OH - Pike Co - 8 in Rhoden Family Murdered Over Custody Issue - 4 Members Wagner Family Arrested #82

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #321






James Pilcher

@jamespilcher
·
2h

Next was Shawn Fisher - tattoo artist from Portsmouth. He covered up diesel tattoo on George with a skull and 8 ball and 3 aces. Said they came up with design on fly and it was mostly his (Shawn's) idea. Also did scorpion on Billy's hand, and diesel tattoo for Jake
@local12

1



6


Show this thread
 
  • #322
Yes, up to a certain point I'd agree with this. Then there has to be a point when they knew and so the sons testimony did seem a little more like he was trying to remain neutral, but he knew something more. Not that he thought they were guilty, but he wouldn't allow his daughter to date Jake, he agreed to send the guns through a dealer only (which is the right thing to do). Why make that known to the court when it should be assumed that you don't mail guns in the mail? Was it because it was this family he had some gut feelings going on then? I think nobody wants to believe someone is capable of this type of thing, but even pastors (or maybe especially pastors) should have some discernment and ability to read people. The fact they needed to have the camera off that Wednesday night before he spoke to the congregation about the Wagner's and them only being accused, but they would allow them to attend. Man transparency is key.
Agree...Pastors, by their training and life experiences, are known to be intuitive and insightful. I'd be very surprised if their hinky-meter didn't go off within a week of reconnecting with the Wagners in Alaska. I was shocked when one testified the Wagners were "a good church family". Maybe pastors' testimony just shows the Wag-4 can pull the wool over anyone's eyes.
 
Last edited:
  • #323
Still a horrible idea with anything '8' on it... plus a death's head. Jeez

Along with the timing of getting that particular tattoo after helping murder 8 people? GW4 is the "smart one", but he got that tattoo.

Jake was smart enough to avoid getting one to "celebrate" the massacre.
 
  • #324
When the site that won't be named was active, someone was thinking of writing a book but don't know if that is still in the works or not
They were on here for a bit, too, then moved on to another board.
 
  • #325
WOW so the defense brought this witness from Alaska to tell them how wonderful the Wagner's were from 2000-2006, then to say George was smart and Jake struggled, then to say he was in disbelief that this crime happened and the defense only asked him about Angela being involved and were you surprised? He said yes, then the defense has no more questions? WTH!?
Both pastors actually made better witnesses for the prosecution. "I'd not want my daughter to date him" ; "GW4 had changed" ; "JW seemed to be attending more b/c of Beth" ; "JW did not seem to take his faith seriously" "We rarely saw the other Ws"; "Rarely saw the children (I guess they were being cloistered from the world and home schooled)" ; "GW4 was open about his love of Glocks" ; "Had they done a pastor confession I'd have turned them in". Didn't seem they clicked, like the same childhood chums, after 17 years, marriage, children, and a vacation visit.
 
  • #326
Still a horrible idea with anything '8' on it... plus a death's head. Jeez
yeah and I don't know that I believe the witness saying it was mostly his idea. I have many tattoos.. a full sleeve a half sleeve, other smaller ones and while I would say my tattoo artist helped design them, I provided input on things I like, what I'd like to incorperate, colors, etc. I mean no way George didn't say I like skulls, 8 ball, I like playing cards or just any type of input on the elements that make up that tattoo.. I'd say the artist designed it, but did he also come up with the 8 ball, the cards, the skull fully?

Are we to believe George sat down and said surprise me and the tattoo artist just happened to come up with a skull, 8 ball, and the Deadman's hand coincidently after 8 people were murdered 2 months prior?
 
  • #327
seems GW tattoo was designed by the tattoo artist to cover up one he didn't like, so his tattoo holds no evidentiary value

I saw GW4's shoulder and tattoo in the Ford Excursion at the Walmart for the shoe purchases. Until now. I wasn't 100% sure GW4 had a right shoulder tattoo previously that got covered by the 8-Ball and Aces. GW4 was in the vehicle at Walmart.
 
