GUILTY HI - Carly Joann 'Charli' Scott, 27, pregnant, Makawao, 9 Feb 2014 - #1

[Mamamerced]

Art is open to interpretation, but this is who I think the "she" is:

Good one, Kapua!

 

[Mamamerced]

I think this was answered already. Sorry just checking in now.
The facebook page "a study to find out what happened to Charli and Joshua Scott"...the person has a map with specific streets and area to search.

I asked why that specific location. The answer was SC grandfather lives around there.

As I've said, the "A study" page is very interesting as is the Crabapple Jones page. Why so mysterious? Why the subliminal messages?

As far as this or any other online activity giving SC ideas...he's already given his statements, any change to his story or movement will be red flagged.

Just a guess, but I think it's meant to unnerve SC........get under his skin to rattle him. Other thoughts?

 

[Seajay]

If the girlfriend was not ready to be a stepparent there is nothing wrong with expressing that. She's 21 for God's sake! That is a reasonable and honest conversation to have. I may be wrong but I do not think this was a serious relationship. It's unfair to point the finger at this girl. No way she could have known CS fate.

Then she should have told him she wanted to break up since he was expecting a child with CS.

If she said that in passing, long before CS became pregnant, that's whole different story. Sure she has a right to her opinion and it's her life, if she doesn't want to be a stepmother, then she shouldn't be a stepmother, but when she's in a relationship with someone who is going to be a father by someone else, then she just needed to break up with him and end it so that she can follow her heart and what she wants.

Now instead, it looks like possibly SC got the idea if he eliminated the "problem" that would clear the way for his relationship with her.

 

[Kapua]

Just a guess, but I think it's meant to unnerve SC........get under his skin to rattle him. Other thoughts?

He/she appears to be trying to goad someone into telling what they know about SC to the authorities. Or, at the very least, to get someone to disassociate himself/herself from SC.

"Would you drink with the person that killed your family member? Have you no soul? You are being associated in our community with this scourge. It's time you grow up and think about how you will paint your life.

We see you. Everybody knows Steven killed Charli. And we see you you associating with him. And we are so let down. As a community.

Auwe"

(Auwe is a Hawaiian word that translates to 'alas' in English.)

 

[Mamamerced]

He/she appears to be trying to goad someone into telling what they know about SC to the authorities. Or, at the very least, to get someone to disassociate himself/herself from SC.

"Would you drink with the person that killed your family member? Have you no soul? You are being associated in our community with this scourge. It's time you grow up and think about how you will paint your life.

We see you. Everybody knows Steven killed Charli. And we see you you associating with him. And we are so let down. As a community.

Auwe"

(Auwe is a Hawaiian word that translates to 'alas' in English.)

Yes, I believe you're right.

 

[Kapua]

Yes, I believe you're right.

Another of his posts. I like him; he clearly has a conscience and wants to do something without disrupting the investigation. IMHO, as always. :moo:

"One day you can reflect upon the decisions you made today. Are you your own Hero?"

 

[mrsobrien]

*flashback to Scott Peterson*

Now instead, it looks like possibly SC got the idea if he eliminated the "problem" that would clear the way for his relationship with her.

 

[TeganJeff]

Then she should have told him she wanted to break up since he was expecting a child with CS.

If she said that in passing, long before CS became pregnant, that's whole different story. Sure she has a right to her opinion and it's her life, if she doesn't want to be a stepmother, then she shouldn't be a stepmother, but when she's in a relationship with someone who is going to be a father by someone else, then she just needed to break up with him and end it so that she can follow her heart and what she wants.

Now instead, it looks like possibly SC got the idea if he eliminated the "problem" that would clear the way for his relationship with her.

Do we know the context in which she told him? Maybe she was breaking up with him at the time and that was one of the reasons she gave?

Sent from my Galaxy Note 2 using Tapatalk

 

[heartgoesout]

Then she should have told him she wanted to break up since he was expecting a child with CS.

If she said that in passing, long before CS became pregnant, that's whole different story. Sure she has a right to her opinion and it's her life, if she doesn't want to be a stepmother, then she shouldn't be a stepmother, but when she's in a relationship with someone who is going to be a father by someone else, then she just needed to break up with him and end it so that she can follow her heart and what she wants.

Now instead, it looks like possibly SC got the idea if he eliminated the "problem" that would clear the way for his relationship with her.

Agreed, if they were in a long term relationship. Were they dating when CS got pregnant? I was sensing this was not serious. Can anyone confirm how long they dated?
(Scott Peterson met Amber Frey 1 month before her Laci's disappearance.)

 

[Kapua]

Agreed, if they were in a long term relationship. Were they dating when CS got pregnant? I was sensing this was not serious. Can anyone confirm how long they dated?
(Scott Peterson met Amber Frey 1 month before her Laci's disappearance.)

