I've given this some thought too. I see JW as being a bit naive. Being a child, living in the country, your playmates are usually your sibling(s), the closest neighbor kid, whether you really get along or not, and the animals on the place. It leads me to believe that HMR was probably his first real girlfriend. I also think that it may be
possible that they ha d both sets of parents thinking that they were sleeping on top of the covers, and with full clothing on, say, sweats, for example... (Believe me, I've seen that happen...blows. my. mind.). So, at first, I thought he was just a naive young man, who thought that it's possible that since he had S, that he could be a possible placement for her 1/2 sis. I also thought that he may be naive enough think that he could get the girls visitation together (play dates).
Then, I also thought about the public FB argument, where HMR was pretty vocal about CG, and thought JW knew that, and he might know why, too, and just was hoping to keep in touch with the child, and just didn't understand the way the world worked.
After the
murders arrests, the comments make him look very different. Not in a good way, either. However, if he was so keen on keeping the girl's together, why would he move S to AK, unless he had to. Sometimes a parent has to move. There's just no choice. I then think back to FW, it's like she knew if anyone was innocent, it was JW;
Is it possible that JW is the mole?
Pike County murders: Who are the Wagners?