  • #328
yeah and I don't know that I believe the witness saying it was mostly his idea. I have many tattoos.. a full sleeve a half sleeve, other smaller ones and while I would say my tattoo artist helped design them, I provided input on things I like, what I'd like to incorperate, colors, etc. I mean no way George didn't say I like skulls, 8 ball, I like playing cards or just any type of input on the elements that make up that tattoo.. I'd say the artist designed it, but did he also come up with the 8 ball, the cards, the skull fully?

Are we to believe George sat down and said surprise me and the tattoo artist just happened to come up with a skull, 8 ball, and the Deadman's hand coincidently after 8 people were murdered 2 months prior?

I don't believe it either. moo

Could lose a lot of business blabbing about what a client said. moo
 
  • #329
Pastor wired the electricity in the Wagner house they burned down for insurance money. He was in AK when the house was burned.

Billy told him (pastor) he "had some girls to raise up" to be wives for his sons. JMO Wagners thought of wives as brood mares, just as they bred their own horses. Pastor told him that wasn't the best way to handle that situation.

Going into recess for break.

As defense witnesses, they're not helping GW4 much. It's not their fault, it's just that there isn't much evidence to show GW4 wasn't involved in the murders. JMO
They wanted good obedient, helpmates, who would do as their husbands asked, help on the farm, and eventually...be a part of the table meetings. It was just the wrong decade, century, and a bit harder to find obedient females and start a criminal cult of their own.
 
  • #330
Agree...Pastors, by their training and life experiences, are known to be intuitive and insightful. I'd be very surprised if their hinky-meter didn't go off within a week of reconnecting with the Wagners in Alaska. I was shocked when one testified the Wagners were "a good church family". Maybe pastors' testimony just shows the Wag-4 can pull the wool over anyone's eyes.
It certainly wouldn't look good for the pastors to say they suspected the Wagners were involved and they were concerened or saw signs all along. I won't go so far as to say the pastors lied because I didn't get the feeling they were trying to be dishonest, but I think it's easy to put suspicious aside because it's not their place to judge or becaues they want to see the good and help people.

I think the reason the defense asked so much about 2000-2006 is because they didn't want to ask too much about 2017-2018 because the answers might not have been so favorable. Maybe the W's were outwardly nice decent people during those years, but if I were those pastors then that hinky-meter should have been screaming in 2017.. don't believe they just didn't see any media or look it up.
 
  • #331
I saw GW4's shoulder and tattoo in the Ford Excursion at the Walmart for the shoe purchases. Until now. I wasn't 100% sure GW4 had a right shoulder tattoo previously that got covered by the 8-Ball and Aces. GW4 was in the vehicle at Walmart.
AW said they all were
 
  • #332
Listening to the two Alaska pastors' testimony, it appears those two pastors were easily tricked and taken advantage of by the Wagner family. my opinion
The Ws were good at that though, and, AK probably had not seen the press the area here had. I've only seen this case, on t.v., here, around three times, since April 2016, and I am not too far across the state line. Easy driving distance. AK would be like another planet news wise.
 
  • #333
BBM - as time goes on I believe this more and more. I think it's possible Jake and George discussed this. We know George saw that text with Jake's hand holding the gun. We know the victims are all connected more to Jake than anyone else (well also Billy). There seems to be lots of activity that George is kept apart from like wrecking his truck. How did Jake get the job to drive and wreck George's truck for insurance money? George went the legal way to court (well I think this is largely because Tabatha backed down didn't have the resources to fight and Hannah's family had the resources to help her fight) over custody.

We hear the defense trying to show George alone and different, but then we have his own voice seeming to be just as riled up, just as feisty, just as concerned and paranoid as the others. He says he will bring all hell down or something like that, he's screaming at Bulvine in that one recording. We have witnesses that were inside this house saying George was just as vocal with the plans if a and b are arrested we do this, and so on. It's like outside looking in they wanted to show one thing, but inside and behind closed doors, he was doing the same things.

