GUILTY HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*

New Posts

  • #161
Case Parties
Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID Name / Aliases
706 01/13/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: N. CHEANG 9:02 AM COURTROOM DECORUM GIVEN BY THE CT. 9:04 AM JURY PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. 9:06 AM CHRISTOPHER INOUE WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 9:17 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 9:18 AM BRIDIE FARLEY WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 9:24 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 440-450 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 9:27 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 467 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 9:29 AM ERIN MIRANDA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 9:33 AM CT QUALIFIED WITNESS AS AN EXPERT IN THE FIELD OF SEROLOGY AND FORENSIC DNA. 10:30 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 10:46 AM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT; CROSS EXAMINATION OF ERIN MIRANDA. 10:55 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 10:57 AM DR. CHRISTOPHER HAPPY WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:05 AM CT QUALIFIED WITNESS AS AN EXPERT IN THE FIELD OF MEDICINE WITH A SPECIALTY IN FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND NEURO PATHOLOGY. 11:17 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 407-439 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 11:24 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 13 & 14 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. STATE'S EXHIBITS 7-12 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 11:57 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 11:59 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. CT ORDERED THE JURY TO RETURN AT 1:00 PM. 12:00 PM CT IN RECESS. ********** 1:31 PM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 1:33 PM KEVIN EMERY WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 1:48 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 1:55 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED; CT IN RECESS. ********** 2:06 PM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 2:07 PM M.E. WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 2:21 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 2:32 PM REDIRECT. TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. CT IN RECESS. ********** 2:51 PM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 2:52 PM DET. TY NGUYEN WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:03 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:05 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:06 PM CPT. SANDI FUJITANI-AWAYA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:09 PM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 3:18 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 478 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 3:20 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 480 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 3:39 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:44 PM REDIRECT. 3:45 PM RECROSS; TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:46 PM STATE RESTED. CT ORDERED THE JURY TO RETURN ON TUESDAY AT 9:30 AM. 3:47 PM CT IN RECESS. ********** 3:53 PM CT RECONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT. DEFENSE MADE AN ORAL M/JA; ARGUMENTS HAD BY COUNSEL. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AND DENIED. 3:55 PM CT ADJOURNED.
Stephen Brown

DPA Bell, Scott
CA Bagasol, William
CLK Ching, Stefanie
JUDG Somerville , Rowena

707 01/16/2023 document purchase Jury Instructions-Deft
EFile Document upload of type Jury Instructions-Deft
Stephen Brown
Brown, Stephen

708 01/16/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

710 01/16/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown



Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/17/2023 09:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/13/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena CON-Continued

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #162
Tuesday, January 17th:
*Trial continues (Day 5) (@ 8:30am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection & ended 1/9/23. Trial began on 1/9/23. Prosecutors rested their case on 1/13/23. Defense will start their case on 1/17/23.
Count 7 Criminal Prop Damage IV-Knowingly damages; severity: PM - Petty Misdemeanor. Plead No Contest on 1/9/23. Judge takes plea as guilty. Sentencing hearing on 4/26/23 @ 1pm.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-5 (1/3 to 1/9/23) & Trial Day 1-3 (1/9-1/12/23) reference post #156 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-8
1/13/23 Tuesday, Trial Day 4: State witnesses: former Honolulu Medical Examiner Dr. Christopher Happy. Makana Boinville Emery, Telma's daughter. Kevin Emery, Telma's husband. Wrapping up their case, prosecutors showed surveillance from the Mililani Walmart store. It showed Dandurand buying an untraceable mobile phone, apparently still thinking they would somehow escape the crowd of police & civilians that waited for them outside. The prosecutor rested his case at the end of the day. The defense will start calling witnesses on Tuesday, 1/17/23.
For more info see posts #159 & 160 (articles) here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-8
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #163
Case Parties
Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID Name / Aliases
712 01/17/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

