Malaysia Flight MH17 shot down in Ukraine. 298 aboard. 7/17/2014 - #1

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #821
Oh dear God - CNN reporting that the separatist rebels have just massacred at least 20 civilians in a town near the debris field.

You keep reporting that CNN are reporting, but provide no links. Could you please provide the links?

Was the town Lugansk/Luhansk? If so, I doubt it was the separatists. No western media is reporting this as far as I can see, but if you search twitter using 'Lugansk' it is pretty evident who is doing the bombing.

https://twitter.com/search?q=lugansk&src=typd
 
  • #822
I don't see anything like that reported by CNN.

Here it is:

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-28363086

Electricity and water supplies have been knocked out in much of the rebel-held city of Luhansk in eastern Ukraine and a major oil refinery is on fire, Russian and Ukrainian media report.

More than 20 people have died in shelling, the city council says, as Ukrainian forces fight rebels.

Correspondents say there are differing reports as to who is to blame.

There is no sign of a ceasefire in east Ukraine despite pressure for a truce after Thursday's airliner crash.

A cessation in hostilities would allow investigators access to the crash site.
 
  • #823
Well Gitana, and all others who deemed this a Usefull Post, let me put it to you like this, in the most friendly way possible:

I am a Dutch woman, living in The Netherlands. If you think that I'm in anyway impressed by an American lecturing me about my country, it's politics, leadership and the lack therof and the emotions that my countrymen and I are going through at this moment, based on something that some travellers have said to a correspondent of The Guardian, wel ..... kindly think again.

I do not demand the Dutch to react angry. I am one of the many Dutch who are angry as we speak.

"There's a particularly sobering statistic that emphasizes the magnitude of this tragedy: with the reported death count now including 189 passengers from the Netherlands, the MH17 crash has claimed the lives of a greater share of the country's population than the September 11th attacks did in the US."
http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...-295-aboard-7-17-2014&p=10763501#post10763501

Thank you.

I don't make statements lightly or without some knowledge. But since you responded twice to my post, I can see it must have been offensive. I apologize for that.

However, I won’t back off my belief that anger that the PM didn’t immediately call for blood is atypical of the Dutch character. That’s just not my experience.

And clearly, not all Dutch people feel the way you do and are enraged that the PM didn't immediately call for blood, or feel that he is in bed with Putin due to his statements:

1. Artur Laumann, 36, arrived with a bunch of tropical flowers — “for tulips aren’t appropriate’’ — to ensure one of his friends would be remembered. He placed the flowers with a picture of his colleague Wayan Sujana and a message of condolence written in Indonesian, and then acknowledged the Australian reaction to the disaster had been more in keeping with the strength of the atrocity.
“Your Prime Minister Tony Abbott has spoken in very strong language but here, we are in shock,’’ Mr Laumann said. “I think we should be as angry as Australia and I think that very soon we will see our politicians speak out loudly too.
“I haven’t slept since hearing about the plane going down and it is only now that I am starting to tremble a bit and realise what has happened.’’

2. But another Dutchman, Henri Karsten, who was checking in for a flight to New York, said: “The Dutch people are still in a state of shock.
“There is fear too about the implications of this, will this escalate into another Cold War? and well, I can only say that everyone is trembling.’’

3. Asked how they felt the Dutch government should react to the tragedy, Van den Akker said: "What happened was awful, and we are all thinking of the victims. But we are not going to call for the government to go and catch the perpetrators or go to war. We are not America."

4. An actual family member of a victim: “I expect there to be a thorough investigation by the authorities into what has happened,” Sander Essers, who lost several relatives in the crash, said in The Hague.

Mr Essers lost his brother Peter, 66, Peter’s wife Jolette Nuesink, 60, and their two children, Emma, 20, and Valentijn, 17.

(Sounds a lot like what the PM said).
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/in-...994237603?nk=5ef20e1f80d3e0fa135c41693fecce5b
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/18/dutch-travellers-react-calmly-loss-flight-mh17

