Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[K9Enzo]

The fact a white van is even mentioned is more evidence we are living in a simulation. It doesnt get any more cliche than a kidnapper with a white van, does it?? This guy wanted to be a kidnapper his whole life. White van, ransom note.

That damn white van every time…. imo

 

[birdbox]

Why Nancy Guthrie? What made her a victim in this?

If truly not for ransome, what was the endgame here?

SA that went worse than it would be just because?

Robbery attempt? Nancy woke up and it went sideways.

A grudge centered on Savannah? I just don’t see that.

I think these ransoms attempts are either a badly thought out afterthought or people trying to cash in.

Probably the strangest case I’ve ever followed.

MOO

Same, its perhaps the strangest ive followed in a while. I literally only login here when its a weird one, admittedly. Kyron Hormon, Laci Peterson, Madelyn McCann, etc. Ones that just don't fit right in what i feel a random crime would look like.

 

[moonbeams]

i was thinking the same thing!

my thoughts about the person who did this (though to be honest, with such a strange case i’m prepared to be completely off)
- bitcoins became popular in the mainstream around 2013. i could see a more tech savvy person in their 30s get into them around that time, someone like that could even be in their early 50s now! so the perp doesn’t have to be super young imo
- the silence of the lambs came out in 1991, so around 35 years ago. i do think it’s a classic, i’m in my early 30s and i’ve seen it too. it makes me think the perp is 30+ but i also think referencing movies in his ransom letter, and using movies as code (if that’s what’s happened) especially says something about his personality - someone who likes to show off his knowledge or who likes to pretend he’s in a movie
- i also think only a local would choose to target NG
- doing this in the dead of night, in the weekend, makes me think it might be someone with a monday to friday job and maybe a partner or family who were not supposed to notice he went missing for a few hours
- could also be two people working together, but i’m not really sure about that

Or someone with a spouse who works nights or weekends so not there to see they aren't actually home....

 

[missy1974]

Armchair detectives flood social media as search for Savannah Guthrie’s missing mom continues​

Source Associated press search for Nancy Guthrie 02/07/26

Websleuths has competition! LOL. This case is white hot.
Banfield is specifically mentioned in this story.

Moments after the news broke about the apparent abduction of “Today” show host Savannah Guthrie’s mother, the floodgates opened on social media....

As the search continues with no suspects or persons of interest, posts across Instagram, TikTok, X, Facebook and YouTube have put millions of eyeballs on tips and theories surrounding her disappearance. But they’ve also helped to amplify rumors and forced law enforcement to repeatedly set the record straight on at least one crucial detail.

I am seeing it pop up all over my social media. Which is good, it creates awareness. What is a bit concerning is... we are on Day 6 or 7? And no sign of her. No real leads that we know of. There is a lot of independent media/msm in Tucson too, they are following LE and staking out the family homes.

I don't know whether the ransom note is real, and if they really have her or not. But until they find NG, it lends credibility to it. Hope today is the day they find her.

All JMO

 

[SaraSmile]

For now.. rbbm. snippets.

FBI profiler gives insight into man who 'abducted' Nancy Guthrie from own home

More than 72 hours after the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, a former FBI special agent, has revealed what she believes is the profile of the 84-year-old's potential abductor

www.irishstar.com

''Speaking to the Daily Mail, Dr Bryanna Fox, a former FBI special agent in the agency's Behavioral Science Unit and criminology professor at the University of South Florida, stated that Guthrie most likely doesn't know her kidnapper.

"If it were a family member or somebody who knows the house, they wouldn't have forced entry," Dr Fox explained. "If she knew them, they would have been likely to have carried out a ruse to get her to go with them and get into the vehicle."

"This was not just a random selection of the victim. This was probably a person or a group of people that selected her, probably cased her pattern of life, what time she goes to sleep, knew that she didn't have security, knew that she lived alone and would be sleeping alone," Dr Fox claimed.''

''However, Chris McDonough, a retired detective with Oceanside PD, instead thinks that Guthrie had "crossed paths" with her abductor at least once before, stating he could be a "gardener or a delivery person."