713 01/17/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: H. HO 9:26 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. DEFENSE RENEWED ITS EARLIER M/JA AND PRESENTED FURTHER ARGUMENTS. STATE OBJECTED AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AND DENIED. 9:31 AM DEFENSE UPDATED T HE CT RE WITNESS STATUS OF DR. BLINDER AND ARGUED OFFER OF PROOF OF TESTIMONY. STATE OBJECTED AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT STATED IT PREVIOUSLY FILED ITS ORDER RE TESTIMONY OF DR. BLINDER, MADE ITS FINDINGS AND DENIED POSTPONING TESTIMONY. CT STATED IT WOULD ALLOW DR. BLINDER TO TESTIFY AT M/EXTENDED SENTENCING IF AND WHEN THAT TIME COMES AND NEEDED TO BE PRESENT BY 1/23/23 IF ANYTHING. 9:40 AM CT ADMINISTERED TACHIBANA COLLOQUY. DEFENDANT ACKNOWLEDGED HIS UNDERSTANDING AND STATED IT WAS HIS WISH TO TESTIFY. 9:43 AM JURY PRESENT. 9:44 AM STEPHEN BROWN WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 10:17 AM CROSS EXAMINATION.
Stephen Brown
DPA Bell, Scott Kamakea
CA Bagasol, William C.
DFT Brown, Stephen
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie


Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/19/2023 09:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/17/2023 09:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #164
www.staradvertiser.com

Defendant testifies in North Shore murder trial

The defense in a North Shore murder case presented its case this morning with just one witness — the defendant himself — accused of killing and kidnapping 51-year-old Telma Boinville and kidnapping her 8-year-old daughter in 2017.
www.staradvertiser.com www.staradvertiser.com

Jan. 17, 2023

The defense in a North Shore murder case presented its case this morning with just one witness — the defendant himself — accused of killing and kidnapping 51-year-old Telma Boinville and kidnapping her 8-year-old daughter in 2017.

Stephen Brown testified that it was his then-girlfriend, Hailey Dandurand, then 20 years old, who killed Boinville Dec. 7, 2017, although he admitted to helping with tying up both mother and daughter.

He said Boinville confronted the pair, who broke into an unoccupied vacation rental, and that when Dandurand told her to lie on the floor, she complied and he helped tie her up with rope from their camping gear.


a bit more in article.
 
  • #165
Thursday, January 19th:
*Trial continues (Day 6) (@ 8:30am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection & ended 1/9/23. Trial began on 1/9/23. Prosecutors rested their case on 1/13/23. Defense will start their case on 1/17/23.
Count 7 Criminal Prop Damage IV-Knowingly damages; severity: PM - Petty Misdemeanor. Plead No Contest on 1/9/23. Judge takes plea as guilty. Sentencing hearing on 4/26/23 @ 1pm.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-5 (1/3 to 1/9/23) & Trial Day 1-4 (1/9-1/13/23) reference post #162 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-9
1/17/23 Tuesday, Trial Day 5: Court convened without jury present; Defense renewed its earlier motion/JA & presented further arguments. State objected & presented argument. Court made its findings & denied. Defense updated the Court re witness status of Dr. Blinder & argued offer of proof of testimony. State object & presented argument. Court stated it previously filed its Order re testimony of Dr. Blinder, made its findings & denied postponing testimony. Court stated it would allow Dr. Blinder to testify at Motion extended sentencing if & when that time comes & needed to be present by 1/23/23 if anything. Defefendant acknowledged his understanding & stated it was his wish to testify. Jury present.
Defense Witness: Stephen Brown.
for more info see posts #163 & 164 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-9
Trial continues on Thursday, 1/19/23.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #166
Case Parties
Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID Name / Aliases
717 01/19/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: L. KAMALANI-MOE 8:21 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. 8:22 AM FURTHER SETTLEMENT OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS. 8:27 AM DEFENDANT PLACED ON RECORD ISSUE OF THROWING KNIVES. ARGUMENTS HAD BY COUNSEL. CT INSTRUCTED DEFENSE TO REMOVE SLIDE. 8:38 AM DISCUSSION HAD RE CLOSING ARGUMENTS. 8:39 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 9:07 AM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 9:09 AM STATE NOTED NO REBUTTAL WITNESSES. CTS INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY. 10:00 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 10:20 AM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 10:23 AM STATE'S CLOSING ARGUMENTS. 11:07 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 11:23 AM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 11:24 AM DEFENSE'S CLOSING ARGUMENTS. 12:20 PM STATE'S REBUTTAL. 12:33 PM BAILIFF OATH ADMINISTERED. 12:34 PM CTS FURTHER INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY RE DELIBERATIONS. JURY RELEASED FOR LUNCH AND ORDERED TO RETURN AT 1:30 PM. 12:37 PM CT THANKED ALTERNATE JURORS AND INFORMED THEM OF BEING ON STANDBY STATUS. 12:39 PM CT IN RECESS. **********
Stephen Brown

