No, erynne936, I'm not an authority or expert on anything. I pretty much rely on outside experts and authority figures to help me form my own opinions.
I read as many varying opinions as I can find ... about everything that interests me. I'm soooo grateful for the Internet. I don't know how I ever lived without it. I sure was much dumber then.
I don't own Photoshop and my own limited photo editing is very elementary.
I was curious if you were an experienced photo editor because if you were, you would be the
FIRST ONE I've found who believes that campfire photo was not a poorly executed fake.
Thanks for your reply. My vote remains that the FIRE in the photo is a total fraud. I don't care about the rest of the photo. Josh's only point in faking the photo was to try to prove the family has freezing-snowy
campground campouts with S'more making blazing campfires.
We already know from Susan's friends that Susan, Josh and the boys had been camping only 4 times -- and NEVER during winter months. Therefore, IMO, that fire in the photo, (whether faked or real) is NOT a camping-in-the-wilderness campfire.
Josh's photo was just another of his half-a$$ed LIES! 
imho