Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

A connection if you consider Mile Marker 230 as possible location to find NG.

Quote:
He maketh me to lie down in green pastures: he leadeth me beside the still waters.
GOOGLE EARTH showing one of the green areas:
View attachment 649540

GOOGLE EARTH, all areas around MM230:

View attachment 649541


Quote:
Yea,though I walk through the valley of the shadow..
The Sonara Desert consists of broad, flat desert valleys separated by numerous, long, narrow mountain ranges.
Quote:
Of death, I will fear no evil..

Self explanatory..

ALL IMO

-Nin

This area seems quite plausible, and for the perp to plan a place that connects with SG's talk of Psalm 23 in her book makes a lot of sense.

Especially if we think about this guy as somebody who wanted to be seen as important and clever.

MOO

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

Do not feel comfortable doing it. But thanks.

-Nin

Totally understand.

 

[VeronicaVaughn]

Southern Arizona is very dry, rugged territory. Lakes/ponds are few and far between. The closest lake of any size is 2 and a half hours north and in the middle of a reservation, not a likely place for this purpose. I agree that one would certainly want to get rid of the evidence that could get you at least locked up for life as quickly and closely as possible. The vastness and baroness of the local terrain is something most people can't comprehend until they see it first hand.

Respectfully, I disagree. Rose Canyon Lake is just over an hour from NG's home. It is part of Coronado National Forest, though, and the gates are closed during the winter months so access would be more difficult, but probably not impossible. The forest itself is 1.7 MILLION acres.

https://www.fs.usda.gov/r03/coronado/recreation/rose-canyon-lake

https://www.fs.usda.gov/r03/coronado

 

[FaviousM]

Which nasty story are you referencing here? I went back to Cryptic's post but didn't see it.

The Epstein stuff. Some people have posited that her covering the victims could be motivation for some sort of 'silencing' attempt from powerful entities.

I don't buy it myself but a lot of important people are implicated and could, in theory, be capable of that sort of thing

 

[turaj]

I admit to following the case closely but not this forum for the last couple of weeks. With media going away (except for BE )and family leaving and resources downsized not much news coming out. Not even a weekly presser. I sort of feel they have a suspect and just not enough evidence to charge yet. What I really want t o know is why is Nancy's car returned and Annie's still considered "evidence"?

 

[wibbleflea]

What I really want t o know is why is Nancy's car returned and Annie's still considered "evidence"?

Has NG’s been returned?

 

[Napoli]

I’m not quite following the thought process of buying a hyper realistic silicone mask only to cover it in a ski mask. Not judging at all, just haven’t yet seen an explanation that satisfies me.

When I google the use of silicone masks by criminals, generally it appears that the realistic masks are used as the main mask to disguise and distract from their features. If anything, the ski mask on top would serve to accentuate the shape of the head (I do recall theories about padding, yes). And a basic latex mask underneath would be cheaper and serve basically the same purpose, aside from possibly altering the appearance of the eyes? MOO.

I dunno. Apologies and appreciation in advance.

I am thinking that there was something under the ski mask. Remember how an intruder would put a nylon stocking over his face and the features could be so distorted? I am thinking a thin something or other under the ski mask is definitely a possibility. Used for protection against DNA shedding and facial feature distortion. Additionally and as an aside, I do think he looks like the bridge of his nose is slender...if that matters in identification. I dunno. JMO

 

[SaraSmile]

Given that the perp planned and executed this crime so carefully, I would imagine that the perp had a solid plan in place for where to get rid of NG's body. And, I would also think that he wouldn't want to be driving around very long with NG's body in the car.

Yes, there was a lot of rain in January in Tucson. But, either way, the perp likely considered a lake or small body of water.