DPA Bell, Scott Kamakea
CA Bagasol, William C.
DFT Brown, Stephen
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie


Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/20/2023 09:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/19/2023 09:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #167
www.staradvertiser.com

Jury deliberation begins in North Shore murder trial

A Circuit Court jury of 12 began deliberating this afternoon as to whether the then green-haired 23-year-old Stephen Brown killed Telma Boinville, 51, on Dec. 7, 2017.
www.staradvertiser.com www.staradvertiser.com

Jan. 19, 2023
A Circuit Court jury of 12 began deliberating this afternoon as to whether the then green-haired 23-year-old Stephen Brown killed Telma Boinville, 51, on Dec. 7, 2017.

more in article about closing arguments, etc.
 
  • #168
Friday, January 20th:
*Trial continues (Day 7)-VERDICT WATCH! (@ 9am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection & ended 1/9/23. Trial began on 1/9/23. Prosecutors rested their case on 1/13/23. Defense will start their case on 1/17/23 & rested on 1/17/23. Closing arguments done on 1/19/23 & Jury began deliberations on 1/19/23. Total deliberations: 1/19: 1:30pm to 4:30pm = ~3 hours.
Count 7 Criminal Prop Damage IV-Knowingly damages; severity: PM - Petty Misdemeanor. Plead No Contest on 1/9/23. Judge takes plea as guilty. Sentencing hearing on 4/26/23 @ 1pm.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-5 (1/3 to 1/9/23) & Trial Day 1-6 (1/9-1/17/23) reference post #165 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-9
1/17/23 Addition: Tuesday Trial Day 5: Defense rested their case. Defense renewed its earlier Motion of dismissal. Court made its findings & denied.
1/19/23 Thursday, Trial Day 6: Court convened without jury present. Further settlement of jury instructions. Defendant placed on record issue of throwing knives. Arguments had by Counsel. Court instructed defense to remove slide. Discussion had re closing arguments. Court reconvened with jury present. State noted no rebuttal witnesses. Court instructions to the jury. State's & defense's closing arguments done. State's rebuttal presented. Bailiff administered oath to jurors. Court gave further instructions to the jury re deliberations. Jury released for lunch & order to return at 1:30pm. [I shall say they deliberated until 4:30pm until I find out otherwise]
for more info see posts #166 & 167 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-9
Trial continues with jury deliberations on Friday, 1/20/23 @ 9am.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #169
  • #170
www.khon2.com

Brown guilty of all charges in 2017 North Shore murder trial

Stephen Brown has been found guilty of all charges in the 2017 murder case of North Shore mother Telma Boinville.
www.khon2.com www.khon2.com

Jan. 20, 2023

HONOLULU (KHON2) — Stephen Brown was found guilty of all charges in the brutal 2017 killing of North Shore mother Telma Boinville and the kidnapping of her then 8-year-old daughter.

After deliberating for less than a day, the jury in the murder trial of Brown handed down its verdict on Friday, Jan. 20.

