Miley Cyrus Embarrassed by Vanity Fair Photo Shoot - Racy Photos

[golfmom]

I believe Golfmom's picture was of her 18 year-old daughter.

Yep, she's in college. Perhaps I've gotten too lax. I've been member of scrapbooking and photographing communities where it's common to share our artwork.

 

[Floh]

Yep, she's in college. Perhaps I've gotten too lax. I've been member of scrapbooking and photographing communities where it's common to share our artwork.

Nope. you posted a picture of your 18 year-old daughter. she's not a minor.

 

[Jade]

Does a girl become less attractive or unattractive to a pedophile once they are legal?

Apparently, yes.


I get Vanity Fair and it is trashy! More than once even I have been shocked by the content, language and the very racy ads. What were they thinking even having her appear in it in the first place?

Obviously Annie L. wanted to present different appearance of Miley. Too bad she decided to portray her looking like she just woke up after a night of drinking and sex.

IMO

 

[golfmom]

Apparently, yes.


I get Vanity Fair and it is trashy! More than once even I have been shocked by the content, language and the very racy ads. What were they thinking even having her appear in it in the first place?

Obviously Annie L. wanted to present different appearance of Miley. Too bad she decided to portray her looking like she just woke up after a night of drinking and sex.

IMO

LOL, you want to talk about a double standard ... I don't see anything dirty in the photo, but I wouldn't even let my girls read Seventeen until they were at least 17. Jeez the crap they publish in those magazines.

 

[kahskye]

Yep, she's in college. Perhaps I've gotten too lax. I've been member of scrapbooking and photographing communities where it's common to share our artwork.

She's very pretty! You are right about some of those scrapbook websites. They share tons of photos of their children.

 

[Paladin]

Huh?


We are not talking about a murderer here. We are talking about Miley Cyrus. I don't see your connection at all.

15 year old murders is tried as an adult (they made the decision, they have to live with it). 15 year old wears a bedsheet is treated as a kid (they were duped! they obviously couldn't have decided that on their own, they were tricked!).

Which is it? Doesn't get any simpler than that.

Please. 15 year olds have brains.

 

[NewMom2003]

15 year old murders is tried as an adult (they made the decision, they have to live with it). 15 year old wears a bedsheet is treated as a kid (they were duped! they obviously couldn't have decided that on their own, they were tricked!).

Which is it? Doesn't get any simpler than that.

Please. 15 year olds have brains.

I still don't get your point.

My stance is these innapropriate pictures were taken of a 15 year old child with adults around her. IMO they border on child pornogrphy. The adults around her have failed her by allowing this to happen.

Only you know why you are discussing 15 year old murderers in this thread. Lord knows I don't know why you are.

 

[sherri79]

15 year old murders is tried as an adult (they made the decision, they have to live with it). 15 year old wears a bedsheet is treated as a kid (they were duped! they obviously couldn't have decided that on their own, they were tricked!).

Which is it? Doesn't get any simpler than that.

Please. 15 year olds have brains.

apples and rocks. the two do not compare. in one case you have a 15 year old being controlled by adults. in the other case you have a 15 year old acting on their own. had MC taken these pictures herself and posted them she would be responsible but that is not the case. adults who have a legal and moral duty to protect a minor from sexual exploitation told her what to do.

 

[NewMom2003]

apples and rocks. the two do not compare. in one case you have a 15 year old being controlled by adults. in the other case you have a 15 year old acting on their own. had MC taken these pictures herself and posted them she would be responsible but that is not the case. adults who have a legal and moral duty to protect a minor from sexual exploitation told her what to do.

:clap:

What sherri said.

 

[southcitymom]

15 year old murders is tried as an adult (they made the decision, they have to live with it). 15 year old wears a bedsheet is treated as a kid (they were duped! they obviously couldn't have decided that on their own, they were tricked!).

Which is it? Doesn't get any simpler than that.

Please. 15 year olds have brains.

Excellent point, as usual!

 

[Mr. E]

LOL, you want to talk about a double standard ... I don't see anything dirty in the photo, but I wouldn't even let my girls read Seventeen until they were at least 17. Jeez the crap they publish in those magazines.

You got that right. My kids don't read that junk, and they're 12 and almost 17. They have no interest in it, thank goodness. Those teen mags are totally contentless. What a waste of ink and paper.

 

[golfmom]

You got that right. My kids don't read that junk, and they're 12 and almost 17. They have no interest in it, thank goodness. Those teen mags are totally contentless. What a waste of ink and paper.

