Found Deceased MN - Michelle Mae, 35, Outing, 2 Oct 2019 *arrest*

As a Minnesotan, I am extremely disappointed in the lack of media coverage with this case. The public is the most helpful resource, but we can't do much if we don't have any information. So sad it ended like this. God bless.
I felt this way too, however I think they may have known way more and didn’t want to spook the perp. Might be good after all because he likely would have moved her body if he watched a media frenzy begin...
 
Noting:
  • 34-year-old Joshua Karjala was arrested on October 5 for probation violation after LE found Michelle's vehicle on October 4.
  • Her body was found within five miles of where her vehicle was located.
  • LE was searching private property belonging to Karjala when they found her.
  • Mae’s toxicology reports are pending.
  • Karjala has previously been convicted of felony burglary in the first degree, as well as felony criminal sexual conduct in the fourth degree.
 
Preliminary results point to homicide in death of missing Outing woman | Brainerd Dispatch
Her body was found on his property after executing a search warrant on said property... unsure still how these two were connected before her murder.
Also from the article:

Joshua%20Emil%20Karjala.JPG


Search warrants were issued for cell phone data.

In addition, search warrants were executed at a private property near Swatara.
 
JK's criminal history includes 5th Degree Assault, Felony Burglary 1st Degree, Felony Criminal Sexual Conduct 4th Degree, Gross Misdemeanor Malicious Punishment of a Child, and Fleeing an Officer not in a M/V.

Numerous traffic infractions - Driving w/o license, Driving w/o Insurance, Driving under Suspension, seat belt violations, etc.

Minnesota Judicial Branch - AccessCaseRecords
 
WDIO-TV reports a criminal complaint says Mae met 34-year-old Joshua Karjala online. The complaint lists evidence of clothing, bedding and electronics that were found in a fireplace, crawl space and in the basement of the residence.

The complaint alleges that Karjala told a nurse at the Aitkin County Jail that he had been using methamphetamine laced with ecstasy and that he "may have killed a girl."

Aitkin County man charged in death of missing woman
 
NOV 13, 2019
Mother memorializes slain daughter Michelle Mae | Pine and Lakes Echo Journal
No matter how difficult things were for Shelly, she remained a positive person who people were drawn to, her mother said.

MichelleMae1.jpg


From an early age, Michelle “Shelly” Mae loved rainbows.

They brightened up her wardrobe and were featured in artwork she and her children created together. Gazing upward toward a large rainbow painting pinned to her living room ceiling helped Shelly through a dark period following the death of her infant son, Tobbie.

On Oct. 20, the 35-year-old Outing woman was memorialized by a rainbow when family and friends released 150 red, orange, yellow, green, blue and purple balloons to float toward the heavens. It was Shelly’s request for her memorial - recorded in one of dozens of journals she kept over the years - but her loved ones never expected to fulfill it this early in her life.

[...]

After Shelly’s 2004 Jeep Liberty was located Oct. 4, it was another 10 agonizing days before Shelly’s family got answers. The experience has been surreal, almost as if she’s starring in a movie, DeAnn said.

“And how did I get in this horrible movie? You see these movies about things like this. You watch ‘Dateline’ and those shows of other families. You hope that never happens to you. And then all of a sudden it’s real and it’s happening,” she said. “You think to yourself, are they ever going to find her? … Is it going to be two years before they find her, or what if they never find her, like other families go through?”

[...]

The second oldest of four children, Shelly grew up first in Brainerd and later St. Cloud. She was a gymnast and a dancer and she loved art, particularly painting and especially brightly colored rainbows.

“She made this rainbow and she super-glued it to the back of her bedroom door. Which basically, you know, ruins the door,” DeAnn said. “She loved bright colors. She would get flowers and it would all be bright colors. … That never changed.”

[...]

Shelly and her mother were very close, DeAnn said, and together, they loved music - Brooks and Dunn, Sugarland and Martina McBride were artists they agreed on. Shelly loved to belt out, “Let freedom ring, let the white doves sing,” along with Martina in her 1994 song “Independence Day.”

“She’d always come to clean my house for me,” DeAnn said. “... Next thing we’d know, the cleaning of the house was done and we were singing. That was one of our deep connections because she enjoyed it. I am absolutely a terrible singer, I’m terrible. I can’t carry a note, a tune, nothing. But I would do it with her, because that’s what she loved doing.”

