GUILTY HI - Carly Joann 'Charli' Scott, 27, pregnant, Makawao, 9 Feb 2014 - #5

[Kapua]

Just me thinking out loud...Let's say he asked Charli to meet with him so he could give her the money he owed her. Let's say he then planned a robbery to get that money back. Enter accomplice here. He did ask for money for tires that we've read he never got. He gives her that money, but plans on getting it right back. Now this I can see being totally planned out. He could have told her the money is down Hana or so and so has it down Hana. A good amount of money that she probably needed could be motivation for traveling with him. He's also had some robbery issues. I haven't gotten any farther but this could make sense. Robbery doesn't go quite as planned and she fights back or Nala gets in the way. hmmm

Or he could have been planning to get the money from one of his, um, customers in Keanae.

 

[Kapua]

I want to know what parts of the lie detector test he failed.

:laughing:

I have this mental picture of the pen making huge patterns on the graph paper every time SC answers a question - just spiking all over the place.

 

[Nikki Lisette]

Charli's skirt was slashed with holes concentrated on one side. Why? Because she was ambushed. The car was torched to cover up the crime. Notice there is no bloody crime scene? Even in the location of the body parts and hacked branches, there were no copious amounts of blood. Unless Rivera hasn't gotten to that part yet, which I can't imagine.

 

[PeterTosh]

Yeah, I think anyone here would have had made a better plan if we were murdererous types. I initially thought he might be innocent because a guilty person would have his act together and a more solid story.

Re PT's comment about ultimatum time:
You don't think that time was earlier? Hard for me to buy that he thought she would willingly have an abortion at that point. Legally she was probably just shy of the limit in Hawai'i (24-26 weeks looks like), but mentally and emotionally she was far past that consideration, and so were her family and friends. Baby toys bought, maternity clothes wearing, baby shower planned, plans to live with Adam and Lydia ...

Plus he would be hated by many for pressuring her into it, would he not? (Yes, not hated nearly as much as for what he did, but he hoped to get away with that.)

I dont think guys think in the emotional sense. He wanted to get on with life with Cass and all those people you mention were yesterdays news

 

[PeterTosh]

If I was thinking about and planning a crime I sure would have had a better plan. The sloppiness makes me think he started and someone else finished or he thought about in a fantasy type way, didn't plan anything and fantasy became reality and then sloppy scrambling.

I want to know what parts of the lie detector test he failed.

He started something that he didnt want to finish but knew he had too

 

[puakenikeni]

Do we know who is testifying after Adam answers jury questions?

 

[heartgoesout]

cricket... cricket...
:desert:

 

[Kapua]

Do we know who is testifying after Adam answers jury questions?

Carlos Young, SC's grandfather testified that SC's drove his 4Runner to work and it was NOT stuck on Hana Hwy. on Feb. 9, 2014!

http://www.mauinews.com/page/conten...ss--Defendant-s-truck-was-at-home.html?nav=10

:happydance:

Thank you, Mr. Young, for your honesty.

 

[julieonmaui]

Help me out please on the relationship here. Is Carlos Youngs wife Stevens grandmother? Or was Mr. young married to Stevens grandmother earlier?

 

[Kapua]

Also, Trevor Pechin testified about the 4Runner:

Kula resident Trevor Pechin testified he sold the lifted 1992 Toyota 4Runner to Capobianco for $4,500 in December 2013. Pechin said he turned over the vehicle to Capobianco, who was making installment payments, with the understanding that Pechin would sign over the title once the amount was paid in full.
In March 2014, with $1,900 still owing, Pechin said he repossessed the vehicle from Capobianco, who drove it to Pechin's house. Pechin said he stored the 4Runner at his residence for "less than a week" before "the police took the vehicle for evidence."
The vehicle had been locked, except for the broken back window, which had a tarp and brick over it, Pechin said. He said items shown in a photograph of the console, including a piece of rope and red pepper spray canister, weren't his.

 

[Kapua]

Help me out please on the relationship here. Is Carlos Youngs wife Stevens grandmother? Or was Mr. young married to Stevens grandmother earlier?

Carlos Young testified that he was married to SC's grandmother, making him SC's grandfather by marriage.

 

[Kapua]

This should clear up the confusion about the "trucks".

Young, who now lives in Vermont, said Capobianco also had a white Ford Ranger; Young also had a white Ford Ranger, an extra cab model.

 

[Kapua]

Ed Feiteira, SC's mechanic also testified. He said that a loose auxiliary wire would not affect the 4Runner's ability to start and wouldn't cause stalling.

At this point, the prosecution has thoroughly disproven SC's alibi. IMHO. :cow:

(Can you believe they had THREE witnesses yesterday?)

 

[Mamamerced]

Grandpa did say SC was home by 11:00 or 11:30..........0n Sat., Feb. 8.

 

[PeterTosh]

Carlos Young, SC's grandfather testified that SC's drove his 4Runner to work and it was NOT stuck on Hana Hwy. on Feb. 9, 2014!

http://www.mauinews.com/page/conten...ss--Defendant-s-truck-was-at-home.html?nav=10

:happydance:

Thank you, Mr. Young, for your honesty.

Yep. Saw that. Tough to do I imagine. No doubt which truck SC drove to work. His 4runner. Boom goes the dynamite.

 

[heartgoesout]

Mr. Young's testimony is huge. Almost the most relevant so far.
That must have been hard for him to do. Wonder if the grandmother will testify to what she did or didn't see.

 

[Nikki Lisette]

SC's grandmother is not on the witness list.

 

[Kapua]

I am certain that it was difficult for everyone who knew Charli and SC to deal with the fact that she was brutally murdered and also to deal with the realization that SC was the last to see her and was lying and being evasive.

The grandfather was dealing with a sick wife, caring for an infant granddaughter at night, and then he had the police knocking at his door in the morning on 2/11. I was really curious as to what he would say with regard to SC's whereabouts on 2/8 and 2/9. I can totally understand how he might not remember exactly what time SC arrived home on 2/9. He must have been exhausted from waking up at all hours to care for the baby. But he came through and validated the fact that the 4Runner was not in Keanae, so now the jury has Kurt Kaiser AND SC's grandfather's word against SC's, plus Taylor's testimony that SC would not, and did not leave a vehicle on the side of the road when his other truck broke down previously.

Notice how SC is not pitching in to take care of the baby.

I sure wish they would have live-streamed Monday's testimony.

 

[Nikki Lisette]

It's a lot of lying for an innocent man. Innocent until proven guilty... that is.

 

[Kapua]

There was a piece of rope and an a red pepper spray canister in SC's vehicle when Trevor Pechin repossessed it from SC. Hmmm.