MN -- woman shot in face and killed by ICE, Minneapolis, 7 Jan 2026

  • #381
WHO do people think these 'thousands' of ICE people ARE??? These instapolice? Armed and protected all over themselves roaming the streets and cities? WHO are their 'direct supervisors'? Do not ever think this group is formed as your State Police or local police are, regular military member... NO, they are not, they were and are being advertised and signed up based on what? (Not that our state police, as we have seen nor local police, can be stable and decent and law abiding themselves at ALL in instances). IMO
Don't know if this has already been stated but the new ICE agents got 47 days of training, the amount of days to symbolically reflect the current president. As a contrast prior trainees trained for five MONTHS.
 
  • #382
Don't know if this has already been stated but the new ICE agents got 47 days of training, the amount of days to symbolically reflect the current president. As a contrast prior trainees trained for five MONTHS.
I think I just made up some new cuss words.
My flabbers are gasted.
 
  • #383
Is there video of what transpired immediately before this? Does anyone know if the white (?) SUV in front of her car is an ICE vehicle or was this a vehicle of a person apprehended by ICE? I ask because all I've seen is the videos of the actual shooting and no context really given for the other SUV there with it's door open.
These two's phones...
Briefly, my opinion is the shooter overprioritized keeping his face hidden. He and a stranger were videoing each other right before (he snapped).
I think the other SUV there with it's door open was driven by the shooter. When he walks back from the victim he kinda acts like he's gonna stop at the SUV before changing his mind. He's also on his phone during that walk which woulda been his first opportunity to look (or etc) at what HE HAD FILMED.
 
  • #384
  • #385
Thoughts.

1. Ms. Good was not blocking the street. As many others have pointed out, several cars went around her vehicle. And the video clearly shows that the silver pickup that the ICE officers emerged from had plenty of room to do the same.

2. Even if she had been blocking traffic on the street, which she wasn't (see #1), there's no way anyone aside from a skilled clairvoyant could know why she did so. If I am not mistaken, she lived on the street, did she not? I'm just making this up out of my imagination, but maybe she pulled out of her driveway, then thought she might have forgotten her phone, then paused for what she thought would just be a second or two to make sure it was in her purse.

It's a gigantic leap to say that she was deliberately blocking ICE, because unless she left a note or yelled out her intentions, no one knows at this point why her vehicle was where it was. Also, see #1.

I just don't see how anyone can watch that video and still believe that the official government accounts of why Ms. Good was shot are in the least bit accurate.

All my opinion.
 
  • #386
Since I read this in February last year, I have wondered who exactly is being recruited by ICE.


According to the Global Project Against Hate and Extremism (GPAHE), the Proud Boys are already positioning themselves as potential enforcers for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Tracking their activity on Telegram, GPAHE has reported that Proud Boys PDX fantasizes about being “deputized as ICE under Trump’s second term” to aid in mass deportations.

They're recruiting on all the job boards. It's sickening to see the LinkedIn ads for them.
 
  • #387
1. I do not see an amount of snow that could possibly get a vehicle stuck. I successully drive through more than this daily in winter to get out of my own driveway, in an ordinary, non-lifted, non-studded or chained SUV.

2. I do not see how the victim's vehicle is blocking the road, since I am able to observe with my own eyes in these videos that a vehicle successfully passes by with clearance.

3. I hear conflicting commands being given.

4. I do not see a riot or rioters.

MOO.
 
  • #388
**edit to add that all links show graphic content**

So here’s what I know on the facts so far:
1. A local ICE watch group claimed the victim was affiliated with them (I don’t know whether she was monitoring or protesting when this occurred. A group showed up to protest, but I don’t know if she was with the group or just happened to be in the area).
2. She was in the middle of the street sideways for unknown reasons (possibly in an attempt to block the road).
3. She waved some cars by her.
4. ICE for some reason approached the car and gave conflicting orders while attempting to open her door.
5. One of the ICE agents (the one who later shot her) decided to position himself in front of the car (like a fool, IMO).
6. She moves the car forward and the agent in front of the car shoots her once, then a few more times after the car passes by.