Re Perp had a place to take NG’s body.
Since he maybe drove down Camino Real to leave foothills, then, maybe, got on River road, then freeway, East side of town, then to desert. If this was his route, she may be somewhere east of town.
He probably is a younger person, who has hiked, ridden bikes, taken ATV to his own meaningful, hidden spots in the desert. I wish locals, or the Cajun Navy would look at special, local, desert areas East of town.
Remember Strava, outdoor app? Kaitlin Armstrong used this app, to see where Mo and Colin were. Perhaps locals use, could point to Desert hideaway spots.
JMO

 

[factseeking]

The Epstein stuff. Some people have posited that her covering the victims could be motivation for some sort of 'silencing' attempt from powerful entities.

I don't buy it myself but a lot of important people are implicated and could, in theory, be capable of that sort of thing

I see, thanks!

My thoughts on that are a lot of other people have exposed or pushed for exposure of Epstein's "clients" since 2019 when SG interviewed survivors. I just don't see why someone who wanted to punish someone for the explosion of information would go all the way back to 2019 and hold her accountable instead of many others who were catalysts for the file release.

I realize though I'm applying logic to a person whose mind is twisted but JMO if this is a Savannah thing it's about something else.

 

[stmichael]

It's not black and white, it's IR, which means you can't estimate colour. What looks like depth of colour is more about absorption and reflectivity of the IR light. If what I've read on here I've understood correctly. Please, science nerds, correct me if I'm wrong. The light spectrum and its photography are not my areas.

MOO

How Do IR and Color Night Vision Compare in Outdoor Security Cameras?

The primary difference between IR and color night vision is that IR (Infrared) night vision uses infrared light to produce a black-and-white image in low-light and total darkness, while color night vision uses advanced sensors and supplemental lighting to reproduce full-color images at night. IR...

www.botslab.com

 

[Napoli]

2 things. The whites of your eyes are the whites of your eyes. Can we infer from the photo below that light things become darker and dark things become lighter due to infa-red? Secondly, could that be a taser in the perp's pocket and not a walkie talkie as some have opined? Jmo ( I cant find the pocket photo) TY
View attachment 649548

 

[you betcha]

Plus on a purely practical level, a hyper-realistic silicone mask seems like it would be a) expensive (doesn't track with other gear coming from cheaper places like Walmart), b) easier to trace the purchase of, and c) in combination with a ski mask, probably hot, sweaty and generally uncomfortable, even on a relatively cool night

Just look for an idiot creep with heat rash bumps all over his head.

 

[turaj]

Has NG’s been returned?

I heard that from a couple of reports so no concrete quote on that. EVen if it had not I would understand as it was at the crime scene. But Annie and her husband have been "cleared" and yet no car returned. Maureen who is often on with BE said normally cars are processed and returned fairly quickly. It has been weeks.

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

Re Perp had a place to take NG’s body.
Since he maybe drove down Camino Real to leave foothills, then, maybe, got on River road, then freeway, East side of town, then to desert. If this was his route, she may be somewhere east of town.
He probably is a younger person, who has hiked, ridden bikes, taken ATV to his own meaningful, hidden spots in the desert. I wish locals, or the Cajun Navy would look at special, local, desert areas East of town.
Remember Strava, outdoor app? Kaitlin Armstrong used this app, to see where Mo and Colin were. Perhaps locals use, could point to Desert hideaway spots.
JMO

And somewhere where he could easily drop her off directly off of a road that he was driving. I'm also thinking east and/or northeast of town since that's convenient and has some fairly isolated places.

If LE had some suspects from Walmart, gun shop and/or other places, that could possibly help them focus on particular areas where the perp might live, if he lives in Tucson.

Since he planned everything fairly meticulously (e.g. doing this crime on the night of a full moon, covering himself so completely as to avoid shedding DNA or recognition), it seems he would have spent a lot of time planning a perfect spot to leave NG. And, the closer to NG's house and to his route to his home, the better.