BIBM GW4 was married so there would be custody. HMR and JW were not. She had sole custody. He had zip.
 
  • #334
Wow so after he knew Jake and Angela confessed he didn't see ANY media or even look for information on the others or the situation at all to know until the trial started that the state thought they were all involved? I find that hard to believe.

If I am a pastor at a church and I've grown up with these people, spent the night at their house, hunted with them, had items of theirs in my house that BCI came with a warrant to take, and then find out one of them confessed?? I just don't look it up, research it, talk to anyone still in the area, get a text, send a text, nothing at all to find out that George and Billy are also accused? Huh?

I know us true crime enthusiast are a little different, but to think I was friends with a family and was that close with them and I just don't check anything out about it until a trial starts?
I think he said something about hearsay. He probably figured he'd be called to testify, or had been talked to already, and wanted to just tell what he knew. He may have already felt he knew once Jake Testified. It would be hard to tell. I know different people react to such things very differently when it's close to them. Can't go into it on this thread, but it's not as simple as folks think when it's their own kin (and friends). That's not the person(s) they grew up with and thought they knew.
 
  • #335
Yes, up to a certain point I'd agree with this. Then there has to be a point when they knew and so the sons testimony did seem a little more like he was trying to remain neutral, but he knew something more. Not that he thought they were guilty, but he wouldn't allow his daughter to date Jake, he agreed to send the guns through a dealer only (which is the right thing to do). Why make that known to the court when it should be assumed that you don't mail guns in the mail? Was it because it was this family he had some gut feelings going on then? I think nobody wants to believe someone is capable of this type of thing, but even pastors (or maybe especially pastors) should have some discernment and ability to read people. The fact they needed to have the camera off that Wednesday night before he spoke to the congregation about the Wagner's and them only being accused, but they would allow them to attend. Man transparency is key.
Maybe the cameras were the ones that go out to the folks who watch from home due to distance or infirmity. At that time they were considered innocent. All of them. They had not been charged. The church is supposed to be for the damned, not the saved. He said he'd tell had they confessed. The pastor in that church is not the same as a Catholic priest taking confession.
 
  • #336
Prosecutor AC cross examination of Caleb.


https://twitter.com/jamespilcher


Shot bows together - especially with George. Would play baseball with them.

Asked if he received any boxes from them shipped from Ohio to Alaska. Doesn't recall that or telling BCI or tip line that fact. He did sent deer head for them back to Ohio.

Asked if he received any boxes from them shipped from Ohio to Alaska. Doesn't recall that or telling BCI or tip line that fact. He did sent deer head for them back to Ohio.

Says George told him he liked Glocks and apparently he told BCI George said he owned every make and model of Glock. George also told him they sold all their guns and ammo before moving to Alaska.

He got along better with George as kids - but he dealt with Jake a lot more as adults. Says George was distant

Says the Wagners "would be allowed there" when asked if he told the congregation they were welcome to come to church.

Remember telling media "if they're guilty they need to be punished and if they're innocent they need to be left alone" about Wagners. But it only got reported "they're innocent ... leave them alone" so he stopped talking to media.

He went hunting with Jake and George once with guns

Jake asked Cinereski if he would ship 4 handguns back through licensed dealers. But Alaska State Police came with search warrant and they got the guns and took other items to be shipped back.

Recounts telling the guardian of Beth Ann Armer he wouldn't let his daughter marry Jake. "Didn't think Jake was really spiritual ... no realness to it ... I wouldn't want my daughter to marry somebody like that."

Said he would have notified authorities if any of Wagners had confessed - but he never did notify. He's never asked if anyone confessed due to hearsay rules.

