Nolen was forced to appear Tuesday morning, at which point the judge asked him to stand by the guilty plea he wanted to make last February.
The courtroom was cleared shortly after Nolen entered.
The man reportedly kicked the swinging door because he did not want to be in court today.
"After that, the defendant put his fingers in his ears and refused to participate in any of the court hearings and didn't answer any of the judge's questions," Cleveland County District Attorney Greg Mashburn said.
After deputies got Nolen under control, he refused to reaffirm his guilty plea.
"He wouldn't even acknowledge any questions being posed to him at that time, so we couldn't go forward with the guilty plea this morning," said Mashburn.
His case will now go to a jury trial.
"Its been a roller coaster ride for the families, its been a rollercoaster ride for us. If I had my way, hed be all the way already on death row but theres a process weve had to go through to have a fair proceeding and the judge has done that. Unfortunately, were just not there yet," he said.
The trial is scheduled for May 31. Officials say a jury trial could take three to four weeks to complete.