NJ NJ - Jean Diggs, 39, & four children, ages 5-17, Teaneck, 6 Dec 1975

wfgodot

Former Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
30,164
Reaction score
148,218
  • #1
NorthJersey.com:

Who killed the Diggs family? 40-year-old mass murder in Teaneck remains mystery

---
In the small hours of Saturday, Dec. 6, 1975, Jean Diggs and her four children were murdered in their brick-and-stucco home at 266 Carlton Terrace, the largest mass killing in Bergen County history. All had bullet wounds to the head from a .22-caliber automatic pistol wielded by someone who moved stealthily through the colonial-style house.
---
Jean, a 39-year-old Avon lady, was slumped on a bench in the basement rec room. Seventeen-year-old Audrey; 16-year-old Allison; and the boys, 12-year-old Wesley Jr. and 5-year-old Roger, were upstairs in their beds. The neighbors heard nothing on a chilly night when windows were shut tight. There was no forced entry. No sign of struggle. No disarray.

From the beginning, the case baffled investigators.
---
much more at link above
 
  • #2
I had never heard of this case. My first thought was that the murders were tied to the husbands business dealings. In reading the article this was brought out. That is the only theory that makes a lot of sense. I also thought it might've been a hate crime. But I don't put a lot of weight in that because the father was not targeted. So that leads me back to his business dealings.
 
  • #3
No surpise that the neighbors didn't hear anything since a .22 is not that loud. A .22 shot to the head is a standard mob or spy type killing but I don't know if this family could have had any issues in that regard.
 
  • #4
No surpise that the neighbors didn't hear anything since a .22 is not that loud. A .22 shot to the head is a standard mob or spy type killing but I don't know if this family could have had any issues in that regard.

I can't think of any case where the mob went after a guy's kids and only one possible case (Estelle Carey-1943) where they may have killed a woman to get back at a man so that's an angle we can pretty much eliminate.
 
  • #5
I just heard about this case. Devastating. Is the father still alive?
 
  • #6
Wesley Diggs died in 1987. I wonder if the "other women in his life" were married. Tragic story. I suspect the husband/father is the murderer. Seems he liked to spend time away from his family. Maybe he saw them as a burden. MOO

SNIP:

"Wesley Diggs, who lived out his years in Manhattan and fathered a daughter in 1981, joined the family plot in 1987."

"The slender, goateed businessman would admit to having other women in his life and that he often stayed nights in New York rather than with his wife and kids in Teaneck."

There was a book about the case written by Bob Chase. Interesting comments on Amazon.

http://www.amazon.com/Diggs-Bob-Chase/dp/B0032QA41Y/ref=cm_rdp_product
 
  • #7
There are so many parallels between this case and the DeFeo family murders on Long Island in 1974; a large family shot to death, no signs of struggle, no one heard anything. And the victims shot in their own rooms. DeFeo admitted drugging his family before he shot them. Were there any tests for drugs in the bodies of Mrs. Diggs and her children?
 
  • #8
Northjersey Facebook post 12/6/2015 but unfortunately the original link is no longer available.

NorthJersey.com

In the small hours of Saturday, Dec. 6, 1975, Jean Diggs and her four children were murdered in their brick-and-stucco home at 266 Carlton Terrace, the largest mass killing in Bergen County history.
 
  • #9
NYTimes article in 1975

Mother, 4 Children Are Shot to Death In Home in Teaneck

TEANECK, N.J., Dec. 6—A mother and her four children were shot to death today in their home in this suburban Bergen County community.

The bodies were discovered late this afternoon by the father, Wesley Diggs. The victims were found scattered throughout their white stucco and red brick home on a quiet street here.

Late this evening, the police said they had no suspects or any explanation for the killings.

The victims were identified as Jean Diggs, 39, and the children—Audrey, 19; Allison, 16; Wesley Jr., 12, and Roger, 5.

Their bodies were found at approximately 4 P.M. when Mr. Diggs, who was returning from New York, entered the home and discovered one of his daughters, reportedly Audrey, lying on an upstairs bedroom floor.

According to the police, Mr. Diggs ran next door and asked for help from the Edward Murphy family.

“My daughter's been hurt!” he shouted. “Call an ambulance!”

Mrs. Murphy and her two daughters, one of them a nurse, ran from their home at 270 Carleton Terrace across the driveway and into the Diggs home at 266.

The nurse went upstairs and came down moments later, shaken and pale.

“Mary, she's dead, she's dead,” she told her sister.

Then the grim discoveries continued. The two sons, Roger and Wesley, were found in a bedroom.

Mrs. Diggs was then found in the finished basement. Finally, the body of the second daughter, Allison, was found in another bedroom upstairs. All apparently had been shot in the back of the head.

