GUILTY SC - Nine killed in Emanuel AME Church shooting, Charleston, 2015; Dylann Roof GUILTY #3

  • #661
As far as where he'll be held, I suspect it will be in ADX in Florence, Co (home of terrorists like Dzhokhar Tsarnaev and the Unabomber) due to the Federal charges. From what I understand, this place is a death penalty in its own way. Twenty-three hours in a cell with one hour "outside" (there is tarp-like covering above their heads, the inmates never see the sky even when outside). Basically, it's solitary confinement for eternity.

Knowing that it's highly likely that this is what is in store for Roof, I'm ok if his DP verdict is eventually overturned though the courts. To me, life in "supermax" seems like a fate even worse than death.

I don't think Roof will go to ADX in Colorado, but will go to Terre Haute in Indiana:

Why Tsarnaev was not sent to Terre Haute

"TERRE HAUTE, Ind. (WTHI) – Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev awaits his death sentence not here in Terre Haute, but in Florence, Colorado.

Since re-implementing the death sentence in the 1988, the federal government has executed three men, the most notorious being Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh.

Right now, Terre Haute is the only federal facility which can carry out executions, so it seemed to be where another bomber, Dzhokhar Tsarnaev would await his death sentence

A Bureau spokesman told News 10 the decision to place Tsarnaev in Colorado was based on “unique security management requirements.” USP Florence is a super-maximum security facility housing about 420 male inmates..."

http://wthitv.com/2015/06/26/why-tsarnaev-was-not-sent-to-terre-haute/

--------------------------------------------

But here is some info on ADX in Colorado:

Inside America’s Toughest Federal Prison

"...The ADX can house up to 500 prisoners in its eight units. Inmates spend their days in 12-by-7-foot cells with thick concrete walls and double sets of sliding metal doors (with solid exteriors, so prisoners can’t see one another). A single window, about three feet high but only four inches wide, offers a notched glimpse of sky and little else. Each cell has a sink-toilet combo and an automated shower, and prisoners sleep on concrete slabs topped with thin mattresses. Most cells also have televisions (with built-in radios), and inmates have access to books and periodicals, as well as certain arts-and-craft materials. Prisoners in the general population are allotted a maximum of 10 hours of exercise a week outside their cells, alternating between solo trips to an indoor “gym” (a windowless cell with a single chin-up bar) and group visits to the outdoor rec yard (where each prisoner nonetheless remains confined to an individual cage). All meals come through slots in the interior door, as does any face-to-face human interaction (with a guard or psychiatrist, chaplain or imam). The Amnesty report said that ADX prisoners “routinely go days with only a few words spoken to them.”

Robert Hood, the warden of the ADX from 2002 to 2005, told me that when he first arrived on the campus, he was struck by “the very stark environment,” unlike any other prison in which he ever worked or visited — no noise, no mess, no prisoners walking the hallways. When inmates complained to him, he would tell them, “This place is not designed for humanity,” he recalled. “When it’s 23 hours a day in a room with a slit of a window where you can’t even see the Rocky Mountains — let’s be candid here. It’s not designed for rehabilitation. Period. End of story.”

Hood was not trying to be cruel with such frankness. The ADX was built explicitly to house men often already serving multiple life sentences and thus facing little disincentive to, say, murder a guard or another prisoner...

In the past, Hood has memorably described the ADX as “a clean version of hell."..."

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/29/magazine/inside-americas-toughest-federal-prison.html

29mag-29supermax.t_CA1-blog427.jpg


(In the Control Unit, the most restrictive section of the ADX prison, most of the beds are equipped with strap-down rings.)

29supermax1-blog427-v2.jpg


(The ADX from above. Credit Jamey Stillings for The New York Times)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

And info on USP Terre Haute:

United States Penitentiary, Terre Haute

"...Death row
On July 19, 1993, the federal government designated USP Terre Haute as the site where federal death sentences would be carried out, including the establishment of the "Special Confinement Unit," the federal death row for men. The Bureau of Prisons modified USP Terre Haute in 1995 and 1996 so it could house death row functions. On July 13, 1999, the Special Confinement Unit at USP Terre Haute opened, and the BOP transferred male federal death row inmates from other federal prisons and from state prisons to USP Terre Haute.[4] There are currently 58 inmates on death row.[5][6] The federal government chose Terre Haute as the location of the men's death row due to its central location within the United States.[7]..."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Penitentiary,_Terre_Haute

and this:

'White supremacists, knife brawls and incessant screams': Life inside the terrifying maximum security prison known as 'Guantanamo North' where the Boston Bomber will wait for the needle

"Terre Haute, Indiana, is home to the federal government's death chamber
Day-to-day life of prisoners has been described as violent and secluded...

