MY Questions About Some Theories

[White Rain]

Thanks everyone, for giving me new things to think about.

 

[Emeralgem]

It could be true that the call was to Magnolia but I will say I did not know that Hank Sr. and Lisa were living at Magnolia when Haleigh went missing until some time later so it could be that no one knew this right away. We saw photos and video of the tent set-up across the street from the Tyler address, with Hank in his wheelchair out in the yard at Tyler. It is not a stretch that people might assume the younger Croslins were staying with the elder Croslins and AH has shown that he will say things without verification.

If there is a phone record that shows a call was made to Magnolia, the info might be coming from that. But unless the call itself was recorded, we cannot know if Tommy was there to answer that phone. This is all JMO...and as much as I want some real facts in this case I hesitate to take AH's word for things that have not yet been verified by someone reliable.

I hope that if this is true it can be verified because it would help corroborate what some of us believe--that Magnolia could be a crime scene.

krkrjx, I didn't know it either.. And to my knowledge none of us knew it right away..IIRC that information about them living on Magnolia at the time Haleigh disappeared only surfaced around the time of the Shell Harbor search, and that is when we also learned Misty had been staying at her parent's home when she returned from her three day bender.
That information was never revealed before then..
What I don't understand is WHY all the residences of family and friends of family who knew Haleigh weren't thoroughly searched in the beginning...
And it wasn't to just last April that Hardy stated there was a good possibility that the crime had occurred in the Shell Harbor area.
Only thing LE ever stated was there was no evidence a crime had been committed at the MH located at 202 Green Lane. And IF a crime had been committed they didn't know where or when it was committed..

 

[Emeralgem]

Great question! Only theories I can come up with is that Jr. was not there at the time, maybe Haleigh was the only one that got in Ron's stash of drugs thinking it was candy, or maybe this late theory from Chelsea is more smoke & mirrors to deflect on what might of really happen.

All of the sudden when someone turns over the riffle in question to LE Misty changes her story to Tommy did it not Joe.
Chelsea then goes on NG saying she feels Haleigh was given drugs..all a bunch of caca IMO, to throw the gun theory on the back burner. Chelsea seems to change her story each time Misty does...I wonder what all Chelsea knows?
I now feel that maybe Haleigh did get shot by accident near the St. John's river or in Ron's car or Tommy's truck. From what we know so far LE never checked Ron's car. Only the van and Tommy's red truck. LE gave back the van, so their couldn't of been any type of evidence or decomposition in it or they would of kept it in the forensics bay.
As for the Red Truck, LE will not answer where it's at, if they found anything, or even comment on it. I wonder if they did find something in the truck and that is what changed the status of the case? As far as what a sometimes reliable source said LE still has the truck. If that is true, I don't know. Nobody wants to dig deeper...Levi, if ya read this can you follow up on Tommy's red truck plz. Last I heard it was out of FL. TIA :blowkisses:


:cow:

I'm still going with Haleigh was accidentally shot and the incident happened at Hank Sr.and Lisa's residence..

 

[justus4all]

I'm still going with Haleigh was accidentally shot and the incident happened at Hank Sr.and Lisa's residence..

I agree...

As I read and think about and rationalize other theories, and sort thru other possibilites, and different senerios, and look at new information being put out there....I just cannot completely change this theory..

I am interested in knowing much more about the Magnolia residence..but there seems to be very little...other than the Croslins moved out a few days after returning from the hospital...(sorry no link)...just read it here on WS..

It blows my mind that Misty's parents home was not searched..since it could have been a place she had visited many times...

But on the other hand...It could have VERY WELL BEEN SEARCHED..and we were not priviledged to know about it...

all in my own opinion

 

[lonetraveler]

I can understand about our brains being scrambled.....There is so much to consider, think about, theorize, suggest, deny, and it changes for me as rapid as the Croslins/Cummings change THEIR stories....lol....

I do agree with you that the Ron's family have circled around him...and I believe he harmed Haleigh ...and I believe it was before he went to work..
Also my theory includes...(so far) that AS did NOT see Haleigh alive like she is claiming and at the time she is claiming...because of the time limits...Meaning...IF she had of seen her when she said she did....and then Misty puts Haleigh to bed at 8 or so...then Misty wakes up..and she says she sees a 3....(time?) and then she looks for Haleigh ..then Ron arrives..there would not have been enough time for the disposal/cover up/clean up and stories given before the 911 call.....I believe AS said that to cover for Ron...and say that she saw Haleigh...ALIVE...AFTER...Ron was at work....(his alibi)...I believe Haleigh met her demise before Ron LEFT for work..then the rest of the day and evening was filled with the clean up/cover up/disposal/ stories given..THEN when Ron arrived home the 911 call was made..IMO

I believe Misty has already spilled in her interragation a couple of days ago...that she has implicated Ron...and that is the reason she is/was on sucicide watch...she would not be on sucide watch for Tommy...She feels such regret after spilling....she doesn't want to live....(again..imo)

Now she wants Tommy to tell the truth and implicate Ron...

No one knows what was really said in that interragation room...but I believe Levi saying she became so upset she was put on suicide watch...She regrets telling them about Ron....IMO.....

Keep your wits, lone......lol..perhaps we will know the real story here very soon..

We are all trying to sort this barrel of "fishhooks" out

all in my own opinion...

Yeah, you're right! I've also considered that bits and pieces of the stories that the players tell have partial truth to them. Ron's story of holding Haleigh in his lap, getting Haleigh's favorite outfit from GGMS, kissing her goodbye are true, but I think that Haleigh was deceased when he told her goodbye and that the favorite outfit is what she was buried in and I believe that he held her in his lap to say goodbye. GGMS probably delivered the favorite outfit to the MH and said her goodbyes as well. These are just a few of the bits and pieces of the Cummings stories that are true IMO. I think I need intervention, LOL.

 

[lonetraveler]

I am so hoping that we are just held in the dark about LE processing the Cummings' vehicles and the Magnolia residence. Surely, this happened, I truly hope it did anyway; but it is difficult to understand that this got missed in all the media coverage. I've searched this many times and can not find a single item about the vehicles (other than the van and TC's red truck) and any other residences being processed for evidence. This concerns me, alot.

 

[MADJGNLAW]

Yeah, you're right! I've also considered that bits and pieces of the stories that the players tell have partial truth to them. Ron's story of holding Haleigh in his lap, getting Haleigh's favorite outfit from GGMS, kissing her goodbye are true, but I think that Haleigh was deceased when he told her goodbye and that the favorite outfit is what she was buried in and I believe that he held her in his lap to say goodbye. GGMS probably delivered the favorite outfit to the MH and said her goodbyes as well. These are just a few of the bits and pieces of the Cummings stories that are true IMO. I think I need intervention, LOL.

Could be why Ron had made a comment that Haleigh would see him when he got home from work. I questioned that then and now. What child stays up on a school night until after midnight to see their parents when they get off work?

 

[justus4all]

Yeah, you're right! I've also considered that bits and pieces of the stories that the players tell have partial truth to them. Ron's story of holding Haleigh in his lap, getting Haleigh's favorite outfit from GGMS, kissing her goodbye are true, but I think that Haleigh was deceased when he told her goodbye and that the favorite outfit is what she was buried in and I believe that he held her in his lap to say goodbye. GGMS probably delivered the favorite outfit to the MH and said her goodbyes as well. These are just a few of the bits and pieces of the Cummings stories that are true IMO. I think I need intervention, LOL.

You know...you could be right...That would make some bits of information fit what has been said ...among all the lies..that didn't make any sense...

Thanks for sharing!!!! It is truly something to consider...