The police said there were no signs of a struggle. No weapon was immediately found and police interviews with neighbors failed to elicit any new evidence.

Chief Robert E. Fitzpatrick of the Teaneck police, a veteran of 40 years of police work in the county, said it was the worst crime of his career.

Township and county police officials were conducting a joint investigation of the murder. Mr. Diggs was taken to police headquarters about a mile away, from which he was released around midnight. The bodies of the five victims were removed from the cordoned‐off Diggs home to the county morgue.

According to neighbors, the Diggses were one of the first black families to move to Carleton Terrace, arriving there about six years ago. Other black families have moved in since, and the neighborhood as well as the township enjoys a reputation of having achieved racial equanimity.

One neighbor described the Diggses as “extremely friendly and well‐received.”

“Jean Diggs was a charming, charming woman—I can't believe anyone would want to harm her,” a neighbor said.

Officials said that Mr. Diggs was the proprietor of Diggs' Den, a Harlem tavern at 320 West 145th Street, and also ran a gift shop, the location of which was not given. According to friends, Mr. Diggs's work kept him away from his family about 18 hours a day.
 
  • #10
  • #11
More at the link.

"Who Killed the Diggs Family?" by Levin, Jay - The Record (Bergen County, NJ), December 6, 2015 | Online Research Library: Questia

Like all cold cases in Bergen County, the Diggs murders are reviewed periodically by the Prosecutor's Office, most recently two or three years ago, Prosecutor John Molinelli said.

"With advances in DNA, we always see if there is anything we can pull from hard evidence," he said, adding that no DNA was captured in the Diggs matter.

The best hope with a case this old, Molinelli said, is that someone with information or a throbbing conscience will come forward, perhaps in a deathbed confession. That hasn't happened.

"We never forget them and we continue to look at them," Molinelli said about such cases.

Memorial award

Many people, even in Teaneck, have never heard of the Diggs murders. Or if they were residing in Teaneck 40 years ago, the details have faded. Township historian Larry Robertson, a retired deputy fire chief, said that until a reporter's call, he hadn't thought about the crime "for years."

Cheryl Miller-Porter hasn't forgotten. The retired Teaneck High School physical education teacher, who still coaches girls track, continues to perpetuate the memory of the Diggses, the first African- American family on the quiet Carlton Terrace block when they arrived from Harlem in 1970.

Miller-Porter presents the Audrey Diggs Memorial Award at the annual high school sports dinner. The recipient is a senior girl athlete "who is very supportive of her teammates and always places the welfare of the team first." Until 2009, the high school also gave a graduating senior a monetary Diggs Memorial Scholarship.

Audrey played volleyball, basketball and softball and was president of the Girls Athletic Association.

"She wasn't the MVP of any team," Miller-Porter said. Rather, she was a caring, well-rounded young woman and dedicated "gym rat."

When presenting the trophy, Miller-Porter tells how Audrey and her siblings and their mother had their lives taken away.
 
  • #12
45 Years ago...

episode179image.png


The Diggs Family Murders 6 December 1975


In 1970, businessman Wesley Diggs and his wife, Jean, moved their family from Harlem to the small town of Teaneck, New Jersey. Although they were the first African-American family in the neighborhood, their neighbors were friendly, and the Diggses became an essential part of the community. Their teenage daughter, Audrey, was a star athlete, and Jean often brought the other children—Allison, Wesley Jr., and Roger—to Audrey’s games.

Wesley, the owner of two Harlem taverns, was a busy man who usually worked up to 18 hours a day. Due to his work schedule, Wesley wasn’t home much and sometimes stayed the night in New York. On the afternoon of December 6, 1975, Wesley came home from work and found Audrey “hurt” in her bedroom.

After he ran outside screaming for help, a neighbor who worked as a nurse checked Audrey and discovered that she was dead. They called the police. As the house was searched, the bodies of the other four family members were found in three separate rooms: Jean in the basement, Allison in the attic, and the boys in their shared bedroom.

The younger children were found in their pajamas, leading investigators to believe that they might have been killed the previous night. Somebody who was familiar with the house might have slipped in and ambushed the family as they were getting ready for bed.

Some members of the community suggested that Wesley, who wasn’t home that night and later passed a lie detector test, might have known more than he let on to the police. Richard Kazinci, the lead investigator on the case, speculated that it was a revenge killing by somebody trying to get back at Wesley.

Wesley, however, insisted that he had told the authorities everything he knew. Annoyed at public suspicion that he was the killer, Wesley expressed harsh disappointment with how the investigation was conducted. At one point, he asked for the FBI to be brought in. His request was denied. He died in 1985, never knowing exactly what happened to his family.