''Profiling the abductor, Dr Fox believes this is not their first attempt, and thinks they are "a male between the ages of 30 and 45, who has a criminal record, is sophisticated enough to know what law enforcement is going to be looking for, and has committed a series of escalating types of crimes."

She just had the roof done recently, that’s why white roof looks so fresh. Lots of people come for a couple of weeks, maybe cased house. I’m sure they have been talked to.
Maybe the reference to TC is just that he knows, referred the workmen for the roof or other recent work done at the house.

 

[moonbeams]

I have to think that, in general, 2 people would be more likely than 1 if a possibly unconscious or disabled Nancy was carried from her house and to a vehicle. If Nancy wasn't walking out herself, but was being carried out, that could explain the blood spatter. Whoever was carrying her out may have taken little care to prevent impacts to her body as she was being removed from the house.

It would be difficult for 1 person to carry her out - she's probably at least 100 pounds, probably more - and then get her into a vehicle. It is possible for 1 strong, likely male individual, but awkward. Doors need to be opened and closed. It could be done, but with 2 people it would much quicker and easier.

I lean against this being a real kidnapping. I think there was some kind of family dispute over money or inheritance, and violence occurred.

It's my opinion that Nancy is no longer alive, and that the kidnapping is some kind of hoax.

the original flyer said 150 pounds

 

[armchairagatha]

The POTUS has shed more info than LE so far. Of course, he has loose lips while LE is tightlipped as they should be if an arrest is imminent. It is interesting he says this is not a Search operation but a Solution.

(Not sure if TMZ can be linked but these are true statements from Trump on Air Force One)

President Trump Says Suspect Possibly ID'd in Nancy Guthrie Case

President Trump says the feds are getting closer to cracking the kidnapping case of Savannah Guthrie's mom Nancy ... and the FBI may even have a suspect!

www.tmz.com

 

[Friday Fan]

Pretty sure Tricia has mentioned Aphrodite Jones books on the YouTube channel. She may have been a guest at one time, but I don't remember for sure.

I have read some of her books. She used to have a show on Investigative Disovery.

 

[Sadi]

Because the family is staying there, the 3 siblings

Didn’t they also return there after the family left? I remember hearing that.

 

[lilyk]

There is no way a family member say in passenger seat helped this frail 84 year old woman who requires a cane to walk in just 120 seconds to unbuckle seat belt, grab her belongings in the car, help walk to garage door leading into home, say good bye to love one, then bolt back to car in order to shut garage door 120 seconds after opening. Does not add up

Yes it is. Assuming a VERY slow "fall risk" pace of 0.6 m/s or 2 ft/second, it would take 10 seconds to walk the depth of a standard 20' deep garage. If they parked another 20 feet from the exterior garage door on a level driveway, that would be 20 seconds total to walk 40' into the house. No one here knows her walking pace (which was likely faster than this example and especially if using an assistive device), nor if she was a fall risk when using the proper assistive device. We don't know if she could sit, turn, come to standing from the car seat then start walking immediately or if she needed do a safety 10 second pause once standing to let her blood pressure adjust. With a ten second pause that's still only 30 seconds to enter the house upon standing. They could have opened the garage door when approaching the house from down the street and it's still very possible.

We only know that she didn't have the endurance to walk long distances, as reported by the family. And surely no family would ever think to downplay her abilities and emphasize her frailties just a little to make the situation seem more serious or urgent.

Unbuckling a seatbelt for someone (if she even needed help with that), grabbing belongings (we don't know she even had) and saying goodnight in the car or while she walks to the door is a few seconds at best.

 

[SMK777]

same here.... i asked about how long it had been there a few days ago!

Can't find it now, but a poster up thread said they can tell how long it's been there; darker color would indicate longer time.

 

[Deleted member 117884]

Our ring camera setup is connected to a flood light outside of our garage. If it senses motion it turns on and records. LE may know the time the garage door opened and shut when NG returned home because she had a similar setup. If that flood light was smashed later they would not have info that the door was again opened later that night or early morning. Her car could have left and returned after the flood light was disabled.