'They are in a small cell by themselves. All their meals are pushed through a slot. There is no recreation but they can go out of their cells three times a week into cages,' she told The Tribune-Star, a newspaper in the city....

High-profile inmates on the block, which has even stricter rules than death row, include John Walker Lindh, known as the 'American Taliban', and Somali pirate Abdulwali Abdukhad Muse, who was portrayed in the film Captain Phillips starring Tom Hanks.

The unit's reputation has led it to being dubbed 'Guantanamo North', and it houses convicts involved in the 1993 attack on the World Trade Center and many hijacking cases.

There is severely limited contact allowed between inmates, and only two visits by outsiders are allowed every month.

Phone calls are limited to 15 minutes once a week - and all conversations have to be in English, Business Insider reported.

In 2008, the American Civil Liberties Union said the conditions on the federal death row were 'grossly inadequate' and 'jeopardize the health and safety of people who live there'.

Prisoners are said to wait for months in agony because their requests for health care are routinely ignored.

A report stated inmates are 'denied access to basic medical care, basic mental health care services, timely and adequate dental care and are subjected to incessant noise that causes sleep deprivation and psychological and physiological stress.

'Prisoners are forced to endure a constant bombardment of incessant noise at all hours of the day and night.'

According to the ACLU's letter, prisoners are subjected to constant banging and screaming from other parts of the institution.

They also have to listen to several deafening fire alarms each week that last as long as 90 minutes and have flashing strobe lights...

Lorenzo Kom’boa Ervin, a black activist and writer who served time at Terre Haute wrote: 'The federal penitentiary at Terre Haute, Indiana, had the reputation of being the most racist and brutal prison in the federal prison system...."

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...antanamo-North-Boston-Bomber-wait-needle.html

Anyway, wherever they send Roof, both facilities sound horrible, but the best place for people who kill and have no regard for the life of others, IMO.
 
  • #662
Great info and links (as usual) YESorNO - thanks! Didn't realize that ADX is for life sentences and Terre Haute is where Federal death row is.

"Anyway, wherever they send Roof, both facilities sound horrible, but the best place for people who kill and have no regard for the life of others, IMO."


Amen to that, I couldn't agree more.
 
  • #663
I wonder if the convict defendant is in his uncomfortable bed in the Terre Haute FCI tonight. I hope he doesn't get a wink of sleep and is terrified for the rest of his days. I hope that every inmate knows what he did to wind up there with the other DP'ers, and I hope the food is lousy. How long until he has a groupie who feels sorry for him?
 
  • #664
  • #665
Dylann Roof courtroom sketch artist wept as he drew images from trial (with clip)

"CHARLESTON, SC (WCSC) -
Robert Maniscalco's sketch book is filled with images of convicted Charleston Church shooter Dylann Roof.

Page after page shows an emotionless profile of the 22-year-old, mostly seated and about 10 feet away.

The pages also show attorneys, family members of the victims and survivors testifying.

Nothing in the courtroom was off limits of Maniscalco's vision to record the proceedings.

Cameras were not allowed inside the courtroom.

TV stations relied on artist drawings to take viewers inside the courtroom.

Maniscalco and his colleagues detailed some of the trials most heartbreaking moments....

"The experience was taxing," he said of many portions of the trial. "Physically, mentally like playing a game of chess. How to draw how to keep going for a full day like that."

Some days he drew through the tears.

"For the most part it was a roller coaster of emotions. At times I was weeping into my drawings," he said..."

http://www.wistv.com/story/34247944...al&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer


12901385_G.jpg

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #666
I just wanted to note that if it's ultimately decided that DR will be executed in SC, the state still has the option of using the electric chair. As the law stands right now, the convicted inmate chooses which he/she would prefer (electric chair or lethal injection). That being said, if the drugs are still unavailable when his execution is to be carried out, I can only assume the default method of execution would then become the electric chair.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Will it ever happen? We haven't killed anyone since 2011 and there are 47 people ahead on him on the list.
Let the feds kill him. They haven't killed anyone since 2003 and have 63 on the list ahead of him.
Why should we (the state of SC) even try him?
 
