Hmmm... huge problem here... please help me, sleuthers, because I'm stumped.
Most of the info here from the FBI interviews as well as the OCSO interviews. A little info from elsewhere such as Casey/Amy text messages. I've gone back to verify info and to answer some questions. I still have some questions. As I said though, I'm stumped!
George says:
* June 24 - Casey came to the house, he asked for the tool out of the trunk of her car, walked with Casey to the car, Casey took the gas cans out of the trunk and gave them to him. Question: did he ever say if Cindy was at the house that day?
* one day between June 24 and June 30 when the car was towed
- Casey called Cindy and asked to borrow her car. Cindy said yes.
- Casey came to the house, alone, in her car to pick up Cindy's car
- Cindy and George were home
- Cindy gave Casey the keys to her (Cindy's) car
- Casey drove off
- George said he was going to follow Casey. Cindy told George not to. George followed Casey anyway.
- Question: did George return home after losing Casey and giving up the chase?
- Casey came back, alone, left Cindy's car and picked up her own car.
- Casey did the car return/pick-up late afternoon or evening
- Question: why no mention from Cindy or George of the decomp smell from Casey's car?
- Question: what date did Casey begin mentioning the decomp smell to others? I know she mentioned on June 27 to Amy H that she had gotten rid of the smell.
- Did Cindy or George look in Casey's car that afternoon? George wanted very much to know what was going on with Casey, that's why he followed her that day. He had keys to Casey's car. Wouldn't the curiosity that prompted him to follow her also prompt him to open up Casey's car while it was in the driveway of their house and Casey was gone?
Cindy says:
- June 16 - Casey stayed at Zanny's
- June 17 - Casey stayed at Zanny's
- June 18 through July 3 - Casey was out of town
If Cindy's claims that Casey said she was out of town June 18 through July 3 are true, then George's claim about Casey borrowing Cindy's car and him chasing her and Cindy telling him not to chase her between June 24 and June 30 is one big fat lie. He remembers dates and details so well, but claims not to remember the date this happened except that it was *definitely* between June 24 and June 30. His voice/mannerisms are funny to me when he says he can't remember the exact date.
Question: what do the pings tell us about when this could have happened?
I think George is telling the truth about the incident because I can't think of a reason for him to make it up.
------- My theory (my opinion, my speculation): --------
Cindy didn't want George to tell LE or FBI about this incident. Why? Well, it looks to me that she's lying about the Casey out of town stories which she uses for her 'theories' that just happen to occur to her the night before she's going to meet with the FBI. And what's she doing with the FBI? Well, she couldn't convince OCSO that Casey had nothing to do with Caylee's murder, so she's desperately trying to convince the FBI that Casey had nothing to do with Caylee's murder by telling the FBI a big long winded tale of theories that all put Caylee out of town.
In other words, she doesn't believe her 'theories' and her 'clues' herself. She stayed up and concocted them specifically to try to throw the FBI (and later OCSO) off track with them. She just never expected George to throw her under the bus and tell anybody about Casey borrowing the car.
So now we have Cindy deliberately fabricating lies to tell the FBI and OCSO to cover up Casey murdering Caylee, and that, my friends, as you know, is obstruction of justice.
No wonder Cindy didn't to swear what she'd said was the truth in the OCSO interview!!!
--- End of my theory, opinion, speculation ----
(Just trying to make it crystal clear that I am not accusing anyone of anything, but simply presenting some of my thoughts in an effort to clarify this information for myself.)
Okay. So that's what's on my mind. What's up with all this? What are your thoughts/opinions? I can't figure this one out.
ETA: lol looks like others are already digging into this!
Do we have a date for the ladder up on the pool and the gate open? That date puts Cindy home and if I recall correctly, George was at work and Cindy called him and yelled at him for leaving the ladder up.