5. My mom: “Volgens een opmerking van een Nederlandse schrijfster laten de Nederlanders zich zeer kritisch uit over het gedrag van Mark Rutte, na de rampzalige gebeurtenis van gisteren. Nu, ik heb gelezen wat de man heeft gezegd en vind daar niets in waarover iemand mogelijk zou vinden dat Rutte een lafaard is. Wat willen de mensen eigenlijk? Moet hij nu onmiddellijk militaire maatregelen gaan nemen? Ik kan echt niet geloven dat Nederlanders, die bekend staan als vredelievend en nadenkend, zich nu achter een vaandel van geweldadigheid willen scharen.
Ik woon nu al 55 jaar in de Verenigde Staten en heb begrijpelijk meer interesse in wat hier op politiek gebied gebeurd. Ik weet dus niet of ik voor Rutte had gestemd, als ik in Holland woonde. Evenwel is het voor mij echter op dit moment niet van veel belang of de man op politiek gebied links of rechts is. Ik reageer alleen op wat de dame in kwestie gelooft over een passende reactie. Als ik de verklaringen van Rutte ga vergelijken met de die van Bush, na 9/11, vind ik dat Rutte's toespraak op simpathiek gebied en realistisch gezien stukken beter is dan de wijze waarop Bush in 2001 reageerde. Rutte heeft duidelijk gemaakt dat maatregelen zullen worden genomen, maar dat er eerst een grondig onderzoek moet plaatsnemen. Hoe is dit fout? Moeten we nu spontaan en zonder overdenking oorlog gaan voeren? “

My initial reaction was to immediately blame Putin (I still do, BTW), to want to send him to hell (I still do) and to be scared of WWIII. I'm not a world leader, though.

And while incredible anger is totally understandable and 100% merited here, (and I do think it’s obvious this wasn’t a regular plane crash and that Russia has it's hand in what happened), I think our anger is better directed at the actual beasts who did this, not at innocent world leaders, like Rutte or Obama, who are trying to carefully respond and figure out how to address this most volatile of situations.

I thank God that the world leaders addressing this are not acting like hot heads or letting their emotions rule.

IMO, we just can't afford that.
 
  • #824
  • #825
From the twitter of Dutch journalist Saskia Dekkers:



Translation:



View attachment 55135

One picture says it all. Villains!
7eheta9e.jpg

"A cuddly toy monkey - the unpicked stitching on its nose offering evidence of just how much it had been loved by its owner - most probably belonged to one of the 80 children on board. "

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...the-gruesome-scene-for-survivors-9615895.html
 
  • #826
I was watching CNN live and that was what a correspondent on the ground was reporting to CNN.
Did they say they are driving by snd shooting in homes?
 
  • #827
You keep reporting that CNN are reporting, but provide no links. Could you please provide the links?

Was the town Lugansk/Luhansk? If so, I doubt it was the separatists. No western media is reporting this as far as I can see, but if you search twitter using 'Lugansk' it is pretty evident who is doing the bombing.

https://twitter.com/search?q=lugansk&src=typd

That's the only thing I could find as well. But it would be presumably be the Ukrainian army that killed these civilians in Lugansk, not the rebels. Is CNN now blaming the rebels for everybody who is getting killed down there?
 
  • #828
Some investigators have already made it to the crash site and the turmoil in Lugansk has been going on for a few days at least.
 
  • #829
  • #830
In case you missed it, here is the video of the militia speaking among eachother about the crash, with English translation of the transcript
Experts claim it is genuine.

[video=youtube;VnuHxAR01Jo]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VnuHxAR01Jo[/video]
 
  • #831
I'm watching CCN live via my Xfinity cable subscription, therefore, I can't provide a link. Apologies to those who have requested a link.

I'm a fan of links, as well, so that I can read/hear it myself, so I fully understand.

I'm very careful to only post information from mainstream media sources in order to avoid rumors. In my posting history here on WS, I've always been careful to post accurate information.

Anyone can choose to accept or reject anything I post.
 
  • #832
  • #833
I don't see anything like that reported by CNN.

If you turn on your t.v. to CNN or Fox either one it is all over the news. It apparently just happened a few hours ago.
 
  • #834

The last one is super pro-Russia. In response to US resistance to the takeover by Russia of Crimea, it states:
"Washington's role in Ukraine is different only in its implications for the rest of us. For the first time since the Reagan years, the US is threatening to take the world to war. With eastern Europe and the Balkans now military outposts of Nato, the last "buffer state" bordering Russia – Ukraine – is being torn apart by fascist forces unleashed by the US and the EU. We in the west are now backing neo-Nazis in a country where Ukrainian Nazis backed Hitler.

Having masterminded the coup in February against the democratically elected government in Kiev, Washington's planned seizure of Russia's historic, legitimate warm-water naval base in Crimea failed. The Russians defended themselves, as they have done against every threat and invasion from the west for almost a century."

I don;t know. I kind of think the push to "recover" territory that has high percentages of ethnic Russians is eerily similar to what Hitler did.

In any event, this attack is bringing the world into the events occurring in the Ukraine.
 
