NY NY - Kristin O’Connell, 20, found nude with multiple stab wounds & slashed throat, Ovid, Aug 1985

Joined
Oct 21, 2009
Messages
56,509
Reaction score
167,488
Lengthy article.
New York State Police decline outside help from docuseries team in 1985 unsolved murder of Kristin O’Connell
Aug. 14, 2021
By Andrea Cavallier
kristin_oconnell_article_art.png

Kristin O'Connell and her parents, Phyllis and Mike O'Connell. Photo provided by family.

''When 20-year-old Kristin O’Connell asked if she could travel to New York to visit a young man she had met while on Spring Break in Florida months earlier, her mother’s first instinct was to say no.

But Phyllis O’Connell knew deep down that her only daughter wasn’t a child anymore. She was nearly 21. And she was sensible. Responsible. Phyllis told Dateline that despite her misgivings about the trip, she realized she had to let her go.''

''The Burnsville, Minnesota native had just completed her sophomore year at the University of Wisconsin Stout in Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin, where she had been studying Hotel and Restaurant Management.''

"It was on that trip that Kristin met a young man named James “Jim” Vermeersch - and was charmed by him from the moment he approached her. The two developed a friendship and it wasn’t long before he invited her to visit him in Ovid, New York.

Kristin and Jim stayed in touch and just before the start of her junior year, made plans for her to travel from Minnesota to New York and stay at his parents’ house. Again, Kristin’s mother was hesitant.''

''Kristin had only been in New York for two days when she called her mother from a payphone and told her she was cutting her trip short.

“Something wasn’t right in her voice,” Phyllis told Dateline. “I asked if she was having a good time, but I should’ve pressed harder.”

That same night, Kristin disappeared.

According to the New York State Police, Kristin was at a party at the mobile home where Jim was living on County Road 139, just west of the Golden Buck Restaurant, in Ovid.

Witnesses told police that it was around 11:30 p.m. when they saw Kristin walking down County Road 139, heading west. She was not wearing shoes or carrying a purse.

The next morning, when Kristin failed to return to Jim’s house, he called her parents and the police to report her missing.''

''On August 16, their worst fears came true. A search party found Kristin’s naked body in a nearby cornfield, less than a quarter of a mile away from the trailer where she had been staying. Her clothes were in a pile nearby.

Kristin had been stabbed multiple times, and her throat had been slashed, according to an investigation by the New York State Police.''

"There are 318 pieces of physical evidence in this case, which includes the victim’s bloodstained sweater and pants, a pillowcase, a painter’s hat, the victim’s fingernails containing unidentified fibers, and a couple of hundred hairs, two of which were found near her pubis. Kristin’s investigation is hampered by a lack of time and a lack of money."

''Anyone with information about Kristin’s case is asked to call the New York State Police Troop E, Major Crimes Unit, at (585) 398-4100''
 
Jun 28, 2021
https://www.fingerlakesdailynews.com/2021/06/28/oconnell-story/
screenshot-2021-06-28-justice-for-kristin-oconnell-organized-by-the-kristin-oconnell-foundation.png

Kristen O'Connell
''Now, a Los Angeles TV producer, Christopher Pavlick, is working on a true-crime documentary series on O’Connell’s murder, but he says he is not getting any help from the New York State Police.
Pavlick says his team is offering a state-of-the-art forensics lab to test all the evidence. A cold case team headed by a former FBI agent has also offered their time to work with State Police.

Kristin’s mother-who is now 81-years old-is writing a book about her daughter’s murder.''

''New York State Police released a statement concerning the case and TV production-

The State Police has been actively investigating the murder of Kristin O’Connell from the tragic day she was discovered. The term cold case is used, however, the case is actively worked on by investigators of the Troop E Major Crimes Unit. State Police did listen to the producers of the True Crime Documentary Company, but after careful consideration, declined their offer. As in all cases, the State Police does not share critical information, evidence, or the techniques used in solving cases. By sharing such information, it could jeopardize the integrity of the investigation.''

“They’ve had thirty-six years to solve Kristin’s case. I’ve been more than patient. And I’ve listened to State Police investigators make excuses time and time again about not having the funding to retest physical evidence or travel outside their jurisdiction to question suspects. They’ve been using Cuomo budget cuts for years as an excuse for why Kristin’s case never seems to advance.” said Kristin’s mother, Phyllis O’Connell. “But now a documentary team offers Kristin’s investigation free forensic testing and an entire cold case team, and the State Police turns them down without ever informing our family or asking our opinion? Why pass up this incredible opportunity that doesn’t cost the State a dime? It’s been thirty-six years without an arrest. Maybe it’s time the State Police give someone else a shot at solving my daughter’s murder.”
 
This year, 36 years after Kristin’s murder, the family has a new offer for help from a true-crime investigative documentary series. Producers have assembled a cold case investigative unit to offer fresh eyes on the investigation and work alongside New York State Police.

“We want to help and we’re offering them a fresh set of eyes,” documentary producer Christopher Pavlick told Dateline. “ We’re offering a forensic lab that’s available to test all the physical evidence and, in Kristin’s case, at no cost to the state of New York.”