  • #667
Airport shooter faces death penalty but actual execution is unlikely

"Federal death penalty cases are exceedingly rare, but prosecutors are already exploring the possibility of seeking execution for a military veteran who flew from Alaska to Fort Lauderdale to gun down nearly a dozen airport travelers.

For federal prosecutors, the contemplated capital case against 26-year-old Esteban Santiago won’t be so much a whodunit — after all, he surrendered immediately after the deadly attack at Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport.

Rather, they will have to prove the former Army reservist premeditated the violent assault — and disprove the defendant’s likely insanity defense that he didn’t know right from wrong when he opened fire in a baggage claim area last Friday.

The decision to pursue the death penalty against Santiago, accused of killing five people and injuring six others, carries such gravity that it must be made by the U.S. Attorney General, with significant input from the U.S. Attorney’s Office as well as the defendant’s lawyers in South Florida.

Prosecutors will be weighing the pros and cons, deciding whether to put a federal grand jury on notice of their plans to pursue the death penalty when it considers an indictment before Santiago’s arraignment on Jan. 23...

For now, there are only 60 federal inmates awaiting execution, a small fraction of the hundreds on state Death Rows across the country. They are housed at a penitentiary in Terre Haute, Indiana.

The 60th was Dylan Roof, who shot and killed nine black worshipers at a church in Charleston, S.C. A federal jury convicted him of hate crimes, and Wednesday a judge approved the recommended death sentence..."

http://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/crime/article126066479.html
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #668
Chad K. Mills ‏@ChadKMills 13h13 hours ago
Week after jury sentences #DylannRoof to death, judge begins preparations to possibly unseal dozens of #RoofTrial documents @wis10 #sctweets

C2fHb-1XUAAJjlk.jpg

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #669
Dylann Roof trial judge sets timeline for unsealing documents in case

"...Among documents under seal are Roof's two competency hearing transcripts, which attorneys for various media outlets argued should be made public at the time. Gergel denied that request, saying that doing so could compromise Roof's right to a fair trial and impartial jury..."

http://www.postandcourier.com/churc...cle_3bf36c92-ddca-11e6-9b46-9b9e15395d52.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #670
Victim Relatives Confront Roof, Honor Loved Ones

[video=youtube;1hTQiQbwmXQ]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hTQiQbwmXQ[/video]
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #671
Simmons Family speaks after Roof sentencing

"Rose Simmons, the daughter of The Rev. Daniel Simmons, shared with media after speaking during the trial of Dylann Roof."

[video=youtube;1KqsvhSa_5w]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1KqsvhSa_5w[/video]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #672
Family of Emmanuel AME shooting victum speaks

"Melvin Graham shares his thoughts on the death penalty and how his family is living with the loss of his sister, Cynthia Hurd."

[video=youtube;5gTqzEqBjHk]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gTqzEqBjHk[/video]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #673
Judge sends sealed files in Dylann Roof case to state court

http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/storie...ME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2017-01-25-11-27-59

The South Carolina judge overseeing the upcoming state trial of convicted church shooter Dylann Roof will review sealed federal court records dealing with Roof's mental competency, which might prevent the need to evaluate him again.

Solicitor Scarlett Wilson has said she should decide how to handle Roof's state death penalty trial in the next 30 days. Wilson has also said she is evaluating what happened in the federal trial and is awaiting some additional information to decide how to proceed in state court.

If a South Carolina jury sentences Roof to death, he would be the only person facing both a federal death sentence and a state death sentence, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.
 
  • #674
Judge sends sealed files in Dylann Roof case to state court

http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/storie...ME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2017-01-25-11-27-59

The South Carolina judge overseeing the upcoming state trial of convicted church shooter Dylann Roof will review sealed federal court records dealing with Roof's mental competency, which might prevent the need to evaluate him again.

Solicitor Scarlett Wilson has said she should decide how to handle Roof's state death penalty trial in the next 30 days. Wilson has also said she is evaluating what happened in the federal trial and is awaiting some additional information to decide how to proceed in state court.

If a South Carolina jury sentences Roof to death, he would be the only person facing both a federal death sentence and a state death sentence, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

5887d5561e825.preview.jpg

Link: http://bloximages.newyork1.vip.town...795f/5887d5561e825.preview.jpg?resize=750,970
 
  • #675
Sentencing of Dylann Roof friend Joey Meek rescheduled for March 2

"The sentencing for Joey Meek, the friend who knew of Dylann Roof's plot to attack Emanuel AME Church and did nothing, has been delayed until early March, a court filing said Wednesday.

