I'm not defending anyone, but I wonder about JS's capacity for reflection, insight...
I.Q. E.Q.
Was JS even able to consider the world from Maddie's perspective? There are lots of people who can't do it. Not necessarily sociopaths. Not apathy. Just unable.
JS, tired, needing sleep. That is very self-centric. No concern for where that puts Maddie. No concern for Maddie's sleep, safety, anxiety, security. It's very perfunctory.
I'm wondering if this falls on a cognitive level. Unable to process on other cylinders.
Because HOW DOES THIS HAPPEN????
Maddie abused from 8 years old and onward...8, 9, 20, 11, 12, 13...
Consider: if JS were an alcoholic. 80-proof every day. And Maddie was left to raise herself. JS, in that scenario, would be derelict, just checked out, unaware. So, is it possible she doesn't have the capacity for great discernment? People like that do exist. Do have jobs and relationships and manage to function without being able to empathize. It's hard to fathom.... but maybe that's how this happened. SS, fast with the stories, confusing to JS, but unable to differentiate?
No free passes but I'm not sure she's functioning on a full level.
State of sheer oblivion? How much of that could be accidental? How much intentional? How much neurological?
With the stats on how many girls have been victims of childhood SA, mostly in their own homes, it's a gutpunch to realize that probably works out to a girl or two or three in every classroom, trying to do school while bearing the awful complexity of abuse...
How do we stop this?
JMO