But they hit a roadblock.

New York State Police declined the offer for help, stating that it’s against policy for outsiders to be brought into an investigation.

New York State Police decline outside help from docuseries team in 1985 unsolved murder of Kristin O’Connell
 
June 26 2021 rbbm.
Mother turns to cold case team to help solve daughter's 1985 Ovid murder
''In August of 1985 her then-20-year-old daughter, Kristin, was murdered. Her nude body was found in a cornfield off a road in Ovid. She had been stabbed multiple times in the chest and her throat was slit.''

''Witnesses said that she went for a walk around midnight down County Road 139, heading west. The road did not have street lights and she was not wearing shoes or carrying a purse. She never returned. Her nude body was found in a cornfield 13 hours after she left the party. She had been stabbed multiple times in the chest and her throat was slit. Her clothes were piled nearby.

At least two motorists told police they saw her being followed on foot down County Road 139 by two men in their early 20s. They said they also were followed by a person driving a dark sedan.

Neighbors reported hearing screams just after midnight
. None of that was reported to police at the time but was later. Pavlick said there was no alcohol in her blood and no evidence of a sexual assault.''
 
Just heard about this case for the first time re: a recent Yahoo article. Glad this thread was created. I'm not surprised that there have been no leads in this 36-year old case. Sadly, it's one of many that has been all-but-forgotten these days.

What was it that caused KOC to cut her trip to NY short, as she mentioned to her mother on the pay-phone? And, what happened at the party that night which resulted in KOC leaving in the middle of the night (presumably alone?!) and walking down the road, barefoot?!

I wonder how much investigation was done into this crime?! That being said - in all fairness, it sounds like the authorities didn't have much to go on.
 
Oct 30 2021
CRIME HUNTER: Cold case notebook | Toronto Sun
''FAMILY BEGS FOR INFO IN NY MURDER
It has now been 36 years of suffering for the O’Connell family of Minnesota and they are begging cops in upstate New York to turn up the heat on finding the killer of Kristin O’Connell.

“I promised my daughter I’d never rest until that person was arrested who murdered her,” her mother Phyllis O’Connell told Fox News. “That’s been my challenge for 35 years to try to find out who did this. I’m never going to give up ‘til I die. I want to know who did it — why they did it. I mean, my God. She wouldn’t have hurt a fly.”

''In August 1985, she traveled from Minnesota to Ovid, NY in the Finger Lakes to meet up with a man she met in Florida during spring break. Two days after arriving, she told her mom wanted to come home.''

''Thirteen hours after the call, the man in question, Jim Vermeersch, reported her missing to local police. He claimed she had left his trailer to take a walk but didn’t take her shoes or purse.

Officers found her naked body in a cornfield and bloody clothing nearby. No arrests have ever been made but neighbours heard screams — and never told cops. They later said they saw Kristin talking to two men on the side of the road.

An autopsy revealed she had been stabbed and beaten but there was no sign of sexual assault.''
 
Thank you, from link..
  • ''August 14, 1985: Sometime during the day, Kristin called her mother to let her know that she planned on ending her trip early and coming home the next day. According to her mother, she sounded upset but wouldn’t say if anything was wrong.
  • August 14, 1985: Around 11-11:30 p.m. Kristin left a gathering at the boy’s house to go on a walk. She never returned.
  • August 16, 1985: Around 5 p.m., her body was found in a cornfield, naked and stabbed in the chest with her throat slit.
  • Witnesses came forward to say that they saw Kristin walking along County Route 139, and others claim to have seen her stopped along the road talking to someone(s) in a car.
  • Other people have said that they saw Kristin walking back to the trailer she was staying at, with two men following behind her.
  • Despite having over 2,000 leads, it seems none of them have panned out since police have never named a suspect in this case, even after 38 years.''
“Don’t keep secrets… don’t keep something like this going,” Phyllis implored, “because maybe the next person might be your daughter, and you will know the kind of pain it is to lose a daughter and especially through murder.”


''There is a Facebook group called ‘Justice for Kristin O’Connell‘ where you can keep track of any progress made in the case. As of right now, this is still an open investigation and anyone with information is encouraged to call State Police Troop E: (585) 398-4100.''
 
A good case for Othram?
2023 rbbm.
''It did rain the night before Kristin’s body was found in the cornfield, but there is still a lot of evidence and DNA that can be tested. “There’s tons of evidence. There’s Kristin’s pants, there’s Kristin’s underwear, there’s Kristin’s sweater, there’s Kristin’s fingernails, there’s over 300 hairs, there’s two packs of cigarettes, there’s a baseball hat, a painters’ hat that was left behind,” said Pavlick''.

''What’s more, Pavlick said that there are people that think the killing did not happen in the cornfield. “This crime scene felt staged, it didn’t feel like it had taken place there, it felt like that they had to put things together to kind of make it look like it had been a sexual assault. When it actually wasn’t,” said Pavlick.''
Aug 20, 2015

Mar 2, 2023
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
87
Guests online
7,438
Total visitors
7,525

Forum statistics

Threads
623,770
Messages
18,472,047
Members
240,523
Latest member
ponyotruffle
Back
Top