Harvard Professor Arrested--Gates Black in America

  • #321
She sure does, as do you!

I have done some reading on Professor Gates and his views that confirm what I thought initially. He has repeatedly demonstrated a huge chip on his shoulder even putting this on his Yale application:

"As always, whitey now sits in judgment of me, preparing to cast my fate. It is your decision either to let me blow with the wind as a nonentity or to encourage the development of self. Allow me to prove myself."

http://www.wtop.com/?nid=104&pid=0&sid=1725138&page=2

ON AN APPLICATION! I have read several other offensive comments but I will not put them on here.
[SNIPPED BY STEADFAST]

In the late '60's, when Gates applied to Yale, that statement would have been considered somewhat cool. Remember, this would have been only about 4-5 years after the U.S. saw fit to grant equal rights to African American citizens, and many in power were still kicking and screaming about it. And it did get him into Yale.

I have also done some reading on Professor Gates; in fact, I've studied and taught him for years. Henry Louis Gates is one of the foremost scholars in the world, and out of the millions of words he has written, I'm sure there are some that people may find offensive. However, his scholarship has forwarded understanding of the African American experience as much or more than anyone else living. Dismissing his work as showing he has "a chip on his shoulder," is facile.
Can any of us compete with the recognition and honors that his work has earned?
An influential cultural critic, Professor Gates has written for Time magazine, The New Yorker, and The New York Times. He is the editor of several anthologies, including The Norton Anthology of African American Literature (W.W. Norton, 1996). Professor Gates also produced and hosted two previous series for PBS, 1999’s “Wonders of the African World” and 2004’s “America Beyond the Color Line.”
Professor Gates earned his M.A. and Ph.D. in English literature from Clare College at the University of Cambridge, and his B.A. summa 🤬🤬🤬 laude in History from Yale University, where he was a Scholar of the House, in 1973. He became a member of Phi Beta Kappa in his junior year at Yale. Before joining the faculty of Harvard in 1991, he taught at Yale, Cornell, and Duke. His honors and grants include a MacArthur Foundation “genius grant” (1981), the George Polk Award for Social Commentary (1993), Time magazine’s “25 Most Influential Americans” list (1997), a National Humanities Medal (1998), election to the American Academy of Arts and Letters (1999), the Jefferson Lecture (2002), a Visiting Fellowship at the School of Social Science at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton (2003-2004), and the 2008 Ralph Lowell Award from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, the highest honor awarded for accomplishments in public television (2009). He has received 50 honorary degrees, from institutions including the University of Pennsylvania, Dartmouth College, Harvard University, New York University, University of Massachusetts-Boston, Williams College, Emory University, University of Toronto, Morehouse, and the University of Benin.
http://aaas.fas.harvard.edu/faculty/henry_louis_gates_jr/index.html
 
  • #322
In the late '60's, when Gates applied to Yale, that statement would have been considered somewhat cool. Remember, this would have been only about 4-5 years after the U.S. saw fit to grant equal rights to African American citizens, and many in power were still kicking and screaming about it. And it did get him into Yale.

I have also done some reading on Professor Gates; in fact, I've studied and taught him for years. Henry Louis Gates is one of the foremost scholars in the world, and out of the millions of words he has written, I'm sure there are some that people may find offensive. However, his scholarship has forwarded understanding of the African American experience as much or more than anyone else living. Dismissing his work as showing he has "a chip on his shoulder," is facile.
Can any of us compete with the recognition and honors that his work has earned?

Gates statement about "whitey" made me laugh out loud - it is awesome - it is sarcastic and ironic and funny and hip, all at the same time. Especially, as you point out, at the time he applied.
 
  • #323
  • #324
  • #325
In the late '60's, when Gates applied to Yale, that statement would have been considered somewhat cool. Remember, this would have been only about 4-5 years after the U.S. saw fit to grant equal rights to African American citizens, and many in power were still kicking and screaming about it. And it did get him into Yale.

I have also done some reading on Professor Gates; in fact, I've studied and taught him for years. Henry Louis Gates is one of the foremost scholars in the world, and out of the millions of words he has written, I'm sure there are some that people may find offensive. However, his scholarship has forwarded understanding of the African American experience as much or more than anyone else living. Dismissing his work as showing he has "a chip on his shoulder," is facile.
Can any of us compete with the recognition and honors that his work has earned?


Who dismissed his work? I am glad some consider it cool, I do not. There are many people who would find some of his statements offensive. Lack of racism and tolerance involve ALL races, not just one. If equality is to be achieved we must practice what we preach ...my opinion.
 
  • #326
...I don't understand the logic behind yelling, screaming, kicking, and calling a member of law enforcement "a racist rogue" cop in order to "assert one's rights". lol, I am truly scratching my head here.
...

IMO



Gosh, I didn't hear that there was KICKING involved!! Please direct me to the source for this information. And any yelling or screaming was in a hoarse, bronchitis-subdued tone. But KICKING!! I guess he could have stood on his 'good' leg and kicked with the one on which he has recently had hip replacement surgery...Wish I had known about the Kicking sooner- that would clearly be a case of attacking a law enforcement officer. Please share the link for this; it doesn't seem to be in the police report or in any media I have seen.

And if I were being wrongly arrested, I would yell, scream, cry, and do everything I could to attract the attention of witnesses to my plight. I am eager to hear what the civilian witnesses to this incident have to say- the Boston media are asleep at the wheel if they haven't spoken to the witnesses.
 
  • #327
Gosh, I didn't hear that there was KICKING involved!! Please direct me to the source for this information. And any yelling or screaming was in a hoarse, bronchitis-subdued tone. But KICKING!! I guess he could have stood on his 'good' leg and kicked with the one on which he has recently had hip replacement surgery...Wish I had known about the Kicking sooner- that would clearly be a case of attacking a law enforcement officer. Please share the link for this; it doesn't seem to be in the police report or in any media I have seen.