I don’t think we know for sure if the agent was actually hit or not. I believe the people saying he was hit are referencing this video. It was unfortunately a post from a partisan source, but it’s the only one I could find slowed down from this angle:

IMO, the footage is too grainy to tell whether he was actually hit, but it certainly got very close to him.

Here’s another slomo video from a different angle that shows the position of the shooter (agent pulls his gun at the 4 second mark):

Both do show that she did eventually turn right.

*Also want to note that I don’t endorse the opinions in the tweets. I just think they were the best videos.

Here’s a good article with multiple eyewitness accounts:
https://www.mprnews.org/story/2026/01/07/shooting-south-minneapolis-ice-agents-federal-operation

IMO, the most concise and inclusive witness account of events in the article:

Caitlin Callenson said she was walking down Portland Avenue with her partner when she saw who she assumed were Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents.

“They tried to zoom their car out of the snowbank but were just stuck,” she said.

She said other ICE vehicles showed up, leading neighbors to believe it might be an ICE enforcement action. People showed up, and some began blowing whistles.

“People in our neighborhood have been terrorized by ICE for six weeks. We want our neighbors safe, and so when we see a group of ICE vehicles, people in the community are showing up and saying, ‘This is not OK,’” she said.

Callenson said one person — the woman who was shot a short time later — drove her vehicle perpendicular to the lanes of traffic on Portland Avenue, south of the ICE vehicles. By that point, Callenson said, the vehicle stuck in snow had been freed.

“Some of them were leaving, and they just went around her, but ICE gave her orders to leave, while at the same time, another ICE person said, ‘Get out of the car,’ and he reached for her door handle. And then there was an ICE agent in front of her vehicle. So it was difficult for her to leave, as she'd been ordered to do,” Callenson said.

“She turned her steering wheel toward the right. The person was grabbing her door handle, the ICE officer who was in front of her vehicle shot once from the front and twice from the side, hitting her maybe three feet away at the max. Because she was shot, and she was already trying to leave, her foot was on the accelerator, and she crashed into a telephone pole.”


We do know from the videos that the person grabbing the door handle was not the one that shot her, but the rest of the facts seem to line up with what we see in the video (although I’m not sure how she could see which way she had her steering wheel turned, especially since the tires were in forward position until the shooter pulled his gun, as seen in video #2).

Just trying to get the objective facts out there with minimal subjective opinion. I personally am trying hard not to make any snap judgments yet one way or the other. I just hope that there’s a fair trial and conviction if the courts deem one is warranted.
 
  • #389
  • #390
I very clearly see an officer in front of the vehicle as the woman very rapidly accelerates into a turn and the camera angle changes. In the two incidents that I cited, the accelerations towards the officers were far slower.

The above aside, I don't think the woman was trying to run over the officer. Rather, I firmly believe that she would have continued to turn, then drove away once she had completed the turn (and cleared the officer).

In the end I think the shooting was "justifiable" in the technical legal sense but not truly justified ethically.

The officer should have noted that the vehicle was tightly turning away from him (while also moving towards him). At the same time, the officer cannot read minds and did not know her true intent.
There's no cohesiveness to the processes these guys use. One of them is telling her to get out of the car, other cops are yelling at people get out of there. I don't believe for a minute this woman was trying to do anything more than trying to leave the scene. She was sitting in her vehicle with her arm out the window motioning for cars to go because she was trying to turn her car to go right. One vehicle to her left did leave and drove around the front of her vehicle. Then the gray LE 1/2 ton pick up with flashing lights came up and she motioned them to move but they got out of the car walking toward her. You can tell by the angle her front tires were, not at all aiming for the cop who shot her. That news bulletin hosted by Kristi Noem was a complete fiction. She even added information about cop cars being stuck in snowbanks when no vehicles in that area were stuck in snowbanks. If you're trying to create a fake narrative the rule of thumb is to keep the majority of facts accurate, adding erroneous information to pad your story is juvenile behavior easily checked. The death of this woman reminds of the poor unfortunate soul who was shot multiple times by a swat team in a motel who were yelling conflicting commands:

 
  • #391
Witness live on Fox9 says he estimates vehicle was traveling ‘around 2 MPH’ until victim was shot, at which point the vehicle accelerated.
It's hard to control a vehicle when the driver is dead and their foot is still on the gas pedal.
 