JMO

 

[turaj]

I am struck by the lack of unified community involvement in support for the Guthrie family. To my knowledge only one small church service way back when. SG was so very proud of Tucson her home town and yet where is the support? YT streamers have been the only organizers and those had no turnout from the community. I am really wondering if the average Tucson resident has. even heard of this kidnapping?

 

[SaraSmile]

This area seems quite plausible, and for the perp to plan a place that connects with SG's talk of Psalm 23 in her book makes a lot of sense.

Especially if we think about this guy as somebody who wanted to be seen as important and clever.

MOO

Good ideas about Psalm 23. Maybe some literal reference for perp, placement of body.

Just a thought, by the time SG spoke of Psalm 23, NG’s body had probably already been placed in its resting spot.

IMO, Psalm 23 is many Christians’ favorite verse, as it speaks to fear, that God will always be with us, to strengthen us, no matter what happens in life, and even in death.

I think the Psalm 23 reference was made by SG, because SG and NG bonded so much over their Christian faith. SG wanted to include, as a prayer for NG, if she was still alive, or for herself & family if NG had passed.

JMO

 

[Napoli]

Re Perp had a place to take NG’s body.
Since he maybe drove down Camino Real to leave foothills, then, maybe, got on River road, then freeway, East side of town, then to desert. If this was his route, she may be somewhere east of town.

He probably is a younger person, who has hiked, ridden bikes, taken ATV to his own meaningful, hidden spots in the desert. I wish locals, or the Cajun Navy would look at special, local, desert areas East of town.

Remember Strava, outdoor app? Kaitlin Armstrong used this app, to see where Mo and Colin were. Perhaps locals use, could point to Desert hideaway spots.
JMO

BBM Look, lol, I get lost backing out of the driveway so east and west are meaningless to me. HOWEVER, some of you live in the area and even more have a mental built in compass that I dont possess. How about this in regards to Psalm 23? TYIA MOO
Agua Caliente Park on the far east side of Tucson is the premier spot forpastures and ponds, featuring a 100-acre oasis with three spring-fed, restored ponds and historic ranch grounds. Other key spots forponds and wetlands include Sweetwater Wetlands for birdingReid Park for alake/fountain, and Silverbell Lake at Christopher Columbus Park.

YouTube +3

 

[factseeking]

I am struck by the lack of unified community involvement in support for the Guthrie family. To my knowledge only one small church service way back when. SG was so very proud of Tucson her home town and yet where is the support? YT streamers have been the only organizers and those had no turnout from the community. I am really wondering if the average Tucson resident has. even heard of this kidnapping?

Are you talking about searching for Nancy or some other kind of support?

 

[moonglow123]

I am struck by the lack of unified community involvement in support for the Guthrie family. To my knowledge only one small church service way back when. SG was so very proud of Tucson her home town and yet where is the support? YT streamers have been the only organizers and those had no turnout from the community. I am really wondering if the average Tucson resident has. even heard of this kidnapping?

People did put up beautiful displays of flowers, and notes of love and prayers outside of Nancy's house.

The Message of Hope Nancy Guthrie’s Neighbors Are Sending With Yellow Ribbons and Flowers

Nancy Guthrie’s community outside Tucson, Arizona, is praying for her safe return.

www.today.com

Nanos pretty much asked people not to arrange their own search parties, I think that's why we haven't seen much of that

 

[SaraSmile]

BBM Look, lol, I get lost backing out of the driveway so east and west are meaningless to me. HOWEVER, some of you live in the area and even more have a mental built in compass that I dont possess. How about this in regards to Psalm 23? TYIA MOO
Agua Caliente Park on the far east side of Tucson is the premier spot forpastures and ponds, featuring a 100-acre oasis with three spring-fed, restored ponds and historic ranch grounds. Other key spots forponds and wetlands include Sweetwater Wetlands for birdingReid Park for alake/fountain, and Silverbell Lake at Christopher Columbus Park.
View attachment 649556YouTube +3

Yes, that looks like a good area to check for NG! I wonder if there are cameras?
JMO