State vs. Jason Lynn Young 2-22-2012

[fifteen89]

I don't think the problem is that JY was able to dominate BH. The problem is that BH kept trying to catch JY in a lie, he would answer with a seemingly reasonable explanation, and then she would move on to another question without challenging any of his responses.

There's still that pesky problem of that humongous pile of 'seemingly reasonable explanations' that the jurors have to wade through and believe in order to discount the more likely, more direct route (imo) to get to 'he might seem slick, but he's guilty'. No matter how bad she might be, he's just not credible. jmt

 

[gorealtors]

Jay is now in his element....salesman role.

Just wowing the jury with all his knowledge. Taking the focus off the real subject at hand.

 

[Just the Fax]

dmaxphil,

"Told him not to talk until he had an attorney"

Key word being "until".

So why didn't he talk to LE with his attorney?

 

[Boodles]

Yeah, and ambien gives me a paradoxical reaction, but for 99% of people, they crash within minutes of taking it. So BS for the rx paradoxical reaction defense.

 

[luckyme]

break time

 

[Turnadot]

No. Story has always been that friends told him of the LE's questions and that he was a suspect. Told him not to talk until he had an attorney.

This is video from 1st trial.

Maybe he watched a video like this.. ttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc

BBM

And he still didn't talk after he got one.

I understand protecting ones own rights, and TBH, I would not tell a cop the time of a day without an attorney present, but JY had legal representation, yet he still didn't help LE find the killer. I can't wrap my head around that fact.

 

[Grammy Jean]

No. Story has always been that friends told him of the LE's questions and that he was a suspect. Told him not to talk until he had an attorney.

IMO I bet those friends wish they had never told him that, I think(MO) most of them now believe JY did it.

 

[dmaxphil]

There's no excuse for JY refusing to cooperate with LE. None. Take a lawyer along by all means, but don't just sit doing nothing to help after your spouse and unborn baby were brutally murdered!

IMO

I agree. It is most definitely possible to show concern and ask LE for answers/information while protecting your rights with an attorney present.

 

[Just the Fax]

"That's all I have"

:banghead:

 

[Tipstaff]

His friends telling him to get a lawyer is NOT the same as saying your lawyer advised you not to speak.

What did these 'friends' suspect or know or believe?

 

[luckyme]

"That's all I have"

:banghead:

Awful wasnt it!!! :back:

 

[luckyme]

I think they have something though! stay tuned for after break!

 

[Turnadot]

What did these 'friends' suspect or know or believe?

That LE saw JY as a suspect, I imagine.

Innocent or guilty, JY would have been a fool not to lawyer up ASAP.

IMO

 

[dmaxphil]

IMO I bet those friends wish they had never told him that, I think(MO) most of them now believe JY did it.

I have a feeling you are correct. Maybe not all friends, but I think the Shaads for sure think he did it along with that other guy (Josh?) that grew up in Brevard and never really became friends til college.

 

[Madeleine74]

Seeing her cross exam just made me mad all over again. Like it wasn't bad enough seeing that once already. Ay Yi Yi.

It's enough to make me turn in my fake JD from Google University in protest! harrumph!

 

[Boodles]

No. Story has always been that friends told him of the LE's questions and that he was a suspect. Told him not to talk until he had an attorney.

IMO I bet those friends wish they had never told him that, I think(MO) most of them now believe JY did it.

Part of me wonders whether they would be standing in line waiting to tailgate with him if he is found not guilty. Except then I realize they are all grown adults with businesses now....and they wouldn't want to impact their personal economic situations by being caught associating with him. Because the stigma will remain with him if he is acquitted. It's like CA, everybody (ok 95% of us) KNOWS she did it.

I mean, Dalton didn't validate Genevieve when she ran to their room after Jason assaulted her. And Michelle is murdered and they say "hey man, get a lawyer." What kind of people were Jason's friends?

P.S. I realize this isn't fair, I don't know anything about the friends except what was gleaned from this trial.

 

[fifteen89]

No. Story has always been that friends told him of the LE's questions and that he was a suspect. Told him not to talk until he had an attorney.

This is video from 1st trial.

Maybe he watched a video like this.. ttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc

Correcting fran? lol. I'm pretty sure she's aware.....

 

[whic]

thats no sign of guilt, its smart not to talk even if you're innocent...
even though he is guilty just sayin.

 

[Paige SC]

No wonder the first jury was hung. WEAK prosecution. Shamefully so.

 

[fifteen89]

What did these 'friends' suspect or know or believe?

Could've been based on the questions LE was asking them....but they should know their friend, Jason. Did the friends know of his affairs?