LINKS:

10 Tragic Unsolved Cases Of Murdered Families - Listverse

The Trail Went Cold – Episode 179 – The Diggs Family Murders – The Trail Went Cold

Mother, 4 Children Are Shot to Death In Home in Teaneck (Published 1975)

Cold Cases Cracked: Teaneck, NJ - Diggs Family Murders

"Who Killed the Diggs Family?" by Levin, Jay - The Record (Bergen County, NJ), December 6, 2015 | Online Research Library: Questia

The 1975 Murders of the Diggs Family: A Mother and Her Four Children Are Shot to Death Inside Their Suburban Home : UnresolvedMysteries

Unsolved massacre of mother and 4 children in Teaneck NJ
 
  • #13
  • #14
I just watched the movie, "American Wispers", which is based on the Diggs family murders. Very loosely based I would've said. They changed the family's last name, the year it happened and the number of children involved. At the conclusion however, the photos of the 3 oldest Diggs children were shown onscreen before the credits rolled. Why little Roger was not acknowledged or portrayed in the film, I don't know. The ending is...unexpected and I won't spoil it, but it would give an explanation as to why the police stopped investigating. They would already know who did it but since they can't prove it, there is nothing more they can do. Just in case, MOO.
 
  • #15
This unsolved multiple murder case will be 50 years old in December.
 
  • #16
Lengthy article.
  • Dec. 15, 2025 rbbm
1765806862931.webp

The house on Carleton Terrace in Teaneck where Jean Diggs and her four children were slain looks much the same today from the outside as it did 50 years ago.Richard Cowen/NJ Advance Media for NJ.Com
1765806906792.webp

Wesley Diggs (left) with his mother, Thelma, during burial services at George Washington Memorial Park in Paramus on Dec. 13, 1975, a week after his family was slain in their home in Teaneck.Photo by Margaret M. Grieve

''Wesley Diggs said he never knew who killed his wife and four children inside their Teaneck home in December 1975 — a claim he would take to his grave 12 years later when he died of a heart attack.''

'Diggs returned to his home on Carlton Terrace late in the afternoon of Dec. 6, 1975, to find his entire family – wife Jean, 39, daughters Audrey, 17, and Allison, 16, and sons Wesley Jr., 12, and Roger, 5 – dead from multiple gunshot wounds.'

Initially deemed the prime suspect, Diggs passed two lie detector tests after the killings and was cleared by the Bergen County Prosecutor’s Office.

''Still, suspicions swirled around Diggs, an entrepreneur who owned four bars with his brother, plus a card store and two apartment buildings in Harlem. Many wondered if he was somehow involved through his bar businesses, and Diggs spent the rest of his life trying to clear his name.''

''But 50 years later, the Diggs case is as cold as the ground in George Washington Memorial Park in Paramus where Diggs is buried next to his wife and four children.

''Maureen Parenta, a spokeswoman for the Bergen County Prosecutor’s Office, acknowledged the trail was cold. But she said the investigation remains “active,” and anyone with information can call investigators at 201-226-5532.'
 
  • #17
50 years ago this family was murdered and the case is still unsolved.
 
  • #18
Do the number of times each family member was shot, represent how many bullets it took to kill that particular person? Were some shot more than others due to the gunman's animosity toward that person?
Wondering why 17 yr old Audrey was shot 5X, could the perp be a highschooler? speculation, imo, fwiw..
1977
''Mrs. Diggs, 39 years old, was shot twice; a daughter, Audrey, 17, was shot five times; another daughter, Allison, 16, twice; Wesley Jr., 12, twice, and Roger, 5, once.''
1765814333651.webp

 
  • #19
Do the number of times each family member was shot, represent how many bullets it took to kill that particular person? Were some shot more than others due to the gunman's animosity toward that person?
Wondering why 17 yr old Audrey was shot 5X, could the perp be a highschooler? speculation, imo, fwiw..
1977
''Mrs. Diggs, 39 years old, was shot twice; a daughter, Audrey, 17, was shot five times; another daughter, Allison, 16, twice; Wesley Jr., 12, twice, and Roger, 5, once.''
View attachment 630810
It is difficult to draw solid conclusions based on simply the number of shots. While the fact that Audrey was shot 5 times with the others one or two times might indicate that the perpetrator was more focused on her, it could mean also that he was a poor shot or that she fought back more, or that some bullets may have passed through two victims.

Analysis of the scene and the wounds might give a better picture of the order of events and the perpetrator's intentions.
 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
73
Guests online
1,281
Total visitors
1,354

Forum statistics

Threads
636,040
Messages
18,689,099
Members
243,497
Latest member
justanaddict
Back
Top