Brown was found guilty of murder in the second degree, two counts of kidnapping and burglary in the first degree.



It does not have a sentencing date - and the court site is down for maintenance right now - so will check on this later.
 
  • #171
  • #172
Maintenance finished...

Case Parties
Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID Name / Aliases
731 01/19/2023 document purchase Jury Instructions Read
SUPPLEMENTAL INSTRUCTIONS
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
732 01/19/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

733 01/19/2023 document purchase Jury Instructions Jury Delib
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
734 01/19/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

735 01/19/2023 document purchase Jury Communication
JURY COMMUNICATION #1
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
736 01/19/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

737 01/19/2023 document purchase Jury Communication
JURY COMMUNICATION #2
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
738 01/19/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

718 01/20/2023 document purchase Order
ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT STEPHEN BROWN'S SECOND ORAL MOTION FOR JUDGMENT OF ACQUITTAL
Stephen Brown
Bell, Scott Kamakea
719 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

720 01/20/2023 document purchase Order
ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT STEPHEN BROWN'S FIRST ORAL MOTION FOR JUDGMENT OF ACQUITTAL
Stephen Brown
Bell, Scott Kamakea
721 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

728 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Correction
/* Docket code JIR was deleted on 01/20/2023 by userid J1CTSCHING as a result of Clerical / Data Entry Correction */
Stephen Brown

739 01/20/2023 document purchase Jury Communication
JURY COMMUNICATION #3
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
740 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

741 01/20/2023 document purchase Verdict
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
742 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

743 01/20/2023 document purchase Other
SPECIAL INTERROGATORY 1
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
744 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

745 01/20/2023 document purchase Other
SPECIAL INTERROGATORY 2
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
746 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

747 01/20/2023 document purchase Other
SPECIAL INTERROGATORY 3
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
748 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

749 01/20/2023 document purchase Memorandum in Opposition
EFile Document upload of type Memorandum in Opposition
Stephen Brown
C&C Honolulu Prosecutors-CAREER CRIMINAL DIV.
750 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

751 01/20/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: J. MIYASATO 10:56 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. JURY COMMUNICATION PLACED ON THE RECORD. 11:00 AM JURY PRESENT. FOREPERSON STATED THE JURY REACHED A UNANIMOUS VERDICT AND HANDED SAME TO BAILIFF. 11:02 AM VERDICT READ. DEFENDANT FOUND GUILTY AS CHARGED IN ALL COUNTS. SPECIAL INTERROGATORIES 1-3 READ. 11:06 AM JURY POLLED; VERDICT UNANIMOUS. CT ADJUDGED DEFENDANT GUILTY AS CHARGED IN ALL COUNTS. 11:07 AM CTS INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY RE EXTENDED TERM SENTENCING AND ORDERED THEM TO RETURN ON MONDAY AT 9:00 AM. 11:09 AM JURY EXCUSED. 11:10 AM DEFENSE REQUESTED HEARING ON THURSDAY RATHER THAN MONDAY DUE TO WITNESS. STATE OBJECTED AND NOTED READY TO PROCEED. CT STATED THAT ON 1/17/23, IT ORDERED THE WITNESS TO BE AVAILABLE AND READY ON 1/23/23 FOR THIS HEARING AND DENIED REQUEST TO CONTINUE. 11:12 AM STATE REQUESTED DEFENDANT BE COMMITTED WITHOUT BAIL PENDING SENTENCING AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. DEFENSE OBJECTED AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT GRANTED AND WILL COMMIT DEFENDANT WITHOUT BAIL. STATE TO PREPARE ORDER. DEFENSE WAIVED SIGNATURE. 11:13 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 2:12 PM CT RECONVENED W/OUT JURY OR DEFENDANT PRESENT. DEFENSE INFORMED THE CT THAT DEFENDANT WAIVES HIS PRESENCE FOR THIS AFTERNOON. CT WAIVED DEFENDANT'S PRESENCE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS HEARING. 2:13 PM ARGUMENTS HAD RE DEFENSE'S MIL #5. 2:27 PM SETTLEMENT OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS. 2:42 PM DEFENSE REQUESTED WITNESSES BE ABLE TO TESTIFY VIA ZOOM. ARGUMENTS HAD RE SCOPE OF TESTIMONY. CT RESERVED RULING ON RELIGIOUS VIEWS AND NO DISCUSSION TO BE HAD RE PAROLING AUTHORITY. DEFENSE REQUESTED CONSECUTIVE INSTRUCTION. CT DENIED. 3:01 PM CT ADJOURNED.
Stephen Brown

CA Bagasol, William
DPA Bell, Scott
DFT Brown, Stephen
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie
752 01/20/2023 document purchase Order Pertaining to Bail
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
753 01/20/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown



Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Hearing Stephen Brown
01/23/2023 09:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/20/2023 09:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena GLT-GLT

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #173
Monday, January 23rd:
*Sentencing Hearing (@ 9am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M. After guilty verdict will be held without bond.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection & ended 1/9/23. Trial began on 1/9/23. Prosecutors rested their case on 1/13/23. Defense will start their case on 1/17/23 & rested on 1/17/23. Closing arguments done on 1/19/23 & Jury began deliberations on 1/19/23. Total deliberations: 1/19: 1:30pm to 4:30pm = ~3 hours. 1/20: 9am-11am = ~2 hours. Total Deliberations: ~5 hours. Trial ended with a guilty verdict on 1/20/23. Sentencing phase starts on 1/23/23.
Count 7 Criminal Prop Damage IV-Knowingly damages; severity: PM - Petty Misdemeanor. Plead No Contest on 1/9/23. Judge takes plea as guilty. Sentencing hearing on 4/26/23 @ 1pm.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-5 (1/3 to 1/9/23) & Trial Day 1-6 (1/9-1/19/23) & Jury Deliberations Day 1 (1/19/23) reference post #168 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-9
1/20/23 Friday, Trial Day 8/Jury Deliberations Day 1: Jury deliberated from 9am to 11am. After deliberating for less than a day the jury in the murder trial of Brown handed down its verdict on Friday, Jan. 20. Brown was found guilty of murder in the 2nd degree, 2 counts of kidnapping & burglary in the 1st degree. State requested defendant be committed without bail pending sentencing & presented argument. Defense objected & presented argument. Court granted & will commit defendant without bail.
for more info see post #170 (article) here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-9
Sentencing phase will continue on Monday, 1/23/23.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #174
Case Parties
Seq # Expn Date Type ID Name / Aliases
754 01/22/2023 document purchase Jury Instructions-Deft
EFile Document upload of type Jury Instructions-Deft
Stephen Brown
Bagasol, William C.
755 01/22/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