That is a good point about the flood lights.

Way back when, and I mean way back when I was a older teen, I had a paper route and delivered papers before dawn. It was long before ring cameras on homes, but some houses had motion detectors and a bright light would turn on when I entered the yard.

It's a good point that a motion detectior might have turned on lights at NG's house and might even have been noticed by others since the area is pitch black at night.

And perhaps even NG's system recorded time of lights turning on. It might place someone in a specific area at a specific time.

Fingers crossed.

jmo

 

[Baba O'Riley]

Pretty sure Tricia has mentioned Aphrodite Jones books on the Websleuths YouTube channel. She may have been a guest at one time, but I don't remember for sure.

She was, One of her books was chosen and read for the WS Guardians book club.

 

[SaraSmile]

Please could someone link to or confirm where the white van is mentioned?

I’m sorry, I don’t have the link, but it was the neighbor, with near Nancy’s backyard. She mentioned it on about day 3, just guessing. Maybe someone knows how to find.

 

[turaj]

Because the family is staying there, the 3 siblings

I don't exactly get this because LE has to know exactly where to find all family members. Mulltiple reports are that they are not at AG's home anymore. So they wanted to go there for some other purpose.

 

[missy1974]

it is very ominous that the second message did not contain any proof of life. If they are going to the trouble and risk of sending a message they might as well have included some proof or evidence that she is alive (this could be something as simple as a fact or statement that only she would know).

The problem with that is, to me anyway. They can hide behine secure servers to send a message, but once you add attachments like a picture, video, audio, is that as secure? Yes info can be removed from them, but can the FBI recover that info? I don't know.

Same reason someone wouldn't leave a paper note at the house. That just leaves evidence behind.

All JMO

 

[dotr]

Feb 5 2026

Nancy Guthrie’s neighbor reported suspicious white van parked on block days before 84-year-old went missing

Neighbors of Nancy Guthrie reported spotting a suspicious white van parked on their street in the days before the 84-year-old vanished.

nypost.com

''TUSCON, Ariz. — Neighbors of Nancy Guthrie reported spotting a suspicious white van parked on their street in the days before the 84-year-old vanished.

Guthrie’s neighbor Brett McIntire told The Post on Thursday that he reported the unmarked van to the police, who asked him basic questions about what he observed in the days leading up to the disappearance of Savannah Guthrie’s 84-year-old mother.

“It was somewhere on that street. It was a white van, full-sized, with no printing on the sides. It was parked on the street,” said McIntire, who lives across from Nancy.

“Normally people that are coming to work on your home will have a company vehicle or if they’re independent, something written on it,” the 72-year-old added. ''

 

[birdbox]

Good question. My thoughts at this very moment, based only on what we know from the outside, I would pay it.

However, deep down I wouldn’t believe I was getting my mom back alive.

I would also feel like there wasn’t anything substantial for me to confirm they really had her without verified proof of life. But, I could not live with the “what if “ I suppose. I would also have to live with the fact, not having her returned alive, that I made a major donation to a crime network. IMO

I would have paid it days ago personally.

 

[flp]

The problem with that is, to me anyway. They can hide behine secure servers to send a message, but once you add attachments like a picture, video, audio, is that as secure? Yes info can be removed from them, but can the FBI recover that info? I don't know.

Same reason someone wouldn't leave a paper note at the house. That just leaves evidence behind.

All JMO

What i meant is there are so many things i could include in a message that only my family would know (not attachments or pictures, just random facts that would prove it is me that only they would know)

 

[thefragile7393]

The POTUS has shed more info than LE so far. Of course, he has loose lips while LE is tightlipped as they should be if an arrest is imminent. It is interesting he says this is not a Search operation but a Solution.

(Not sure if TMZ can be linked but these are true statements from Trump on Air Force One)

President Trump Says Suspect Possibly ID'd in Nancy Guthrie Case

President Trump says the feds are getting closer to cracking the kidnapping case of Savannah Guthrie's mom Nancy ... and the FBI may even have a suspect!

www.tmz.com

the POTUS is not a reliable source of factual information on many things, IMO