I’ve tried searching online but can’t find anywhere if the police actually confirmed two phone calls came to the house when JK said she was there. (not the caller’s identity but simply records of someone calling.) If not then it’s only her word, Possibly a red herring. It bothers me so much that JK essentially created, and has changed on TV the timeline. (7:30/ 9:30 when she started calling.) NO, I do NOT think she killed anyone, nor am I accusing anyone of anything. I simply think she knows something and her mother’s convenient alibi only fuels my suspicion. The fact that her mother and father accompanied her to the house the next day is also curious to me as they weren’t the best of friends with Sherrill or Suzie.
I first thought the girls didn’t make it home that night, and that Sherrill was only taken so the crime scene could be staged at the house. If something did happen at the parties Sherrill would ask questions/ know they went missing somewhere else. I now have some doubts about this theory, especially if Stacy’s blood/ footprint was truly found at the house, but still think someone who knew them is involved with luring them out. Why? That’s the age old question that’s haunted this case for almost thirty years. I do not believe in the Hospital theory at all, nor Cox, nor the porch lady sighting. I also believe the note of “using gas man as ruse” was another red herring someone wrote after seeing the original show. I also can’t understand why JK didn’t call Mrs. McCall immediately. With everything at the house it makes no sense to me.
On a separate post I mentioned a prank. If JK and friends were praking Suzie by calling before they could have said something was going down on graduation night. What if Stacy was originally in on the prank and went with SS so she could unlock the front door? JK saying someone called while she was there was a perfect way to draw attention to a mystery man. (yes, I am aware there was a man pranking the neighborhood at the time.) I find that even more convenient.
I’d also like to add that I was not even alive when these women went missing. I happen to stumble on this while reading missing person cases in 2014 and have never been able to forget it. I think about the women all the time and I have no clue as to why this case means so much to me. I suppose it’s because of how unfair it all is. Granted horrible things happen everyday, but Suzie and Stacy had their whole lives ahead of them and were celebrating a milestone in their lives.
I believe many locals are somewhat involved/ know something about this case, some of them with enough old money and influence to instill fear in possible whistleblowers.
I plan on traveling to Springfield in a few months with the attempts of befriending someone who was/ is close to JK and her friends. I believe without a shadow of a doubt that she knows something.
EDIT:
I would also like to add that I believe Sherrill parked in the carport thinking Suzie would not be home that evening, which offers a simple solution to their cars not being where they normally park.
