Judge's Order re: OP's Mental Health Eval

Status
Not open for further replies.
Did that person ever come back to the board that had worked with Nel and Roux?

are you referring to the pathologist bloke, Reggie Pheremul?? if so, no. he didn't. if not, disregard my post!!


no.. I just remembered who you meant. BarnacleZA. no he hasn't. he was hounded out by a poster who was convinced he was someone else, and kept on about it.
 
Apologies for this OT post, but just while it's quiet and for the very few Aussies here, have you been reading about the trial re the Lin family massacre in North Epping that occurred in 2009. One of the worst multiple homicides in NSW history. It was just a couple of doors down the street where my parents lived. My dad bought his daily newspaper from Mr Lin.

OMG! What an absolute shocking tragedy. One by one slaughtered. :(

So much to that story as well, I will definitely keep an eye on that case.
 
are you referring to the pathologist bloke, Reggie Pheremul?? if so, no. he didn't. if not, disregard my post!!

I don't remember his name. He had the big red glowy dot as his moniker.


YES (seeing your added post) him ! Oh well. Thanks !! (BarnacleZA)
 
Thanks.

I asked Gryffindor (twice) to provide a link to a similar case to OP's (partner shot dead in toilet when they were the only other person in the house) in which the killer didn't get prosecuted.

She wasn't able to.
I've seen other cases referenced that weren't prosecuted but the only common thread was that family members were mistaken as intruders. The comparison ends there. In none of the cases I've seen were there allegations of an argument or witness testimony to screaming heard. Some have varying shots, but most often one, and no one sat holding their loved ones for several minutes before calling a friend prior to calling for emergency services. ;)

JMO
 
The witnesses said they heard a woman screaming. No one ever identified Reeva. In fact, didn't one ear witness say she heard the screams coming from the street?

I am not convinced that most of the ear witness testimony is accurate and reliable. Ms Burger heard screams fade out after the last shot. I don't need to comment on that unlikelihood or impossibility of that. Her husband's testimony was not so convincing either and seemed hostile and confused.

The Stipps are another matter, but Mrs. Stipp heard gunshots at 3:02am with a clock 3-4 minutes fast. The defense's ballistic and sound "experts" imo, were worse than useless and didn't shed any light on anything for me. I don't know when bat sounds could ever be mistaken for gunshots, no matter who is testifying.

That leaves me with many questions. When someone's life or freedom is on the line, I believe that all important questions and discrepancies need to be answered. I find a lot in this case, although many don't. I wish someone could adequately explain the many unanswered questions and perhaps some view points might change.

The post up thread by FromGermany further convinces me that OP's psychological problems run far deeper than we know. Does this excuse him? No. It may explain some of his actions that are incomprehensible to those of us who are not disabled, and do not live in one of the most violent and crime-ridden countries in the world.

The witnesses said they heard a woman screaming. No one ever identified Reeva. In fact, didn't one ear witness say she heard the screams coming from the street?

The chances of the woman's screams, at that time of night on that very day, being someone rather than Reeva run into the millions to one category............it's that unreasonably improbable as to be totally impossible:)
 
It is also very odd that he claims to know nothing, and that he heard nothing. If he truly 'heard nothing', wouldn't that be helpful for OP? Why wouldn't Frank come forward to say that he heard nothing that evening? Maybe because that is not possible? We know he got dressed and went out front right at the time that security was arriving. So he had to know something was going on.

It is possible that Frank is an 'illegal'....just sayin'...
 
Thanks, zwiebel!

*Good morning, everyone from Louisiana!
Does anyone know how long court might last this morning? TIA!

Because I never claimed to be Mother Theresa, I am hoping the white cart pulls up and Oscar is dragged howling into it without any farewells at all.. .but.... I suspect it will be short, unless, there is argument... then it will be long!.
 
Barry Bateman ‏@barrybateman 2m

#OscarTrial it appears counsel are in chambers. The order is likely being discussed before Masipa makes it an order of the court. BB
 
It is possible that Frank is an 'illegal'....just sayin'...

Thank you Zim. I've wondered about this and also the possible dynamics of a master / servant relationship. I hope I'm not overstepping the mark with my hypotheses.
 
Because I never claimed to be Mother Theresa, I am hoping the white cart pulls up and Oscar is dragged howling into it without any farewells at all.. .but.... I suspect it will be short, unless, there is argument... then it will be long!.

Thanks, Trooper.
I'm not Mother Theresa either and am right there with you!
 
Hi all. Still on the bus so looking forward to updates from you guys... Gotta know what's happening! TIA!
 
Barry Bateman ‏@barrybateman 1m

#OscarTrial Oscar is chatting to one of his attorneys, Roxanne Adams as we wait for proceedings to start. BB
 
Barry Bateman ‏@barrybateman 1m

#OscarTrial the overflow courtroom, next door to the main courtroom, has now been closed. The end is nigh. BB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
69
Guests online
834
Total visitors
903

Forum statistics

Threads
625,956
Messages
18,516,345
Members
240,905
Latest member
nexy9522
Back
Top