- Joined
- Mar 4, 2018
- Messages
- 30,633
- Reaction score
- 731,220
Now or several years from now, when US losses would be catastrophic. It's pretty clear that Iran had no intention of agreeing to anything remotely palatable, and my concern was that the US would settle for something like that past deal.Snipped by me for focus,
This much seems reasonable to me. It doesn't seem to have such political Trump-focused aims. It doesn't even mention regime change, though I think that is a reasonable part of the aims inasmuch as it's the choices of the current regime, their decisions to facilitate terrorism that have made their country a target.
I'm trying to sort of ignore the lousy messaging coming from the president and the politics of him and his administration and look at it purely from the perspective of perceiving what Hegseth has said here to be the main goals of the operation/war. And in this sense I would see all the years through different presidents and administrations as attempts to avoid this, but with the actions of Iran and their subsidiary terrorist groups over the past 2 years or so, I can see that it's reached a point where Iran can't be trusted to stop supporting terrorist groups, and I can agree that waiting until after they have working nukes is not the best option. Imagine an Iran that says you can't go after terrorist groups that we're supporting, because they're under our nuclear umbrella?
I don't know if better diplomacy could have changed this, I only see that it hasn't.
You do not mention "regime change" as one of the goals, as we all know how that has gone in the past. Yes, it would be wonderful if the regime did fall, but that's incredibly difficult to do with an air attack and unarmed civilians kept in check by a powerful, brutal regime.
Ballistic missiles are the biggest immediate threat, as if you have enough of them you can deter any further attacks on your nuclear ambitions.
Take them out. Take out the launchers. Take out the generals in charge. Kill the leadership. Hit those nuclear sites again if necessary.
Hopefully you set the conditions for a better deal down the road.
The ability to strike Iran like this was a pipe dream just a year ago (It's beyond a logistical nightmare, air defenses aside). The 12 Day War was proof of concept that this could be done, and those air defenses are really close to not existing at all.
This is the best shot you will EVER have - perhaps the last one.
Last edited: