I took this post from the thread
Shannan Gilbert Found, death declared an accident. #2 and responded here as I thought it was more appropriate.
Why is it that we know the exact time of BBrennan's 911 call but almost every source, still left on the internet, states that GC was up shaving just before 5:00 AM and he called 911 ABOUT 5:30 AM. There is no specific time for this call.
Shannan made a 23 minute call starting at 4:51 AM and ending at 5:14 AM.
8 minutes later B Brennan calls 911 at 5:22 AM.
Early reports put LE arriving at about 5:55-6:00 AM and GC as saying he called 911 around 5:30 AM. Original reports had LE arriving about 40-50 minutes after SG initiated her call to 911.
One year after the first bodies were found, Newsday began reporting that BB called at 5:22 AM and that LE sources report arriving about ten minutes after the BB call.
Of course we have no idea how long that BB call lasted. Let's go with the minimum, of say one minute, to call in report, give address, phone number, description, etc.
Now, wouldn't that put LE arriving at almost the exact time that GC made his call and then MP, rolls down the street,SG runs off and MP talks to GC and follows SG.
Isn't it possible that SG ran out of JB's, turned right down Anchor, banged on a few doors, got no help and ran to GC's. At that point if GC's 911 call was at 5:30ish, then SG was nearer the OP and the gate. MP could have seen her and followed her out just before the LE arrived. BUT, MP stated he searched the OP and gave up and left the Oak Beach area at 6:00 AM.
It would be very nice to know via which bridge he left and which bridge LE used to come in...
The timing of events is very crucial,
The Foreingner's expertise in setting the 911 timelines is useful here:
5:14 AM...
SG 23 minute long phonecall with the 911 operator stops.
5:22 AM...
Gustav Coletti calls 911. Police arrived about 45 minutes later (that would be 6:07 am)
Here is a problem, Newsday says BB called 911 at 5:22AM. If Newsday is correct, since this call took place after the GC call, GC must have called 911 prior to 5:15AM. because after GC made his call, he went outside, saw SG, and spoke to MP. I have a problem with Newsday's timing of BB's call at 5:22 AM as that would have given SG 8 minutes to leave JB's house, run to GC's, talk to GC wait while he made the 911 call, than run to BB's.
Some local has to measure the time to cover this distance.
BB sees SG and calls 911 at 5:22PM but I do not believe this time, I think BB called 911 closer to 5:35AM
MP says he left Oak Beach at around 6:00PM
GC allows LE into Oak Beach at 6:07AM
The question does MP have enough time between 5:35AM to grab SG and leave Oak beach and not be seen by GC?
There are only three ways that GC could not have seen MP drive out of Oak Beach
1) GC had not reached the gate house prior to MP leaving (finished dressing, finished coffee, walked as a older gentleman?????)
2) GC was doing something, or was distracted while at the gate house when MP drove out.(Checking to see if cameras are working, Checking tapes, taking a whizz, calling the wife???????)
3) GC, as a typical eyewitness in most criminal cases, was confused about what he did or did not see.
PB has stated that GC, after his 911 call, went directly to the gate to allow LE in, and that MP would not have time to grab SG and return to the gate and leave Oak Beach prior to being seen by GC.
It boils down to a matter of seconds and minutes; especially what time was BB's 911 call and what time did GC arrive at the gate house?
MOO
