evil people out there and in this case, I would do everything possible to keep my children from anyone like that, even if that person was my ex. The problem is, we don't know what another person is capable of before they do it.

I would find it incredibly difficult if the reason I left was due to the mistreatment of my children.

 

[Money Girl]

Do you remember what they took on the initial search? So long ago I don't recall ... also do you know who gave out the information?

I don't know what they took. Don't recall seeing a list, but I do recall the search.

 

[cluciano63]

LE had no reason to take a cereal bowl that first day. They thought he was lost or had run off from what MR told them. They looked for his phone, I remember.

 

[Linda7NJ]

Yeah, saying that he did EVERYTHING HE COULD to prevent Dylan having to face the parents' problems is what I meant and imo could definitely be leakage. I hadn't thought of your idea about Middle Mountain (or the middle of the woods?) but very interesting too!

If Marks behavior was consistent with his behavior now.. I doubt he ever missed a chance to bash his ex-wife. I'm certain at Dylan's age he was infuriated and ferociously defended his mom. I know my son would. I can't see Mark handling that well. That was a long ride ...

 

[Money Girl]

LE had no reason to take a cereal bowl that first day. They thought he was lost or had run off from what MR told them. They looked for his phone, I remember.

What do you think they took to determine that Dylan was there?

 

[SCHMAE]

Oh you know what ? Any item from Walmart would work. We talked way earlier about if his fingerprints were on the dvd , but even the bags and any item inside them he probably touched.

ETA And then I just talked myself out of that because in theory we know he was ok at walmart and made it to the truck at walmart, so he could have touched the bags then. LE said he was inside the home. Who knows if they'll ever tell us .

 

[Ghostwheel]

What do you think they took to determine that Dylan was there?

This was not addressed to me, but I wanted to point out that LE stated that it was confirmed that Dylan ARRIVED at Mark's house. Not that he was inside, just that he got TO the house. The wording is what I pay attention to. It's why I agree with many posters that the confirmation may be related to electronics in nature.

 

[cluciano63]

What do you think they took to determine that Dylan was there?

No idea. Possibly got his prints off the actual unwrapped DVD? I don't recall the entire search warrant. Or maybe his prints were fresh on the remote?

 

[Linda7NJ]

No idea. Possibly got his prints off the actual unwrapped DVD? I don't recall the entire search warrant. Or maybe his prints were fresh on the remote?

For me to believe it, it would take Dylan's skin cells on a pillow case or something else that substantial.

 

[rosesfromangels]

If Marks behavior was consistent with his behavior now.. I doubt he ever missed a chance to bash his ex-wife. I'm certain at Dylan's age he was infuriated and ferociously defended his mom. I know my son would. I can't see Mark handling that well. That was a long ride ...

Anything is possible, and I dont know what LE has gathered , but I stick to my theory this was well planned, orchestrated, premeditated. I see many parallels to the Horman case, and I also wonder if there was an assistant in this crime. A thirteen year old isnt all that easy to transport. I wont be shocked if there is more than one arrest, or some sort of deal made with the D.A. in exchange for testimony. This is purely theory on my part. I do have someone in mind, but it would be irresponsible for me to state who triggers my hinky meter, as this is intuition and behavioral observation, which can often be wrong.

 

[Lordeebee]

This was not addressed to me, but I wanted to point out that LE stated that it was confirmed that Dylan ARRIVED at Mark's house. Not that he was inside, just that he got TO the house. The wording is what I pay attention to. It's why I agree with many posters that the confirmation may be related to electronics in nature.

Refresher course 101 (CAPS MINE) good memory Ghostwheel! I think it is interesting to reread in light of what we now know (sadly)


"Investigators confirmed that Dylan arrived AT Mark's home on Sunday at about 8:00 PM after stops at Walmart and McDonald's in Durango."

"Investigators continue to seek information AND EVIDENCE from the public to determine WHETHER SOMETHING HAPPENED TO DYLAN AT THE HOME or WHETHER HE SOMEHOW LEFT THE HOME and SOMETHING HAPPENED TO HIM AWAY FROM THE HOME."


That reference to "somehow" left the home has always bothered me.