And if I were being wrongly arrested, I would yell, scream, cry, and do everything I could to attract the attention of witnesses to my plight. I am eager to hear what the civilian witnesses to this incident have to say- the Boston media are asleep at the wheel if they haven't spoken to the witnesses.

LOL about kicking. :crazy: Maybe instead of "kicking," he shook his cane at Crowley, you know, like old men are wont to do: "You police officers get offa my lawn!"
 
  • #328
Very cool!

Really? Everyone has to be so enlightened already. Can't anyone just say, "I was really kind of a jack 🤬🤬🤬 and I'm sorry"???

That would be cool to me.
 
  • #329
Nova, no offense, and I hope this post doesn't come across as having a sacastic tone,but you and I are not on the same page in regards to "asserting one's rights".:)

It kinda amazes me that you obviously thought I didn't know my rights or how to "assert my rights" accordingly, because I would prefer not to get into a confrontational argument with a police officer.

I don't understand the logic behind yelling, screaming, kicking, and calling a member of law enforcement "a racist rogue" cop in order to "assert one's rights". lol, I am truly scratching my head here.

If I have an encounter with a police officer, unless I see a "clear" violation of my rights, if he says jump, I will ask how high. Note the word "clear". On the other hand, if I see a clear violation of my rights, I will assert my rights, but I will assert in a civil manner.

I belive Mr. Gates thought he had the ability to assert his rights with total disregard to the rights of others.

Again, hope this doesn't come across in a sarcastic tone, but I don't need an Attorney to tell me Professor Gates accusations are unfounded. We have no proof at all that Sgt. Crowley's actions were racially motivated.

IMO

Gosh, I didn't hear that there was KICKING involved!! Please direct me to the source for this information. And any yelling or screaming was in a hoarse, bronchitis-subdued tone. But KICKING!! I guess he could have stood on his 'good' leg and kicked with the one on which he has recently had hip replacement surgery...Wish I had known about the Kicking sooner- that would clearly be a case of attacking a law enforcement officer. Please share the link for this; it doesn't seem to be in the police report or in any media I have seen.

And if I were being wrongly arrested, I would yell, scream, cry, and do everything I could to attract the attention of witnesses to my plight. I am eager to hear what the civilian witnesses to this incident have to say- the Boston media are asleep at the wheel if they haven't spoken to the witnesses.

Morag, do you see Professor Gates name in that statement? We were discussing "asserting one's rights" in general.

However, if Gates is capable of traveling overseas, getting on/off a motorcycle, I am more than sure he has the strength to lift his leg and kick.

Please share the name of the witness who has stated Mr. Gates tone was hoarse and subdued.
 
  • #330
I have a lot of respect for your posts, Magnolia. You have a good 'head on your shoulders'. JMO

Thank-You angeleven. Having your respect means a lot to me.
 
  • #331
  • #332
  • #333
I agree...that picture is priceless. I truly admire what I have seen and heard about Crowley.
 
  • #334
  • #335
OMG that pic spoke not a thousand words but a million! Ummm but let me guess what most folks will say...he's only doing it for the camera's...

I'm definately not one of those folks.
 
  • #336
Interesting read~

The first question to be asked about Sgt. Crowley’s initial response is, was it lawful and reasonable? Clearly it was both. A cornerstone U.S. Supreme Court decision, Terry v. Ohio, held that an officer may stop and detain a person he reasonably believes to be involved in criminal activity. Here, Sgt. Crowley answered a citizen’s report of a possible burglary. Such reports are granted a presumption of reliability under the law, so Sgt. Crowley was on solid ground in approaching the home and, upon seeing a man inside who matched the description provided by the witness, asking him for his identification. A police officer responding to such a report must, for his own safety, assume the report to be accurate until he can satisfy himself that it isn’t. The cop who blithely handles every call assuming it to be a false alarm will likely not survive to handle many of them.In fact, many police officers faced with the identical facts would likely have ordered Henry Gates out of the home at gunpoint.






http://pajamasmedia.com/blog/sgt-james-crowleys-nightmare-is-all-too-real/
 
  • #337
I agree...that picture is priceless. I truly admire what I have seen and heard about Crowley.

There's no question that Crowley is a terrific man! So is Gates. That's just one of the things that makes this incident so interesting.
 
  • #338
That was an interesting read, magnolia. However, if you go look at "Jack Dunphy's" list of blogs (http://pajamasmedia.com/blog/author/jackdunphy/page/2/), you find that almost every one of them is a defense of LE actions against minorities or criticisms of LE actions benefitting minorities. I would say his most recent blog is more a furtherance of his agenda than a thoughtful piece about a specific incident. He basically "collects" incidents like this to write about.

I'm not saying he doesn't have some valid points, I'm just saying he's got a dog in this fight.
 
  • #339
Re: the picture of the 3 leaving the White House

It has been reported that Obama is a long-time friend of Gates.

I have a very dear friend with a disability who used a cane for a several years and now uses a scooter to get around. It is an unspoken rule between the two of us that if she needs my help, she will ask for it. She is very independent and will graciously accept help from strangers to be polite. But, if I try to help her without her asking, I get the evil eye.

I'm not saying this is the case with Gates and Obama, just food for thought.
 
  • #340
Jack Dunphy

“Jack Dunphy” is the pseudonym of an officer with the Los Angeles Police Department. The opinions expressed are his own and almost certainly do not reflect those of the LAPD management.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
89
Guests online
1,316
Total visitors
1,405

Forum statistics

Threads
632,382
Messages
18,625,538
Members
243,128
Latest member
Cheesy
Back
Top