  • #392
There's no cohesiveness to the processes these guys use. One of them is telling her to get out of the car, other cops are yelling at people get out of there. I don't believe for a minute this woman was trying to do anything more than trying to leave the scene. She was sitting in her vehicle with her arm out the window motioning for cars to go because she was trying to turn her car to go right. One vehicle to her left did leave and drove around the front of her vehicle. Then the gray LE 1/2 ton pick up with flashing lights came up and she motioned them to move but they got out of the car walking toward her. You can tell by the angle her front tires were, not at all aiming for the cop who shot her. That news bulletin hosted by Kristi Noem was a complete fiction. She even added information about cop cars being stuck in snowbanks when no vehicles in that area were stuck in snowbanks. If you're trying to create a fake narrative the rule of thumb is to keep the majority of facts accurate, adding erroneous information to pad your story is juvenile behavior easily checked. The death of this woman reminds of the poor unfortunate soul who was shot multiple times by a swat team in a motel who were yelling conflicting commands:

I also was thinking of this video when I heard the conflicting directions from them ☹️

But the vehicle being stuck was backed up by a witness:
https://www.mprnews.org/story/2026/01/07/shooting-south-minneapolis-ice-agents-federal-operation

Caitlin Callenson said she was walking down Portland Avenue with her partner when she saw who she assumed were Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents.

“They tried to zoom their car out of the snowbank but were just stuck,” she said.

She said other ICE vehicles showed up, leading neighbors to believe it might be an ICE enforcement action. People showed up, and some began blowing whistles.
 
  • #393
How the heck do you get stuck there? My city, which is similar in latitude to Toronto, does not plow tertiary streets. At all. And somehow I get out to work every day, despite having learned to drive in Alabama. 🤣
 
  • #394
It's hard to control a vehicle when the driver is dead and their foot is still on the gas pedal.
Especially when it's an injury to the head, likely nerve/limb spasms, imo.
 
  • #395
Another thought.

How was Ms. Good supposed to know the people surrounding her vehicle were "LE"? None of them identified themselves as such or displayed a badge as far as I can see.

If I saw some masked guy running toward me and yelling for me to get the eff out of my car, I too would attempt to drive away as fast as possible.
 
Last edited:
  • #396
  • #397
A Roosevelt High School student told 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS that ICE agents pulled up to the entrance sometime during Wednesday afternoon, then blocked portions of the road.

Roosevelt High School is about three miles away from the intersection of 34th Street and Portland Avenue, where federal agents fatally shot 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good on Wednesday morning.

The student added that he saw ICE agents chasing people, adding that someone was tackled by federal agents.

A video from the scene shows a person lying on the ground, with federal agents surrounding them.

 
  • #398
Being an ICE agent is an optional profession, no one is being forced to do that job. If they feel their lives and safety are at risk, they could quit and get another job.
But how many jobs offer a $50K signing bonus with only 47 days training. And, you get to carry a gun! And wear a mask! Every little boy's dream.
 
  • #399
If I didn't have a life and a career and animals here, I'd be tempted to go be very, very bad at it. 😉
 
  • #400
was this woman protesting or did she just turn down a blocked street? It is lucky she did not kill anyone else as she lost consciousness and crashed. Her son is now without any parent as her husband died young. https://www.startribune.com/she-was...fies-woman-shot-killed-by-ice-agent/601559922 I guess more information about her will be reported soon. Noem said the officer who did the shooting was previously hit and dragged by a car in June. https://thehill.com/homenews/state-...polis-shooting-bashes-city-and-state-leaders/
 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
172
Guests online
2,101
Total visitors
2,273

Forum statistics

Threads
637,291
Messages
18,711,916
Members
244,091
Latest member
ssonnenschein
Back
Top