According to the "Study" FB page, they were together by early November 2013, so they were dating about 3 months prior to Charli's murder and not when Charli got pregnant, which was in late September. So the relationship was fairly new. As with Scott and Laci, the girlfriend is the symptom, not the problem. The problem was that Steven did not want the responsibilities of fatherhood. (The answer to his question, "What man doesn't want a son?" is Scott Peterson, for one. And there are many others.)

 

[heartgoesout]

Just a guess, but I think it's meant to unnerve SC........get under his skin to rattle him. Other thoughts?

My impression is that they know something.
I have my own thoughts on who and why.

 

[heartgoesout]

According to the "Study" FB page, they were together by early November 2013, so they were dating about 3 months prior to Charli's murder and not when Charli got pregnant, which was in late September. So the relationship was fairly new. As with Scott and Laci, the girlfriend is the symptom, not the problem. The problem was that Steven did not want the responsibilities of fatherhood. (The answer to his question, "What man doesn't want a son?" is Scott Peterson, for one. And there are many others.)

It's almost as if he was questioning himself on that question.

So CS gets pregnant late September. Early November SC starts to date new girl. Does CS even know she's pregnant at this point? New girl leaves island for extended stay elsewhere. Pregnancy is confirmed. New girl due back soon. SC hopes to rekindle with her? Understandably she is not into being a step-mom at 21. The rest is set in motion.

 

[hambirg]

I have to pretty much wonder why she even made such a comment. Is that when SC told her that CS was expecting? And if she made that comment, what did she think was going to happen?

She should have just told him she wanted to break up instead of sounding so petty and thereby inadvertently putting a target on CS's back and the baby's.

I'm sure in hindsight she would have answered differently. However, did she even know why the topic came up? She may have not known anything about SC and CS's "relationship." She just answered a question truthfully, not knowing this (&^$)** had a pregnant FB. And I'm sorry about the FB , but obviously that is what Charli was to him. Judging by some of her family's statements about him, she really cared about this guy. It makes me sooooo angry! Even if he's not guilty of disappearing Charli, he's a gigantic *ss!!!! It's not just Charli. In my eyes, an innocent baby is a victim here too.

I think this was answered already. Sorry just checking in now.
The facebook page "a study to find out what happened to Charli and Joshua Scott"...the person has a map with specific streets and area to search.

I asked why that specific location. The answer was SC grandfather lives around there.

As I've said, the "A study" page is very interesting as is the Crabapple Jones page. Why so mysterious? Why the subliminal messages?

As far as this or any other online activity giving SC ideas...he's already given his statements, any change to his story or movement will be red flagged.

These pages. .. Anons or not. . .they hacked SC's phone. That's why they are being "mysterious." No mystery really, hacking is illegal.

 

[Mamamerced]

These pages. .. Anons or not. . .they hacked SC's phone. That's why they are being "mysterious." No mystery really, hacking is illegal.

Why do you believe "they" hacked SC's phone?

 

[hambirg]

Why do you believe "they" hacked SC's phone?

Because I have seen many similar screenshots from when Anons have hacked someones phone. Also, who those pics were sent to can still be deciphered from the screenshots. I don't think anyone would put it out there like that if they were one of the recipients of those pics, kwim?

 

[Mamamerced]

Because I have seen many similar screenshots from when Anons have hacked someones phone. Also, who those pics were sent to can still be deciphered from the screenshots. I don't think anyone would put it out there like that if they were one of the recipients of those pics, kwim?

Is there any other way to get those screen shots?

 

[Seajay]

Agreed, if they were in a long term relationship. Were they dating when CS got pregnant? I was sensing this was not serious. Can anyone confirm how long they dated?
(Scott Peterson met Amber Frey 1 month before her Laci's disappearance.)

Exactly! Even though she's not responsible for what he's done, if he did it, her words set this little mind to thinking. Amber Frey had no idea when she was involved with Scott Peterson that he was married, let alone he had a pregnant wife. This gal (Cass?) may not have had any idea that she was dating a man who would think murder was an option to fix this "problem." That's what I've been trying to say, just beating around the bush, I guess.

 

[hambirg]

Is there any other way to get those screen shots?

Only the ones that can be viewed on those FB pages.

 

[Seajay]

I just can't understand all these people disappearing in paradise. Charli, Mo, and now this David. Maui is such a beautiful place. You don't ever imagine anything bad happening.

 

[Nikki Lisette]

These pages. .. Anons or not. . .they hacked SC's phone. That's why they are being "mysterious." No mystery really, hacking is illegal.

There was no hacking. Facebook was created for the narcissist. Those are Steven's own pics he posted on his FB. I'm sure if FB had rolled out a year earlier, Scott Peterson would've had two or three accounts to maintain his philandering.