Also says he only learned Jake says all four Wagners were involved in watching YouTube of the trial. Asked if he is equally disgusted of anyone involved "100 percent"

On lunch break until 1:45 ... that's to allow next defense witness. It's supposed to be Barbara Moore, the lawyer who represented George in his divorce from Tabitha Claytor.
Recounts telling the guardian of Beth Ann Armer he wouldn't let his daughter marry Jake. "Didn't think Jake was really spiritual ... no realness to it ... I wouldn't want my daughter to marry somebody like that."


Guarding responded: She's not my daughter. (What a fantastic guardian!! What a great friend she had too! IIRC she called her friend telling him she was in danger and he shrugged it off, taking JW's side. Just an hysterical female. Nothing to worry about lil lady.)
 
  • #337
I was surprised the pastors were so easily fooled by the Wagners.
Not me. My husband’s family are pastor’s they very easily fooled. I have personal experience of them so fooled that they took the other person’s side against mine. Pastors hear something and prays to it.
 
  • #338
yeah and I don't know that I believe the witness saying it was mostly his idea. I have many tattoos.. a full sleeve a half sleeve, other smaller ones and while I would say my tattoo artist helped design them, I provided input on things I like, what I'd like to incorperate, colors, etc. I mean no way George didn't say I like skulls, 8 ball, I like playing cards or just any type of input on the elements that make up that tattoo.. I'd say the artist designed it, but did he also come up with the 8 ball, the cards, the skull fully?

Are we to believe George sat down and said surprise me and the tattoo artist just happened to come up with a skull, 8 ball, and the Deadman's hand coincidently after 8 people were murdered 2 months prior?
I took my kid to have an awful tatt covered up (nothing bad, just really poorly done at someone's home...yeah...I paid for that one myself!), and our artist just looked at it and said dude, shook his head, sketched up something and said, how about this? My kid said, sounds good, just get rid of that other one. His ex gf has his name on her privates. I think she ended up keeping hers, it was painful, I'm told. I truly didn't need to know that but she felt the need to tell me. All of my tatts have a distinct reason behind them and I had a hand in their design from the get go. I've been in the chair and seen younger folks just point to stuff. Makes no sense to me. Ya never know with folks.
 
  • #339
I think he said something about hearsay. He probably figured he'd be called to testify, or had been talked to already, and wanted to just tell what he knew. He may have already felt he knew once Jake Testified. It would be hard to tell. I know different people react to such things very differently when it's close to them. Can't go into it on this thread, but it's not as simple as folks think when it's their own kin (and friends). That's not the person(s) they grew up with and thought they knew.
I can completely understand this and I have been in situations too where I didn't want to see something for what it was. I saw good and bad so I would let the bad slide and defend the person because there was some good. I've since went back to others I dismissed the concerns of over this other person and said, you were right, I saw it and I wanted to see the good.

I think it was just low of the defense to call them in the first place. They largely centered around how this family was 10+ years prior to the murders then barely touched on the recent years and the prosecution brought that stuff up. I am assuming the defense went over testimony with these witnesses first. They likely didn't ask anything about stuff they didn't want the honest answer too.. then the prosecution does ask. It seems the prosecution did tread lightly though maybe realizing the tough spot the witnesses are in. They all likely missed red flags and are now left feeling like wow. To be called as a defense witnesses leads some to believe that you support the person on trial and I didn't get that vibe from any of what we can see at least.
 
  • #340
Not me. My husband’s family are pastor’s they very easily fooled. I have personal experience of them so fooled that they took the other person’s side against mine. Pastors hear something and prays to it.
The girl who was murdered in Ky, a few years back, his parents were pastors. My farrier lived next door to the guy. His parents had zero clue he did it til Dad found her in their garden. They were adamant he was innocent. His Dad turned him in. His elder brother later committed suicide I think. I don't think he'd ever been in any serious trouble at all but turned out to be a real strange cat.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
133
Guests online
2,324
Total visitors
2,457

Forum statistics

Threads
633,251
Messages
18,638,547
Members
243,458
Latest member
Velvetnigh
Back
Top