  • #835
On the ABC news last night they said that the separatists seized the Buk from the Ukraine's in the hours before the plane was shot down .. do you think I can find anything online to support that? Nope. Looking around I did find an interesting article on the Buk however, and what is likely to happen to it now, ie driven into Russia and destroyed: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...lls-claim-PROVES-Russia-shot-Flight-MH17.html

The other thing, there is a lot of talk about how this is a Russian built piece of weaponry, which is not such a big deal, since Russia's built weapons are used by everyone involved ie Russia, the Separatists, and the Ukrainians.

I'm thinking Putin is getting a bit of a bum rap .. I know he's been supporting this conflict because it suits his own agenda, but he may not have 'supplied' the rebels with this missile .. they may have stolen it from the Ukrainians.

Still catching up on todays news etc, so all of the above may be completely off the mark.
 
  • #836
From the twitter of Dutch journalist Saskia Dekkers:



Translation:



View attachment 55135

One picture says it all. Villains!

????? Context of photo may paint different stories imho

Sent from my SCH-S720C using Tapatalk 2
 
  • #837
On the ABC news last night they said that the separatists seized the Buk from the Ukraine's in the hours before the plane was shot down .. do you think I can find anything online to support that? Nope. Looking around I did find an interesting article on the Buk however, and what is likely to happen to it now, ie driven into Russia and destroyed: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...lls-claim-PROVES-Russia-shot-Flight-MH17.html

The other thing, there is a lot of talk about how this is a Russian built piece of weaponry, which is not such a big deal, since Russia's built weapons are used by everyone involved ie Russia, the Separatists, and the Ukrainians.

I'm thinking Putin is getting a bit of a bum rap .. I know he's been supporting this conflict because it suits his own agenda, but he may not have 'supplied' the rebels with this missile .. they may have stolen it from the Ukrainians.

Still catching up on todays news etc, so all of the above may be completely off the mark.

If Putin didn't supply it, there would be no reason for Russia to spirit it away and destroy it. They would want to keep the evidence.
 
  • #838
I want to ask a question, I hope it's not too insensitive to ask ... The plane was shot mid-flight and broke up. Does this mean that the cabin where crew and passengers were was destroyed and they died - or passed out - instantly from lack of pressure/oxygen? Or did they have to fall to earth in full consciousness? I just want to hope that there was not much time for fear and panic, that it was over very quickly.

My heart breaks for all these people. May they rest in peace.

Been looking at pictures of the victims here http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ck-killed-298-people-board.html#ixzz37qJPgYVo
 
  • #839
From the twitter of Dutch journalist Saskia Dekkers:



Translation:



View attachment 55135

One picture says it all. Villains!


They don't look like they're celebrating. We don't really have context for this - are they showing the plane they shot down and taking ownership, are they taking this photo to send to compatriots/Russia for an "oops" taking ownership situation, or are they taking this photo to document something that someone else did and they are horrified by it?

We don't really know.
 
  • #840
From a report this afternoon:

But a senior defense official told CNN that the "working theory" among U.S. intelligence analysts is that the Russian military supplied the Buk missile system to rebel fighters inside Ukraine.

http://www.cnn.com/2014/07/18/world/europe/ukraine-malaysia-airlines-crash/index.html

Although it hasn't been confirmed definitively, and I think President Obama and other world leaders are being cautious with their words until solid evidence is gathered, I trust that U.S. intelligence analysts have good reason to support their "working theory" that the Buk missile system was supplied to the separatists by Russia.

For obvious reasons, world leaders don't wish to enflame the situation any further by pointing the finger at Moscow right now, which I think is a wise decision given the volatile situation. It's possible that it's already been confirmed that the Buk did, indeed, come from Russia, but that information is perhaps being kept under wraps in order to give Putin an opportunity to save face so that he'll take the necessary action to de-escalate the tensions.

It's an extremely delicate situation and the last thing anybody wants is for Putin to feel that he's being backed against the wall on a world stage and accused by other heads of State.

Personally, I'll be surprised if the public ever truly learns who specifically supplied the Buk missile system to the separatists, for the reasons I mentioned above.

I think you are right and every country is doing its best not to push Putin to far but its such a balancing act. We need the hostilities to cease at the least to collect the bodies and give them back to their loved ones for burial and that will take Russia;s help. On the other hand it is outrageous and criminal that they helped a civilian jetliner be shot down and I would love to see him jailed in the Hague.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
138
Guests online
3,410
Total visitors
3,548

Forum statistics

Threads
632,568
Messages
18,628,489
Members
243,198
Latest member
Angi7275
Back
Top