756 01/23/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: S. YOU 9:06 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. CT STATED IT WAS IN RECEIPT OF DEFENSE'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND THAT IT HAD PREVIOUSLY RULED UPON BUT WILL ALLOW DEFENSE TO MAKE ITS RECORD. DEFENSE PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT DENIED. STATE TO PREPARE ORDER. DEFENSE WAIVED SIGNATURE. 9:12 AM DISCUSSION RE RELIGIOUS BELIEFS. STATE REQUESTED CLARIFICATION OF DEFENSE'S DEFENSE RE "DANGEROUSNESS". CT STATED IT WILL CATEGORIZE AS SENTENCING HEARING BUT STILL SUBJECT TO THE RELEVANCY PROVISIONS AND WILL ALLOW WITNESS TO GET INTO IT. DEFENSE INFORMED THE CT WHAT DR. BLINDER WAS INSTRUCTED NOT TO OPINE TO. STATE PRESENTED BRIEF ARGUMENT AND REQUESTED THE CT REJECT OPEN DOOR. 9:19 AM DISCUSSION RE EXHIBIT LISTS AND EXHIBITS. 9:23 AM JURY PRESENT. CTS INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY RE EXTENDED TERM SENTENCING. 9:25 AM STATE'S OPENING STATEMENTS. 9:27 AM DEFENSE'S OPENING STATEMENTS. 9:28 AM STATE REQUESTED THE CT RECEIVE ITS EXHIBITS AND HAD NOTHING FURTHER TO PRESENT. STATE'S EXHIBITS 1-4 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 9:30 AM DR. MARTIN BLINDER WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 9:45 AM CT QUALIFIED WITNESS TO TESTIFY AS AN EXPERT IN THE FIELD OF FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY. 9:46 AM STATE STIPULATED TO IDENTIFICATION OF DEFENDANT. 10:02 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 10:27 AM REDIRECT. 10:31 AM JURY EXCUSED. 10:33 AM ARGUMENTS HAD RE TESTIMONY. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AS TO WHAT DR. BLINDER CAN TESTIFY TO AND WILL STRIKE PORTION FROM THE RECORD. 10:43 AM JURY PRESENT. CT INSTRUCTED THE JURY TO DISREGARD STATE'S PREVIOUS STATEMENT. 10:44 AM CONT. OF REDIRECT. 10:47 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 10:49 AM DEFENSE STATED NO OTHER WITNESSES. STATE HAD NO REBUTTAL. JURY EXCUSED. 10:50 AM CT ADMINISTERED TACHIBANA COLLOQUY. DEFENDANT ACKNOWLEDGED HIS UNDERSTANDING AND STATED HIS DECISION NOT TO TESTIFY. CT FINDS DEFENDANT KNOWINGLY, INTELLIGENTLY AND VOLUNTARILY WAIVED HIS RIGHT TO TESTIFY. 10:51 AM FURTHER DISCUSSION RE JURY INSTRUCTIONS. 10:54 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 11:28 AM CT RECONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT. DEFENSE RAISED INSTITUTIONAL BEHAVIOR. ARGUMENTS HAD BY COUNSEL. 11:34 AM DEFENSE STATED DEFENDANT WILL NOT TESTIFY. CT COLLOQUY DEFENDANT. DEFENDANT ACKNOWLEDGED HIS UNDERSTANDING AND STATED HIS DECISION NOT TO TESTIFY. CT FINDS DEFENDANT KNOWINGLY, INTELLIGENTLY AND VOLUNTARILY WAIVED HIS RIGHT TO TESTIFY. 11:35 AM JURY PRESENT. 11:36 AM CTS INSTRUCTION TO THE JURY. 11:56 AM STATE'S CLOSING ARGUMENTS. 12:06 AM DEFENSE'S CLOSING ARGUMENTS. 12:24 PM STATE'S REBUTTAL. 12:28 PM BAILIFF OATH ADMINISTERED.
Stephen Brown

DPA Bell, Scott
CA Bagasol, William
DFT Brown, Stephen
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie


Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/24/2023 09:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing Stephen Brown
01/23/2023 09:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #175
Tuesday, January 24th:
*Sentencing Hearing continues (Day 2) (@ 9am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M. After guilty verdict will be held without bond.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection & ended 1/9/23. Trial began on 1/9/23. Prosecutors rested their case on 1/13/23. Defense will start their case on 1/17/23 & rested on 1/17/23. Closing arguments done on 1/19/23 & Jury began deliberations on 1/19/23. Total deliberations: 1/19: 1:30pm to 4:30pm = ~3 hours. 1/20: 9am-11am = ~2 hours. Total Deliberations: ~5 hours. Trial ended with a guilty verdict on 1/20/23. Sentencing phase Day 1 (1/23/23) ~12:30pm to 5pm (1 hour lunch?); Total Deliberations: ~3 1/2 hours.
Count 7 Criminal Prop Damage IV-Knowingly damages; severity: PM - Petty Misdemeanor. Plead No Contest on 1/9/23. Judge takes plea as guilty. Sentencing hearing on 4/26/23 @ 1pm.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-5 (1/3 to 1/9/23) & Trial Day 1-6 (1/9-1/19/23) & Jury Deliberations Days 1-2 (1/19-1/20/23) reference post #173 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-9
1/23/23 Monday, Sentencing Phase Day 1: Court convened without jury present. Appearances were entered by Counsel & defendant in custody. Court state it was in receipt of defense's proposed jury instructions & that it had previously ruled upon but will allow defense to make its record. Defense presented argument. Court denied. State to prepare Order. Defense waived signature. Discussion re religious beliefs. State requested clarification of Defense's re "dangerousness". Court state it will categorize as sentencing hearing but still subject to the relevancy provisions & will allow witness to get into it. Defense informed the Court what Dr. Blinder was instructed not to opine to. State presented brief argument & requested the Court reject open door. Discussion re exhibit lists & exhibits. Jury now present. Court's instructions to the jury re extended term sentencing. State's & Defense's opening statements made. State's exhibits 1-4 were marked & received into evidence. Dr. Martin Blinder was sworn in. Court qualified witness to testify as an expert in the field of forensic psychology. State stipulated to ID of defendant. Cross examination & redirect. Jury was excused. Arguments had re testimony. Court made its findings as to what Dr. Blinder can testify to & will strike portion from the record. Jury present. Court instructed the jury to disregard State's previous statement & redirect continued. Testimony concluded. Defense stated no other witnesses. State had no rebuttal. Jury excused. Court administered Tachibana colloquy. Defendant acknowledged his understanding & stated his decision not to testify. Court finds defendant knowingly, intelligently & voluntarily waived his right to testify. Further discussion re jury instructions. Defense raised institutional behavior. Arguments had by Counsel. Defense stated defendant will not testify. Jury present. Court's instructions to jury. State's & defense's closing arguments done. State's rebuttal. Bailiff oath administered to jury. At about 12:30pm Jury started deliberations on sentencing phase.
for more info see post #174 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-9
Sentencing phase jury deliberations continues on Tuesday, 1/24/23.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #176
From yesterday, Monday on closing arguments.

www.hawaiinewsnow.com

In sentencing hearing, attorney tells jury that North Shore killer is a changed man

A jury is now deciding whether North Shore killer Stephen Brown will spend the rest of his life in prison or will get a chance of parole.
www.hawaiinewsnow.com www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Jan. 24, 2023

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - A jury is now deciding whether North Shore killer Stephen Brown will spend the rest of his life in prison or will get a chance of parole.

The jury last week found Brown guilty in the brutal murder of Telma Boinville.

His attorney says he’s a changed man and has become a born-again Christian.
[.....]
But prosecutors say he’s still a danger to the public and should remain locked up.

“Surely whatever religious beliefs he now subscribes to were absent the day he buried a machete in Telma’s skull,” said Deputy Prosecutor Scott Bell.

The jury will continue deliberating Tuesday [1/24/23].
 
  • #177
The court site is down right now - but found an article for Tuesday's deliberations.

www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Judge to decide whether North Shore killer will ever be eligible for parole

On Tuesday, a jury ruled the extended sentence should be considered in the case.
www.hawaiinewsnow.com www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Jan. 24, 2023
HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - A judge will decide in May whether North Shore killer Stephen Brown should spent the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of parole.

On Tuesday, a jury ruled the extended sentence should be considered in the case, saying he posed a continued risk to the public.

The 28-year-old Brown showed little emotion as the verdict was read.
[.....]
Brown will be back in court on May 10.
 
  • #178
Niner said:
The court site is down right now - but found an article for Tuesday's deliberations.

www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Judge to decide whether North Shore killer will ever be eligible for parole

On Tuesday, a jury ruled the extended sentence should be considered in the case.
www.hawaiinewsnow.com www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Jan. 24, 2023
HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - A judge will decide in May whether North Shore killer Stephen Brown should spent the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of parole.

