Not to interrupt the motor vehicle violation discussion, but I just got caught back up after the weekend, and I wanted to look at interesting, but frustrating exchange on
Nancy Grace last week, in which Psycholanalyst Bethany Marshall long-distance diagnoses TMH as a borderline personality. (Admittedly a pet peeve with me, but I intend to dip a toe or two in that water myself, momentarily.) Here's the conversation as it unfolded on NG:
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1008/20/ng.01.html
Aside from the usual NG interruptions, during which a potentially interesting point gets lost, Marshall's comments caught my attention because the article under discussion here had already got me to thinking about someone I knew who was a borderline personality. Now, I am not sure what Marshall is talking about, because most descriptions of borderlines that I have seen don't
highlight "ragefulness" or "lack of conscience" or "callousness."
So I looked up borderline personality and found this on the NIMH website; I thought it was more useful for lay people than, say, than the DSM description. I snipped a bit for space:
This description talks about "intense bouts of anger" [or other emotions] that "may only last hours, or at most a day," and which are "associated with episodes of impulsive aggression..or drug and alcohol abuse." So for a borderline, if I have this correctly, rage or anger is intense but passes quickly and may occur with "episodes" of aggression or alcohol abuse (the word "episode" implying contained and having a beginning and end.) The unfortunate NG discussion really cut short this important point, which indicates that anger/rage in such people is not a pervasive, contunual condition but rather intense and "episodic."
If we think about that in relation to the discussion further down, we see that people with this personality disorder have "stormy" relationships, in which their valuation of a loved one might switch "suddenly" from love and admiration to "intense anger and dislike."
We also note the extreme fear of abandonment and rejection--which in the case of the woman I knew, led to abandoning people, including her children as they became adolescents and therefore began (naturally) pulling away from their parents.
Then:
- "frequent changes in long-term goals, career plans, jobs, friendships, gender identity and values..."
- they may "have little idea who they are"
- "frantic efforts to avoid being alone" if they feel isolated and "lacking in social support"
- "risky behaviors," e.g. "excessive spending, binge eating and risky sex."
- "often occurs with other problems." e.g., depression and substance abuse.
Now, I am not going to be a giant hypocrite and diagnose TH, but Bethany Marshall kindly opened the door. It seems to me that TH might well be the same page as "borderline." At least, as we consider how a woman could seemingly stop loving a little guy like Kyron, or turn on a dime from helping him with his science project to kidnapping or worse, we can see that "psychopath" is not the only possibility. This personality disorder would explain much of what we see in the article, in particular, her seeming disenchantment with Kyron (the notion that her bio son was better off away from Kyron); the sexting and moving DS in after Kaine left (to avoid being alone); the reported "spending money like water"; the DUi and traffic issues,etc. I'd love to hear a real, uninterrupted discussion of the role mental health problems like borderline personality disorder and narcissism play in criminal behavior.