[...]

In 2013, Shelly suffered the loss of her 4-month-old son, TK, to meningitis. That was a devastating turning point in her daughter’s life, DeAnn said. She faced her pain openly, however, and made a point to be receptive to her children’s pain as well.

[...]

No matter how difficult things were for Shelly, she remained a positive person who people were drawn to, her mother said. Her charisma shined in her work as a bartender and server at various area restaurants and bars, including the Pickled Loon Saloon in Outing, and as a retail merchandiser with Driveline Retail Merchandising.

IMG_3727.JPG


DeAnn said a letter read at Shelly’s memorial service, written by a friend named Jamie whom Shelly met in the aftermath of TK’s death, poignantly described her daughter’s personality.

“Before you came into my life I was selfish, bitter, hateful, thought I was better than others. I was quick to judge without even giving anyone a chance,” the letter stated. “Then I sat down and listened to you talk, listened to your story. That instant my heart changed. You taught me that no one should ever be judged. You taught me how to be more empathetic, and that everyone has their own story to tell.

[...]

Along with sharing personal remembrances, Shelly’s family and friends together sang a rendition of the soul classic “Lean on Me” at the memorial service - yet another of Shelly’s wishes, fulfilled. As her loved ones look ahead to the difficult weeks, months and years before them, DeAnn said she takes comfort in knowing her daughter’s fate.

[...]

rainbow-and-stars-smiley-emoticon.gif
 
Last edited:
NOV 13, updated NOV 19, 2019
UPDATE: Karjala seeks change of venue
Joshua Karjala, who is charged with felony second degree murder involving the death of an Outing woman appeared at a hearing in Aitkin County Court Nov. 18 and requested a change of venue.

Karjala and his attorney presented a motion for the change of venue to another county yet to be determined, because he said pre-trial publicity has rendered a fair trial impossible in Aitkin County.

The motion hearing is set for 8:30 a.m. on Dec. 18 in Aitkin County Court.

[...]

According to a Rochester Post Bulletin report: “Karjala and Mae had met through a dating app and had met up Oct. 2 for a date, documents said. When questioned by authorities, Karjala said they had sex and she left that same night, according to the criminal complaint. On Oct. 5, authorities searched Karjala’s residence with his permission and found women’s clothing, identified as Mae’s by her family — though Karjala said the clothes belonged to his girlfriend, court documents said.”

On Nov. 7 in District Court of the 9th Judicial District, Aitkin County, Karjala was arraigned on one count of felony second-degree murder in the strangulation death of Michelle Mary Mae. Judge David Hermerding set unconditional bail in the amount of $5,000,000 or conditional release in the amount of $2,000,000 bond and $500,000 cash bail.

[...]
 
JAN 24, 2020
Court date to discuss change of venue in murder case set | Brainerd Dispatch
A contested omnibus hearing for the 34-year-old Swatara man facing second-degree murder charges in the death of an Outing woman is scheduled at 1:30 p.m. April 20 in front of Judge David F. Hermerding in Aitkin County District Court.

[...]

Karjala’s Public Defender Charles Frey filed a motion Nov. 18 requesting a change in venue stating it would be impossible for the defendant to have a fair and impartial trial in Aitkin County. The case is being prosecuted by Minnesota Assistant Attorney General Daniel Vlieger of St. Paul, who filed a motion Jan. 7 to oppose the change in venue motion. In the state’s motion filed in court, a letter signed by Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison stated the defense did not provide any additional documents or legal analysis to support a change in venue.

[...]
 
JAN 24, 2020
Court date to discuss change of venue in murder case set | Brainerd Dispatch
A contested omnibus hearing for the 34-year-old Swatara man facing second-degree murder charges in the death of an Outing woman is scheduled at 1:30 p.m. April 20 in front of Judge David F. Hermerding in Aitkin County District Court.

[...]

Karjala’s Public Defender Charles Frey filed a motion Nov. 18 requesting a change in venue stating it would be impossible for the defendant to have a fair and impartial trial in Aitkin County. The case is being prosecuted by Minnesota Assistant Attorney General Daniel Vlieger of St. Paul, who filed a motion Jan. 7 to oppose the change in venue motion. In the state’s motion filed in court, a letter signed by Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison stated the defense did not provide any additional documents or legal analysis to support a change in venue.

