We seem to be on the exact same page I think.i do think this couldd be a possibilty! but how does josh get back into his room without swiping in? let in by a roommate? let in by a monk? door wedged open?? if josh did make it back to st maur house,played music,this means that something bad maybe took place in st maur house or outside it...in fact im trying to picture myself as a 'fly on the wall' in this scenario!!
im listening to music.i dont know this but someone is going to try to lure me into a dangerous situation. maybe ive had a confrontation with them, or im about to have a confrontation. but not immediately.theyre not going to come in and punch me or assault me. its loud. its going to be heard. this person is calculated. its not sneaky enough to come in right now. whoever wants me in this dangerous situation is intelligent. theyre going to lure me out of the dorm room by a knock on the door,i open the door and go outside with them...this means they didnt swipe in and i didnt swipe out....no trace of door entry and exit logs... <<<<<<< thats what i think might have happened (my objective opinion of course)
There are still some things to work out. One of them being the keycard. I can't explain how Josh entered without being recorded...that really bothers me. If someone had let him in then surely they'd have said so. Was the door propped open, possibly. Did the system fail, maybe.?
Could someone who had access have been already waiting for Josh and let him in? Who had access? Nick...but he was with Katie. Staff members, I assume so.
This is where this whole theory falls down, this one little point. And it drives me crazy.
Every single theory and idea has a stumbling block which seems to be some small thing that can't be proved either way!