GUILTY GA - Rodrigo Abad Diaz, 22, fatally shot due to faulty GPS, Lilburn, 26 Jan 2013

  • #21
Are there any Georgians in here?

I think it is very apparent that their ARE Georgians here seeing as how many people clearly designate their locations.

I am a California native that is now Georgian and proud of it. I am not even going to address your comments as I do not wish to violate the rules of this site.
 
  • #22
If homeowner felt threatened, he could have simply aimed into the sky and fired a warning shot into the air FIRST.

Do the police fire "warning shots"??? No.

Ever wonder why? Because what goes UP must come down and "warning shots" will come down somewhere possibly injuring or killing someone or damaging property.

Most folks I know would NOT fire a warning shot, they may give a verbal warning but if they are pushed to the point of firing their weapon they will shoot to kill. If they have to fire the negotiations are over.
 
  • #23
Do the police fire "warning shots"??? No.

Ever wonder why? Because what goes UP must come down and "warning shots" will come down somewhere possibly injuring or killing someone or damaging property.

Most folks I know would NOT fire a warning shot, they may give a verbal warning but if they are pushed to the point of firing their weapon they will shoot to kill. If they have to fire the negotiations are over.

You're comparing apples to oranges. The homeowner is NOT a police officer.

Police officers are specifically trained to handle ambiguous situations such as these. The homeowner is NOT.

Furthermore, you as a private armed citizen are supposed to use "reasonable force" against an aggressor only in cases of self-defense, not excessive, deadly force to kill someone who was obviously NOT committing any crimes against you or your property.

Unless the group of people who had driven onto your property posed a reasonable threat to you/your property, or the foreign exchange student had acted in such a manner as to have physically threatened you or your property, you have no right to shoot to kill.

I believe in use of comparable force against antagonists. The homeowner, if he felt threatened, should have stayed inside his home and called the police, not run outside to confront what he considers dangerous criminals by shouting out "Shut up!" and over-extend himself by fatally killing innocent people.

Sorry, any way you look at it, the homeowners were DEAD WRONG in the case discussed in this thread, as well as the Baton Rouge case, and in both, innocent people were unjustly murdered.
 
  • #24
Sorry, any way you look at it, the homeowners were DEAD WRONG in the case discussed in this thread, as well as the Baton Rouge case, and in both, innocent people were unjustly murdered.

This guy will probably be convicted. The Baton Rouge homeowner was not found guilty.

The standard is generally are you "in fear for your life or in fear for the lives of others" and if a stranger comes onto your property and you tell them to leave while brandishing a firearm, and they keep COMING AT YOU then that can certainly be made into an argument that you are in fear for your life.

The homeowner in this story doesn't stand a chance, the man in Baton Rouge was found NOT GUILTY because he told the person to back off and the student kept heading straight toward him quickly even while staring down the barrel of a gun.
 
  • #25
This guy will probably be convicted. The Baton Rouge homeowner was not found guilty.

The standard is generally are you "in fear for your life or in fear for the lives of others" and if a stranger comes onto your property and you tell them to leave while brandishing a firearm, and they keep COMING AT YOU then that can certainly be made into an argument that you are in fear for your life.

The homeowner in this story doesn't stand a chance, the man in Baton Rouge was found NOT GUILTY because he told the person to back off and the student kept heading straight toward him quickly even while staring down the barrel of a gun.

I don't see a difference between the two cases. Yet, you seem to be making the distinction that the Baton Rouge homeowner was somehow justified in shooting an innocent foreign exchange student.

What is the difference? In both cases, innocent people were killed. Unless you can prove to me the foreign exchange student was committing a crime and/or presented an imminent physical danger to the homeowner, you have no case.

Let's consider when the tables are turned. Let's say you're visiting Spain and you don't speak Spanish. You rented a car. It runs out of gas in front of a Spaniard's home. Would you want the homeowners to come running out to confront you in a language you don't speak and then shoot and kill you on the spot because you didn't understand what they were saying and you continued to walk up their driveway?

Be serious!

Furthermore, from what I can tell, the only reason the Baton Rouge homeowner was acquitted is that that the jury pool were full of his American peers -- NOT foreigners whom I am certain would have voted to convict.

Anyhow, I'm not going to continue arguing this because I find both of these murder cases RIDICULOUS. And I'm not going to change my POV and I genuinely don't care if you don't either. Just know if I am ever in a juror in a case in which you've shot and killed an innocent person who unknowingly walked into your property that I will vote GUILTY as heck. lol
 
  • #26
Now I know that there is a recent increase of older people acting irrationally. My daughter and her fiancee were at 7-11 today. They were joking around and he pretended to begin to drive off without her. An older woman quit pumping her gas, pushed my daughter aside, and opened the door screaming and calling him a 🤬🤬🤬. Saying he doesn't deserve a woman like my daughter. She wouldn't listen that they were joking. He's the nicest guy ever and even bought me a hoodie and matching pants just before this happened and supports his dad financially.
 
  • #27

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
123
Guests online
2,291
Total visitors
2,414

Forum statistics

Threads
635,353
Messages
18,674,412
Members
243,174
Latest member
Bedroom Detective
Back
Top