On Tuesday, a jury ruled the extended sentence should be considered in the case, saying he posed a continued risk to the public.

The 28-year-old Brown showed little emotion as the verdict was read.
[.....]
Brown will be back in court on May 10.
Click to expand...
You are a national treasure for keeping this so up to date. Thank you so so much I really appreciate it.
 
  • #179
Docket update:

Case Parties
Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID Name / Aliases
760 01/23/2023 document purchase Jury Instructions-Deft
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
761 01/23/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

765 01/23/2023 document purchase Jury Communication
JURY COMMUNICATION #4
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
766 01/23/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

767 01/23/2023 document purchase Jury Communication
JURY COMMUNICATION #5
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
768 01/23/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

769 01/23/2023 document purchase Jury Communication
JURY COMMUNICATION #6
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
770 01/23/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

771 01/23/2023 document purchase Jury Communication
JURY COMMUNICATION #7
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
772 01/23/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

757 01/24/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: S. YOU 11:49 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. 11:50 AM JURY COMMUNICATION #7 PLACED ON THE RECORD. 11:53 AM JURY PRESENT. 11:54 AM FOREPERSON STATED THE JURY REACHED UNANIMOUS DECISION AND HANDED STIPULATIONS TO BAILIFF. 11:55 AM STIPULATIONS READ. 11:58 AM JURY POLLED; UNANIMOUS DECISION. CT SCHEDULED SENTENCING FOR 5/10/23 AT 1:30 PM. 11:59 AM CT ADJOURNED.
Stephen Brown

DPA Bell, Scott Kamakea
CA Bagasol, William C.
DFT Brown, Stephen
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie
773 01/24/2023 document purchase Other
SPECIAL INTERROGATORY 4
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
774 01/24/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

778 01/24/2023 document purchase Other
SPECIAL INTERROGATORY 5
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
779 01/24/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

780 01/24/2023 document purchase Other
SPECIAL INTERROGATORY 6
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
781 01/24/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

782 01/24/2023 document purchase Other
SPECIAL INTERROGATORY 7
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
783 01/24/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

763 01/25/2023 Pre-Sent Investigation Ordere
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
764 01/25/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

775 01/25/2023 Docket Deleted
SPECIAL INTERROGATORY 5 /* Docket code OT was deleted on 01/25/2023 by userid J1CTSCHING as a result of Clerical / Data Entry Correction */
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
776 01/25/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

777 01/25/2023 document purchase Notice of Correction
/* Docket code OT was deleted on 01/25/2023 by userid J1CTSCHING as a result of Clerical / Data Entry Correction */
Stephen Brown

784 01/25/2023 document purchase Request for Transcript
EFile Document upload of type Request for Transcript
Stephen Brown
Brown, Stephen
785 01/25/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

786 01/25/2023 document purchase Request for Transcript
EFile Document upload of type Request for Transcript
Stephen Brown
Brown, Stephen
787 01/25/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

762 04/26/2023 Minutes
OFF/RSC TO 5/10/23 AT 1:30 PM
Stephen Brown



Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Sentencing Stephen Brown
05/10/2023 13:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena


Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Trial Hailey Dandurand
07/10/2023 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call Hailey Dandurand
06/27/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena



link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #180
Looks like Brown's sentencing was put off until Hailey's trial ends...

Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Sentencing Stephen Brown
08/30/2023 13:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Hailey Dandurand
07/10/2023 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call Hailey Dandurand
06/27/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Hailey Dandurand
05/16/2023 10:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Hailey Dandurand
05/10/2023 13:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena RSC-Rescheduled

Sentencing Stephen Brown
05/10/2023 13:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena RSC-Rescheduled


link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/PartyNameSearch.iface
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 110 more.
Total: 2,169 (members: 111, guests: 2,058)

Online statistics

Members online
111
Guests online
2,058
Total visitors
2,169
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
632,764
Messages
18,631,464
Members
243,290
Latest member
lhudson
Back
Top