FL - "Pillowcase Rapist", 44 Victims, 1981-86, Miami to Deerfield Beach *Arrest in 2020* *guilty*

  • #241
Just reposting one of the early article about this infamous serial rapist....


Interesting how the language about DNA sounded rather primitive in 2020 --only 5 years ago! Shows us how much we have learned from Othram!!!


The affidavit said a break in the case came recently, when police arrested Koehler’s son in an unrelated case. The prosecutor later declined to press charges against the son, according to court records.

As a result of that arrest, police obtained the son’s DNA, helping investigators determine that Robert Koehler may have been the rapist in the 1983 case, the affidavit says.

The redacted version of the affidavit does not fully elaborate on how that link was made.

But police have been known to use a technique called genetic genealogy to link crime scene DNA – say, the evidence in the 1983 case – to relatives of whoever left that DNA. Once a relative is identified, investigators determine who on that relative’s family tree could have been around to commit the crime. When they identify a possible suspect, police may try to obtain DNA from that person – such as from saliva left on a trashed napkin.

In this case, investigators determined from the son’s DNA that they needed to find Koehler’s DNA and check it against the 1983 evidence. He had been living in Miami-Dade County in the 1980s, the affidavit says.

On January 16, police watching Koehler’s home followed him to a public area “where DNA swabs were obtained from objects he had touched,” according to the affidavit. The samples were analyzed, leading to probable cause for his arrest, the affidavit says.


Police will need to collect DNA directly from Koehler’s body to confirm that his DNA matches the evidence from the 1983 case, the court affidavit says.

 
  • #242
Things are moving quick! Now we just need to get more agencies to adopt these tools.
 
  • #243
Looks like his trial is next...

Hearings:
JUSTICE BUILDING 7-3
Address 1351 N.W. 12 ST
Hearing Date 10/20/2025
Hearing Time 09:00
Hearing Type T

No docket updates.
 
  • #244
Docket updates:

Docket info:
Din Date Docket
168 10/17/2025 DEPOSITION OF: HUMBERTO TABARES
167 10/17/2025 DEPOSITION OF: JAMES ODONNELL
166 10/17/2025 DEPOSITION OF: NC
165 10/17/2025 DEPOSITION OF: ROSEMARY TAYLOR
164 10/17/2025 NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION WITHIN COURT FILING

163 10/15/2025 ORDER TO RELEASE RECORDS
161 10/15/2025 ORD TO APPT & PAY EXPT FOR COMP EVAL OF DEF FOR MNTL ILLNESS EXPEDITED/DR GIANNA SALAS
160 10/15/2025 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE FILED 10/08/2025 SET FOR 10/17/2025 AT 11:20 DENIED
159 10/15/2025 REPORT RE: FARETTA HEARING SET FOR 10/17/2025 AT 11:00

158 10/14/2025 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE FILED 10/08/2025 SET FOR 10/15/2025 AT 10:47 CONTINUED
157 10/14/2025 E-SUBPOENA: SACRAMENTO, CRISTINA ID: 030-08978 FOR: TRIAL ON 10/20/2025 AT 09:00 ISSUED BY: CJIS SENT: 10/14/2025 RECD/NOTFD: 10/14/2025 ACKN: 10/14/2025 S

link: https://www2.miamidadeclerk.gov/cji...sQkO2L53wJuwrXpoAKPytzYlUtGiKLQMXx6nForTT0Sab
 
  • #245
Monday, October 20th:
*Trial set to begin (Miami-Dade County) (@ 9am ET) - FL – “Pillowcase Rapist” – *Unknown victim - *Robert Eugene Koehler aka Robert Eugene Koeholer (25 @ time of first crime/62/now 65) charged with (3/1/23) & arraigned (3/21/23) with armed burglary/assault, aggravated kidnapping/weapons & 2 counts of armed sexual battery. No Bond. Plead not guilty. Miami-Dade County
Trial set to begin on 10/20/25.
Judge David H. Young & defense attorney Andrew Peters.

*5 victims (1984-1985, Pompano Beach, Broward County) - *Robert Eugene Koehler aka Robert Eugene Koeholer (25 @ time of first crime/62/now 65) charged (6/7/22) with 3 count of sexual battery with great force, 3 counts of armed sexual battery/victim under 12 yrs. in Broward County [on 2/4/84, 6/23/84, 7/23/84, 8/18/84, 8/29/84, 5/13/22]. Broward County
Will be tried after Miami-Dade case than in Broward County charges.
Defense attorneys Andrew Peters & Alexander Shear.
Case info & court info from 7/21/21 (Broward County Case) thru 4/24/23 & from 1/21/25 (Miami-Dade County) thru 9/25/25 reference post #240 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ld-beach-arrest-in-2020-guilty.498416/page-12

10/6/25 Docket update: [153] Additional discovery exhibit. 9/10/25 Docket update: [154] Order on Motion to Compel-granted. 10/8/25 Docket update: [155] Motion for continuance, exclusion or in the alternative a continuance. 10/9/25 Docket update: [156] Report re felony sounding hearing on 10/10/25 @ 9:05am.
10/10/25 Update: Next trial set to begin on 10/20/25 @ 9am. 10/14 Docket updates: [157] E-subpoena for Cristina Sacrament. [158] Motion for continuance filed. 10/15/26 Docket updates: [159] Report re Faretta hearing on 10/17/25. [160[ Motion for continuance filed-Denied. [161] Order to appoint & pay for competency evaluation for defense for mental illness expedited/Dr. Gianna Salas. [163] Order to release records. 10/17/25 Docket updates: [164] Notice of confidential information with court filing. [165 to 168] Deposition of Rosemany Taylor, James O'Donnell & Humberto Tabares.
*40 to 45 victims (May, 1981 to Feb. 1986, Miami to Deerfield Beach) - *Robert Eugene Koehler aka Robert Eugene Koeholer (22 @ time of 1st crime/60/now 65) – Found guilty (1/25/23) & sentenced on 3/17/23 to 17 years in prison.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
126
Guests online
2,122
Total visitors
2,248

Forum statistics

Threads
633,551
Messages
18,643,831
Members
243,577
Latest member
Rieske
Back
Top