AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[No_Stone_Unturned]

CNN has FBI video footage from Nancy’s front door.

 

[whitelilac]

Wasn't it said in the beginning that a camera picked up a figure, movement, inside the home? Maybe that's the next video to be released.

 

[Athos65]

My opinion:
two pairs of gloves, the hands are moving oddly for someone wearing only nitrile or latex gloves so an added layer with, perhaps, knitted gloves. This might be to prevent leaving fingerprints once the gloves we're seeing are discarded.
The same goes for the clothes. I am thinking two layers so that the ones that might show on camera can be easily discarded and the appearance can be changed.
There is something feminine about the eyes and lips. The mustache looks too groomed to be real. The selection of a mask with two different shades around the eyes is to create the impression that the person might be male or female, but there's something on the upper lashes (moving to the outside of the eyes) that makes me think of rimmel...mascara.
As the person leans forward (quite awkwardly so the contents of the backpack might be heavy?) to pick up the greenery, they look back. This person was probably not alone, but was the person assigned to enter the home while the other idled the engine.

I see a weapon tucked into the front of the waistband, but I might be mistaken.

All my opinions.

 

[Ur728]

Two of his band mates/associates- could match the suspects physical features in my opinion.
View attachment 643330View attachment 643331

I’ve been suspecting the bandmate for quite some time. Has a history of criminal behaviors.

 

[dogmom805]

I wonder if they recovered this footage in the backlog, what about the other cameras in and around the house they spoke of? Is this all they have, or just the best view for the public to identify?

 

[clearskies1]

No way it should take this long to get this from the front door cam. #$%! Is this the fault of the door cam company?

 

[Jenny9]

When I worked NYC/Brooklyn it was very common trend in the lat likea gang in community. Sharpie eyebrows we'd call them. Some of the rookies I worked with were Puerto Rican and they'd all have them and we'd laugh about it.

Actually looks like a gang member

 

[Tortoise]

These are the flowers he picked, on the left as you look at the house

timestamp 7.06

 

[Vaderman]

respectively, as long as i've been on this site, there has never been a correct guess to a suspect's gender when they are in "disguise". i remember when many members said the devil's den murder suspect looked female before they identified the actual alleged culprit.

For sure.

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

So this seems to be a true planned break in/kidnapping/assault of some sort.

Or...could be planned and staged to make it look like that. To cover something else that happened prior. MOO.

If he were hired, wouldn't he have staked out NG's property and anticipated the nest cam. He doesn't seem to have expected the nest cam.

 

[Wishbone]

He looks like a professional hitman.

he is certainly suited up enough to not leave a trace of himself for LE to find.....

 

[shonyakay]

Was he trying to smash the camera?

I see the lantana in the upper left still frame.

 

[stmichael]

To me, one of the most unique characteristics of this unsub is the holster/gun. The placement right in front of the groin is very very distinct in my opinion. Never seen that in my life. Hope LE will go to local gun ranges and ask about folks who use that set up/type of gun. Also, he does reach for the gun/holster to adjust/confirm it's stable i think. Sort of an involuntary motion. MOO

As a gun guy who used one for years on the job, it's weird in a number of ways.

-The holster doesn't seem to match the sidearm, the gun looks more like a poly late gen semi auto and it's stuffed in a holster that profiles for a longer gun with a shape of a revolver like a Colt python for instance. Too hard to truly tell w/ the pic/ darkness, but it looks off.

-Also a light-colored holster, usually a burglar would go all black (same w/ reflective stripes on a backpack??? It's a weird detail but again a bit wonky or "thrown-together" in his get up, much easier to get darker leather or kydex etc.

-in the earlier frames he is not open carrying. he pulls the holster out front and center over his crotch (right hand orientation) as he approaches the door - indicating he wants it to be seen then. His hand does seem to hover in ready position then, though it could be a threat posture or like you said involuntary.

 

[dogmom805]

I’ve been suspecting the bandmate for quite some time. Has a history of criminal behaviors.

I looked at the images immediately and I agree of the likeness.

 

[desert-blue]

I don't see the backpack or gun in this photo? Is it just not good resolution? Or did the perp go to the door once and then go get his stuff and come back? No timestamps.
Edit: Upon closer inspection, I think the gun is to the side instead of in front.

 

[iamthewalrus]

he could be a friend or business associate of family or hired. This guy looks hired to me.

A bandmate.....?

 

[Yellowbunny2]

Reported on the channel I am watching to be the most important video is coming. IDK what that means until we see it.

What channel is that?

 

[Sadi]

Noticed the backpack was full, too. Definitely not a robbery. What would be in the backpack?

Bag big enough to fit her in to be able to carry her? Makes me wonder now if the ransom is true? How would they know she was going to be home that night? How were they so sure? And how did they know what tools to bring? And the camera thankfully captured them.

 

[Mauritius]

if he's the one who removed the camera, it would take more time to tape over it and then remove the tape/camera together.

My impression - he keeps not covering the camera part, his fist at first is aiming above it? If that makes sense. So he maybe didn’t know where the camera part was vs the light (?) on it. Not super familiar with how they work? So ended up just taking it.

 

[MassGuy]

https://twitter.com/x/status/2021292239465611722