GUILTY HI - Carly Joann 'Charli' Scott, 27, pregnant, Makawao, 9 Feb 2014 - #4

[heartgoesout]

I'm watching on youtube and listening to Loo's interview. Some things that really stand out to me.
Steven said he drives Hana when he wants to listen to his very loud truck stereo because "NOBODY CAN HEAR YOU."

He says he WOULD have been ready for the baby and WAS ready for the baby in two different sentences. He then says muffled "I keep saying it like she's gone". ((sigh))

He then says he's the prime suspect...and we've all discussed this, prime suspect of what? At this point she just missing.

 

[puakenikeni]

I'm paraphrasing here but Steven said in the second interview that he feeds his dogs pretty much "raw food". So vegetarian or not, he was comfortable handling flesh.

good point, but not necessarily similar to butchering. Not Ramsay Bolton level dog feeding. ;-)

My grandparents had an old style pet shop where they sold pure meat (horse meat) for dog food, and they had a grinder that turned it into ground meat and sold it in a package. There was nothing the pet owner needed to do but open the package and serve it up. It wasn't bloody. It wasn't cutting through bone and sinews. I'm sure there are similar options today. I used to buy unseasoned poke at the counter for my cats and I would dice it up. There are degrees of being grossed out about flesh. It's not all or nothing.

 

[puakenikeni]

I thought it was interesting that the only time Steven really got some intensity to his voice there was when he talked about feeding his dogs nothing but he best and NO FILLERS. He cares about his dogs. His child to be, well it could be a legacy for him and that's nice and he would not hurt it, all said calmly.

 

[puakenikeni]

I think today bore out the MPD claim that the first interview was seeking information and the second when he had his rights read he was told flat out that Loo was looking at him as a suspect, having a tough time believing him. The whole demeanor was changed.

Friday, the morning after clothes were found with stab wounds in the skirt. A blanket covered with maggots found and empty rolls of duct tape. Loo had to know this, and a veteran like him has to presume she is deceased and he starts telling Steven they WILL find her and what story will that tell. Will it tell a story that he lied. He's so quick to say he's a 100% positive it will not. Because he thinks he did a good job of disposing of remains? But he really didn't. Does he not know that? I wonder.

 

[Mamamerced]

I was more astonished by the nonchalant/eager-helpful tone you mention than his lack of local accent. He thinks he can just play it off. But... he says that he had only learned about the baby a month previous (lie) and then says that he knows that he's the "prime suspect" (his words) at the point when it's still a missing person investigation. I predict that his own words are going to trip him up more than any other evidence.

Yes, I think so, too, Kapua. He's now given about 3-4 different versions of the "marks" on his hands. And also about what was wrong with his truck. His lies are laid in concrete now. Good catch about him being the prime "suspect". Huh? Suspected of what? His tongue got ahead of his rehearsal. And now he has to sit there and squirm as the world hears his ridiculous fabrications.

 

[Mamamerced]

I think today bore out the MPD claim that the first interview was seeking information and the second when he had his rights read he was told flat out that Loo was looking at him as a suspect, having a tough time believing him. The whole demeanor was changed.

Friday, the morning after clothes were found with stab wounds in the skirt. A blanket covered with maggots found and empty rolls of duct tape. Loo had to know this, and a veteran like him has to presume she is deceased and he starts telling Steven they WILL find her and what story will that tell. Will it tell a story that he lied. He's so quick to say he's a 100% positive it will not. Because he thinks he did a good job of disposing of remains? But he really didn't. Does he not know that? I wonder.

My old iPad died on me today so I missed a lot of the testimony regarding the 2nd interview. I thought it took place on Wed. 12th. On to Court Chatter to catch the rest.

 

[heartgoesout]

Was the second interview conducted after the poly? Was the poly the reason for the second interview?

 

[Loio]

This whole ordeal is terrible for all involved. I didn't want to hear that Charli's breasts were pierced or see him undressed to his waist. Now I'm thinking the body piercing found was one of her breasts.

 

[puakenikeni]

Let me know if it's not Friday. I know the first was Wed. and then the polygraph that day.

He said the "undeniable I'm the prime suspect" line to Mileka from HNN too, on Thursday.