GIGO = Garbage In, Garbage Out

 

[Paladin]

apples and rocks. the two do not compare. in one case you have a 15 year old being controlled by adults. in the other case you have a 15 year old acting on their own. had MC taken these pictures herself and posted them she would be responsible but that is not the case. adults who have a legal and moral duty to protect a minor from sexual exploitation told her what to do.

Miley could have said "NO". They teach you that in gradeschool.

 

[sherri79]

Miley could have said "NO". They teach you that in gradeschool.

so could every teenage girl asked to do something sexual inappropriate by a father/teacher/trusted adult. your theory discounts the control adults have over children and the imbalance of power.

 

[Rino]

so could every teenage girl asked to do something sexual inappropriate by a father/teacher/trusted adult. your theory discounts the control adults have over children and the imbalance of power.

Only if she had said no or did not want to do this. This photo shoot is not underground or done in a depraved secret society.

Is you're logic she had been a victim of these adults for so long that she was helpless to make a different choice?

 

[SweetPea2]

I think she could have said no too. I think she did them because she wanted to do them but once she seen them in print, she got embarrassed "AFTER the FACT"

I don't for one minute think she was manipulated into taking these photos.

 

[sherri79]

Only if she had said no or did not want to do this. This photo shoot is not underground or done in a depraved secret society.

Is you're logic she had been a victim of these adults for so long that she was helpless to make a different choice?

first the quote from VF indicates she was not happy with it but the pout of the photographer changed her mind.

In a caption with the image, Disney's Hannah Montana star tells VF: "I think it's really artsy. It wasn't in a skanky way. Annie took, like, a beautiful shot, and I thought that was really cool. That's what she wanted me to do, and you can't say no to Annie. She's so cute. She gets this puppy-dog look and you're like, 'OK.

second yes and no. i was raped from 7 to 15 years of age. i never was able to say no. at 15 i simply ran. i do not think it is easy for most children to stand up to their parents and say no. my abuse was horrific and painful and i knew it was wrong. if i was strong enough to run yet unable to just say no despite the horror i suffered what do we really expect from this child? she loves her parents, her whole family depends on her for support, she has a hundred people that depend on her for a paycheck if not more, the adults in charge tell her not to worry it will be fine. do we really expect the 15 year old to look at the famous photographer, the Disney suits, and her own parents and say i think this is wrong?

 

[ember]

Maybe I'm the only one but I think the photos are beautiful and tastefully done.
yeah, I know she's only 15 and no, I wouldn't let my daughter have photos taken like that at 15 but I still think they are art....to be used at home not released to the public but art, none the less. I certainly see the beauty.

Of course, I have a more European mindset when it comes to the body...so my opinion may be biased because of that....


What I can't wrap my mind around is how everyone is saying that the ones with her dad are weird.

Has the American mind become so perverse that a daughter can't take a loving picture with her father? Obviously they are very close. I see nothing sinister there. Just a dad and his girl. I think it's lovely.

 

[Paladin]

second yes and no. i was raped from 7 to 15 years of age. i never was able to say no. at 15 i simply ran. i do not think it is easy for most children to stand up to their parents and say no. my abuse was horrific and painful and i knew it was wrong. if i was strong enough to run yet unable to just say no despite the horror i suffered what do we really expect from this child? she loves her parents, her whole family depends on her for support, she has a hundred people that depend on her for a paycheck if not more, the adults in charge tell her not to worry it will be fine. do we really expect the 15 year old to look at the famous photographer, the Disney suits, and her own parents and say i think this is wrong?

I'm sorry for your past. That's horrible. But I don't think anyone held down Miley and forced her to take these photos.

Also, about the Disney suits...I bet they weren't there. They probably would have said "NO" from an image standpoint.

For now, I'm going to give Miley's parents the benefit of the doubt. I think maybe the photographers crew tried to keep Miley's parents busy so they could take those questionable shots. The parents probably saw the shots that they were taking were innocent enough so they felt comfortable leaving for a few moments. That's all it takes to be asked to remove your clothes and your training bra for a bedsheet shot.

 

[Rino]

Sherri, sorry for your pain. :blowkiss:

But to equate a spoiled tv personality with actual abuse is absurd, imo. She speaks as if she is an adult "you can't say no to Annie.", and is treated like an adult until some sees it as inappropriate then its all... I'm sorry. Frankly I would have at least some respect for her and her family it they would just own up to it...