The hearing, which had been slated for Feb. 28, was rescheduled for 11 a.m. March 2 in front of U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel in downtown Charleston.

The 22-year-old resident of the Lexington area faces up to eight years in prison after pleading guilty last spring to misprision of a felony and lying to federal agents. As part of a deal with prosecutors that required him to cooperate with them, he could seek a lighter sentence than prescribed under federal guidelines..."

http://www.postandcourier.com/churc...cle_d129fa6c-e340-11e6-a556-6f8c63fdcc1c.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #676
Questions remain about timing, possibility of Roof's state trial

"CHARLESTON, SC (WIS) -
There's still no word if and when the convicted Charleston church shooter will get a trial in state court...

At this point, Solicitor Scarlett Wilson hasn't said how she'll proceed in prosecuting Roof. Some observers have asked why state prosecutors even have to bother at all since a federal jury has already voted to send Roof to death row.

WIS asked that question to an attorney and legal expert, Jack Swerling.

"Well, I think there's several reasons. One is that the charges in Charleston County are murder charges, as opposed to in the federal court you had different charges arising out of the murders,” Swerling said. “The second reason would be that it's possible, and I would think probably likely, that the solicitor believes that this is a case that a Charleston County jury should decide what the ultimately punishment is. You know, the third reason, I think, would be obvious. You don't know verdict is going to stand in federal court. I mean, it's going to go through an appellate process up to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, and it's going to go up to the Supreme Court. It's going to be scrutinized by a number of different judges, so having a conviction and a sentence of death in state court would ensure the possibility of a death sentence even more."

Again, Federal Judge Richard Gergel ordered the release of a number of documents related to Roof's mental competency to state Circuit Court Judge J.C. Nicholson.

Those documents are still sealed from the public."

http://www.wistv.com/story/34349549/questions-remain-about-timing-possibility-of-roofs-state-trial
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #677
Jury verdict form for Dylann Roof's federal hate crimes trial (20 pages)

"This is the form the jury foreman filled out after polling the jurors in the Dylann Roof federal hate crimes trial..."

https://www.scribd.com/document/336...n-Roof-s-federal-hate-crimes-trial#from_embed
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #678
Opinion:
The right to kill and the trial of murderer Dylann Roof

"...Some argue he is not a white supremacist, though Roof’s jailhouse manifesto states otherwise. Some say he is mentally ill and deserves sympathy, mental help or pardon. Others say he deserves death, which is what was decided Jan. 11 by a jury of his peers.

What made Roof’s act of murder so profoundly abominable is that he, like all murderers, thought he had the right to take the life of another. No matter how he justified his actions, Roof took something away from those women, men and children will never get back. Now, the federal government intends to do the same....

If Roof is put to death — as he is set to be — he will no longer have to face the consequences of his actions. In his own eyes, he will die remembered for his actions. A martyr. He will no longer have to think about the testimonies of the families he tore apart and will not endure the pain of watching his infamy waste away before his eyes.

That is a greater punishment than death. Death is permanent, indiscriminate and beyond our control. It is a release, a journey and, to some, an escape.

Death, in this case, would be too good for Dylann Roof."

http://www.jackcentral.org/opinion/...cle_4418fd62-dd2d-11e6-a09a-8f88b168c9df.html
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #679
Re the State of S.C. trying Roof for murder --

Let me first say I am not a resident of SC, but IMO, I think the people of SC and Charleston would like to try Roof because of what he did to The People of the State of South Carolina. Although they know he is confined to a Federal prison until he is executed or until he dies, there could be a reversal, retrial, etc., etc. I would think that the prosecutors in Charleston County would like to prosecute him for crimes against the State. I would certainly feel that way if I were a resident of that state.

In a church, no way to escape, trusting and welcoming their guest in Christian love, being killed by someone who just wanted to kill, their church picked because AME churches are traditionally African-American churches....

It will be interesting to follow this part of this horrible and hateful crime.
 
  • #680
Wonder if the state trial will be streamed or just Tweets?
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
128
Guests online
1,673
Total visitors
1,801

Forum statistics

Threads
632,451
Messages
18,626,940
Members
243,159
Latest member
Tank0228
Back
Top