Well, now we know what truck he may have detailed on the Monday. The same one he repeatedly offered up for a police search. (The Forerunner, lifted, seems to be his only vehicle he was driving, in fact he said as much, mentioned his gas cost, mentioned the loan from his boss, talked about the tires.)

 

[puakenikeni]

This whole ordeal is terrible for all involved. I didn't want to hear that Charli's breasts were pierced or see him undressed to his waist. Now I'm thinking the body piercing found was one of her breasts.

yes, I thought of that too. Either way it is unbearable.
I just hope that her soul flew far away fast and never knew what was done, but I do not think Kim pictures it that way, or dreams it that way, because of Joshua. (Judging by KS' amazing poems.)

 

[heartgoesout]

I hit pause and replay. In Loo's part 2 interview around the 23 min mark Steven answers the question why he didn't wait to continue to see her headlights he answers in part...
"She wasn't stuck in Keanue (sp) anymore and if she got stuck in Twin Falls I was only a phone call away"

WTH? Now hold up a second. According to him it was he that was stuck not her. She wasn't stuck anymore??? And why would he think she could get stuck again at Twin Falls???

Is it possible that she met him there for whatever reason, then her car got stuck and he took advantage of her vulnerable position. If he met her there at 8:30p would the timeline make more sense? I'm rambling without really thinking it through because he statement really threw me.

edited...she was low on gas. mind overload right now.

 

[heartgoesout]

I don't like the way he says he wants to find "this girl". Really? ...this girl? She has a name, her son has a name.
He says he would love a legacy. Oh I bet.
He says about naming the son. Loo asks Oh did you know it was a boy? I'm hoping that he didn't see that it was a boy. ugh

 

[Kapua]

I am also finding some of the gruesome details hard to listen to.

On a different note: One slightly new thing I learned from SC's recorded interview today is that the red lights in the skull ornament on the grill in Charli's car shone almost as bright as her headlights. We've heard that the grill was "distinctive" before, but now I have a clearer understanding of what that would look like coming down the street at night. SC mentioned the grill at least twice.

 

[RunDaSurf]

“But I get half the house to myself I can do whatever I want and I can leave my dog there which is really big for me there’s a big acre yard and I don’t have to chain my dog up I refuse to do that.”


“God that’s going to go up now that I took one of her dogs”

 

[heartgoesout]

It's never -20 degrees in Pennsylvania by the way. ; )

 

[heartgoesout]

SC "I didn't have anyone else do it"
Do what Steven??

 

[RunDaSurf]

“I did not have anyone else do it. I just wanted to make this all work.”

Do what mutha faka

 

[Mamamerced]

Let me know if it's not Friday. I know the first was Wed. and then the polygraph that day.

He said the "undeniable I'm the prime suspect" line to Mileka from HNN too, on Thursday.

Well, now we know what truck he may have detailed on the Monday. The same one he repeatedly offered up for a police search. (The Forerunner, lifted, seems to be his only vehicle he was driving, in fact he said as much, mentioned his gas cost, mentioned the loan from his boss, talked about the tires.)

You're correct, Pua. It was Friday, 14.

 

[Loio]

A quick sidenote and a little history regarding Maui's pidgin dialect:

In the early 1900s, workers were imported here by Alexander and Baldwin to work their sugar cane fields, mills, pineapple fields and canneries. The workers largely came from Japan, Portugal and the Phillipines. Each ethicity was kept separated by housing them in camps. Pidgin was developed as a language everyone could all understand in the fields. There was an English standard school on Maui in Sprecklesville where admission was granted only after determining that the student did not "suffer" the pidgin dialect. The school closed in the early 60s, shortly after Hawaii became a State in the Union for several obvious reasons.

Anyway, the pidgin dialect is an affliction of distinction in Hawaii. It means you've earned your stripes (generational or otherwise) and your family is aina.

Sorry to interrupt.

 

[puakenikeni]

You're correct, Pua. It was Friday, 14.

how funny, I was just reading about a second interview on Wednesday and was going to post apology for getting it wrong. I notice Loo did not mention the burned car, so it does seem like it should have been included in questions if it were Friday. I'm all mixed up.
in any case, it was really good to hear it.