[...]

I'm in an adjoining county in MN. This is not being covered by local news at all. I wonder why the request for change of venue.
 
SEP 23, 2020
Karjala attorneys request dismissal | Crime/Courts | messagemedia.co
In a Sept. 9 contested omnibus hearing in Aitkin County Court, attorneys for Joshua Karjala filed two motions – one to dismiss the case entirely and a second to suppress a statement made by Karjala to police.

[...]

Karjala was charged Nov. 7, and has been in and out of the court since then, with first public defenders and then his attorneys contesting evidence, filing for extensions and now requesting a dismissal of the case or the supression of Karjala’s statement.
 
APR 16, 2021
Swatara man pleads guilty to murder in strangulation death | Brainerd Dispatch
[...]

Joshua Karjala pleaded guilty to second-degree unintentional murder in the death of Michelle Mae in front of Judge David F. Hermerding in an in-person courtroom hearing. A jury trial for the Swatara man was scheduled to begin June 14. However, Karjala pleaded guilty to the murder charge in an amended criminal complaint.

[...]

Bergeson asked Karjala about the night of Oct. 2, 2019, when Mae came over to his house. Karjala said they used drugs and engaged in what he called rough sex, including him choking her.

“At a certain point I realized that she was ... not responding to me. I said something to her, and she did not respond. At that point I, I panicked. I sat her up and tried to revive her … she didn’t seem to be breathing at that point. I panicked. I laid her down at the edge of my bed, after sitting her up and shaking her. ... I assumed at a certain point that the police would be coming to my house because Michelle had a safety net and stuff in place, that if she didn’t call her friend at a certain time her friend was instructed to call the police. Apparently this is something she does,” Karjala said, according to court transcripts.

Karjala continued, “... I assume the police were going to be coming to my house. I grabbed all my drugs and I tried eating them. I ate probably roughly 2 grams of meth laced with ecstasy, and I blacked out. ... When I woke up I panicked. I tried hiding her body. I picked her up and I put her in her jacket and tried moving her ... away from the bed and she fell to the floor. ... I decided to move her without her jacket because it was impossible to do so with the jacket.

“I brought her to my back bedroom and lowered her down through a trapdoor with the intentions of hiding her because I didn’t want ... cops to see her. ... I ended up dropping her slightly into the hole with the trapdoor. ... A couple days later I finally moved her into the final place where she was found by police.”

Karjala admitted to intentionally choking her, but not with the intent to cause her death. He said he had no recollection of the other injuries and bruises to her body.

[...]

Aitkin County man pleads guilty to murder in strangulation death | Duluth News Tribune
Karjala’s attorney asked him if he understood the sexual encounter may have started out as consensual, then at some point when he damaged her neck it became nonconsensual. Karjala said he did understand. Karjala also stated he understood hiding her body from police is considered an aggravated factor.
 
JUN 2, 2021
Judge gives Swatara man close to 30 years in prison for murder | Brainerd Dispatch
[...]

Joshua Karjala was convicted of second-degree unintentional murder in the death of Michelle Mae. Unintentional murder is causing the death of a human being without intent to effect the death of any person, while committing or attempting to commit a felony offense other than criminal sexual conduct in the first- or second-degree with force.

The second-degree murder charge with intent was dismissed.

Judge David F. Hermerding sentenced Karjala to 330 months — or 27 1/2 years — in the Minnesota Correctional Facility in St. Cloud, where he will serve two-thirds of his sentence before being released on probation. He was given credit for 660 days already served in jail.

[...]

In 2013, Mae suffered the loss of her 4-month-old son Tobbie Krebsbach to meningitis.

No matter how difficult things were for Mae, she remained a positive person who people were drawn to, her mother told the Dispatch in 2019. Her charisma shone in her work as a bartender and server at various area restaurants and bars, including the Pickled Loon Saloon in Outing, and as a retail merchandiser with Driveline Retail Merchandising.

“She was full of life. She was a great listener, a great friend, a great mom. Full of life,” Mae’s mother said in 2019. “She wanted to see her kids go off to school or get married and have babies. It was something that she was looking forward to because she knew how much I loved being a grandma.”

[...]
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
140
Guests online
711
Total visitors
851

Forum statistics

Threads
626,294
Messages
18,523,855
Members
241,010
Latest member
AppleJaxRN
Back
Top