MN -- woman shot in face and killed by ICE, Minneapolis, 7 Jan 2026

  • #481
He didnt draw until AFTER the tires spun momentarily as she pressed the gas to move forward. Her reverse lights were off and the tires were still straight towards him as he's drawing his weapon.
We will have to agree to disagree. I see him drawing before she ever puts the car in drive. I will say the NYT analysis in post #484 supports my stance.
 
  • #482
While doing that, have someone yell "get out of here" as another burly masked 🤬🤬🤬🤬 yells "stop" while both aim guns at you and reach in through the window to grab you. Point is, her car was a danger to no one until after he murdered her.
In the video I saw, none of the officers aimed weapons at her until she accelerated very rapidly (but...said to be beyond her control).
 
  • #483
Would anybody be so kind to compile the videos into a single post that we could link to? I’m on mobile so it’s a bit of a hassle and the videos are posted all over the place so it’s hard to know which ones we can actually refer to. Or perhaps a media thread even? It’s a bit annoying when people start claiming things and then admit that they haven’t even seen the original videos.
 
  • #484
And would you expect to them to try to open your car door and forcibly remove you from your vehicle? Or shoot you multiple times in point blank range? Is that how you would expect that situation to be handled?

Objectively, no I would not want my situation handled like that (and I have said that multiple times in this thread).

Likewise, objectively, I would also consider the totality of my actions to be badly thought out and placing my self at risk.

Though I have participated in many protests, doing what she chose to do would make me leery about a bad outcome. I would definitely advise friends and family not to follow her lead.
 
Last edited:
  • #485
Another thought.

How was Ms. Good supposed to know the people surrounding her vehicle were "LE"? None of them identified themselves as such or displayed a badge as far as I can see.

If I saw some masked guy running toward me and yelling for me to get the eff out of my car, I too would attempt to drive away as fast as possible.
I seriously am disappointed that no state in the US is vigorously enforcing that ICE must display badges and follow protocols for things like gun use, searches and arrests that other LE must follow. Some states have taken some measures, but not have aggressively policed ICE in their states.

MOO
 
  • #486
We will have to agree to disagree. I see him drawing before she ever puts the car in drive. I will say the NYT analysis in post #484 supports my stance.
Watch a complete slowed down video. The NYT video jumps back and forth between slow and full speed. Her reverse lights are off and the front tire spins for a split second and she starts to go forward , both front and rear tires made a forward motion before he drew.
 
  • #487
Watch a complete slowed down video. The NYT video jumps back and forth between slow and full speed. Her reverse lights are off and the front tire spins for a split second and she starts to go forward , both front and rear tires made a forward motion before he drew.
I am telling you I watched the complete slowed video. Again, we will have to agree to disagree.
 
  • #488
Watch a complete slowed down video. The NYT video jumps back and forth between slow and full speed. Her reverse lights are off and the front tire spins for a split second and she starts to go forward , both front and rear tires made a forward motion before he drew.

Exactly
 
  • #489
The land of the free lol.

So many people here are saying Americans must instantly obey these masked, plainclothed, ID-less, half-trained heavies if you don't want to be shot three times in the face and have your fellow citizens say you deserved it for not being obedient enough.

Sure. Sounds like a free society to me.
And it's the "don't tread on me" supposedly anti government overreach people that are applauding the overt establishment of a police state.
 
  • #490
And it's the "don't tread on me" supposedly anti government overreach people that are applauding the overt establishment of a police state.
I think it’s much easier for some people to try to justify this woman’s shooting than it is for them to admit to themselves we have a problem in our country with poorly vetted, poorly trained federal agents who are both acting and being treated as though they are above the law. Because admitting that is scary.

ETA: the evidence in totality is clear to me. There are at least two other cases this year where ICE accused civilians of ‘ramming’ them with their vehicles and shot the civilians. Both cases have been dropped against the civilians due to lack of evidence. The ‘they were weaponizing their vehicle’ is a convenient lie for ICE - they just hope no one will remember the case by the time charges are dropped.

Secondly, the victim was filmed waving officers around her car, and one officer does travel around her car. She was not obstructing the roadway. She did not ram the agent who drove in front of her vehicle. If her intent was to hurt ICE agents, that would have been a prime opportunity.

Lastly, this has been rattling around my mind: “The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential, command’ - George Orwell, 1984.
 
Last edited:
  • #491
The uniform and police/ice on their uniforms says exactly who they are to me, Law Enforcement.

Jmo
 
  • #492
Just so you’re aware, I’m not defending them. But it’s a deadly weapon. Do you think they were concerned she was going to ram into him? It was a split second reaction?

Very concerning that they don’t seem to have training and are so trigger happy.
Ms. Good, a mother of 3, was not using her car as a weapon in any way, shape or form.

If she were, shooting the driver is not what one does. Dead people don't stop cars.

<modsnip>

MOO
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #493
I keep telling myself, with every new atrocity, that surely *this* will be the tipping point. I hope one day to be right.
 
  • #494
The video I saw featured one car going around her as she crept forward as it if to block it.

A second car stopped. I have a feeling that if I were to position my car perpendicular to traffic and then creep towards other cars in other lanes, the local police would consider me to be blocking a street.
Blocking a street is not a capital offense.
 
  • #495
  • #496
The uniform and police/ice on their uniforms says exactly who they are to me, Law Enforcement.

Jmo
They are covering their faces and not displaying badges/ID making ID impossible, even with numerous incidences of imposters.

Ironically, it's the people who are now expected to always have ID/proof of citizenship.
 
  • #497
In the video I saw, none of the officers aimed weapons at her until she accelerated very rapidly (but...said to be beyond her control).
Yeah it's weird to not be able to control your car after being shot in the face..jmo.
 
  • #498
  • #499
  • #500

Ms. Good has no criminal history beyond traffic citations. It also appears that although we have heard from her youngest child’s grandmother that her husband who was in the USAF was deceased, she has a ex-husband, who was her first husband, as per ABC.

“Trump administration officials painted Macklin Good as a domestic terrorist who had attempted to ram federal agents with her car. Her ex-husband said she was no activist and that he had never known her to participate in a protest of any kind.

He described her as a devoted Christian who took part in youth mission trips to Northern Ireland when she was younger. She loved to sing, participating in a chorus in high school and studying vocal performance in college.

… Good had a daughter and her son from her first marriage, who are now ages 15 and 12. Her 6-year-old son was from her second marriage.”
 
Last edited:

Guardians Monthly Goal

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
232
Guests online
2,060
Total visitors
2,292

Forum statistics

Threads
637,343
Messages
18,713,124
Members
244,112
Latest member
let the world burn
Back
Top