The Anthony Family: Who Might be the First to Tell the Truth?

Who will Crack? Multiple answers allowed.

  • GA will crack

    Votes: 243 30.6%
  • CA will crack

    Votes: 21 2.6%
  • LA will crack

    Votes: 111 14.0%
  • KC will crack

    Votes: 13 1.6%
  • NO ONE will crack -they will stick it out till the bitter end!

    Votes: 458 57.8%

  • Total voters
    793
Status
Not open for further replies.
The more I learn from the trial and from reading some threads here, the more I doubt that any of the Anthonys will ever tell the complete truth; I think they all know more than they will ever say.

I could not sleep last night and was reviewing George's demeanor with Casey when they visited her at jail in August 2008; his greeting to her (Good morning, beautiful, or whatever) and asking how she slept one time, I think....gives me the creeps. Not because of what he said, but in this setting, in those circumstances...why is he dancing around her so much, placating her so much, she is in JAIL, her daughter has been missing for almost 2 months, and they KNOW Casey has lied about everything.

So it makes me suspicious of George...of what, I do not know, but his are not the actions of a "normal" dad in this situation and I cannot imagine that a juror would think so either. To me, he seems afraid to upset her and he seems to be telling her to placate mom. Just very odd and "off" behavior to me.

Look back at the dynamic in that family when he has tried to confront ICA's lies... when he proved to CA that ICA was lying about having a job at the Sports Authority she was all over him for "spying on his daughter"... she did NOT want it brought up to her that he had checked.
GA was relegated to houseboy years ago. He maintains cars, does handyman work, yard maintenance , stuff like that, but CA ruled that household and all discipline (lack of it) for ICA.
 
You know...I've thought about this. I want to feel sorry for the Anthonys because they lost their granddaughter. And also, because GA is kind of an easy mark (and I purposely use the word "mark" for I don't think she views anyone in her life as a human being, just as people she can take advantage of and use for her own benefit) for KC - as apparent from the interview transcripts, he's really not that bright, and has no say in his own home, nor does he have much of a backbone. That being said, these two "parents" had a huge hand in creating this monster. Why? Because in all of the interviews and the numerous, numerous times their own daughter lied to them and STOLE MONEY from them, even hacked into their accounts to do so, never once did I see any consequences whatsoever put on her. I firmly believe that she was raised without them and learned how to run circles around them because she would never be held accountable for her actions. I think if I could ask them anything, it would be, why wasn't she ever punished for this??? If I had hacked into my mother's bank account and stolen hundreds of dollars, you can bet she would have called police on me and I would have faced the consequences. Cindy seems to have no problem and no reaction to it whatsoever. That to me is highly disturbing. Maybe the problem is that these parents really WOULD do anything for her, and I don't know if that's an admirable skill to have as a parent - if you know Dad will always bail you out, what's to stop you from doing whatever you want to do and leave him to deal with it, especially if you already have little to no respect for him? And their only basis for considering KC a good mom to own daughter was that her kid was always "clean and fed". Well, I guess there's nothing in their moral playbook about setting a good example or setting limits/discipline, the value of working hard to become successful and self-sufficient (just when did they expect her to stop stealing money and actually work?), and teaching kids right from wrong. It just blows my mind. And I don't think they will change, even when thrown under the bus. I think GA and CA really WILL lay on their swords for her, as they've always done, and to them this is being a "good parent". Sorry, but I have higher standards than that, and a jaded view of humanity - people just don't change like that overnight, they are mostly set in their ways.

Whatever the reason, CA has always had a desperate need to be popular with ICA and still does. She will apparently let ICA walk over her face to get to what she wants, and then whisper 'I love you' . St Cindy,Patron Saint of Martyrs is what I have called her.
And she wonders why ICA feels such absolute contempt for her.
CA needed a backbone years ago. I think GA might have had one at one time, but she took care of that ...
 
I have spent hours (as i'm sure many others have) trying to figure out this seemingly "perfect family" (on the outside).
I used to hate that my mother would be the first one to distrust me in suspicious situations and be the first one to give me up when I was caught lying or "guilty" but this family is like therapy for me! I see now what I coud have become if my entire family blindly believed everything I said and had the "Not MY daughter/sister!!" attitude.
I don't think ANY of them will break down and tell the truth, although I think they all know what the truth is.
It is one more dysfunctional link in this unbreakable chain of a family. BUT there definitely is no weakest link.
 
I don't think they have not been honest IMO.One thing I am certain of though, the truth will not come from Casey. She has no concept of the truth and has a deep, complete resentment against George, Cindy & Lee for not going along with her lies or picking up on her subliminal hints and codes about what to say, think, DO! ( Listen to her jail house visits with them, particularly with Lee.)
JMO:sick:
 
I think Caylee was the first to tell the truth, when they found her lovely bones and saw what had been done to her.
 
This family has no idea what the truth is. There is nothing to crack. The truth floats around in their heads, it is fluid, and changes to suit the listener.
 
I'd only believe their two Yorkies at this point.

ETA: *aughh* why can't I keep my promise to not waste another brain cell on those people!
 
My thoughts are that MAYBE,SOMEDAY George will tell the truth.I do not believe the incest story or the drowning story.And I really don't think George looked that happy when Casey was found not guilty.He knows Casey killed Caylee....and in my opinion he is the only one that didn't forsake her.JMO
 
I am not convinced that the Anthony's know the 'full truth'. IMO each of them has their own truths regarding the dysfunction in the family, ICA's behavior before Caylee's disappearance, the relationships amongst themselves, etc, but I don't know if they know what truly happened to Caylee. It's likely that ICA fed them each a different story so they only know the 'story' told to them but since they know that ICA lies, they are not convinced of whatever version told to them.

The only person who has a glimpse of the truth is ICA. Depending on her psychological disorder she might have distorted that truth in her own memory. All that means is that I'm not sure if we'll ever get an accurate picture of what occurred. Everyone involved needs to protect their psyche and deal with their feelings of guilt and that will always distort 'the truth'.

I might trust a book written by LA if I knew that he had gotten psychotherapy along with disengaging himself from his toxic family.
 
My thoughts are that MAYBE,SOMEDAY George will tell the truth.I do not believe the incest story or the drowning story.And I really don't think George looked that happy when Casey was found not guilty.He knows Casey killed Caylee....and in my opinion he is the only one that didn't forsake her.JMO

Agreed. He's the only one who tried to get justice for Caylee.
 
This family has no idea what the truth is. There is nothing to crack. The truth floats around in their heads, it is fluid, and changes to suit the listener.

There is no truth, per se, only their reactions to specific events, and as such, it's completely relative. Combine that with some very twisted dysfunction and some just plain dumb and voila! Instant plastic explanations molded to fit what ever tiny little twisted keyhole they can find - or even create. (remember the Gonzale Gonzales "comma" CA was hanging onto in the Morgan depo?)
 
At this point I think it would be George. But I honestly think even if someone told the truth now, we'd never know it. It would be just another Anthony story.
 
None of them will. If ANYONE would, it would be GA. However, I don't believe he knows anything, except maybe he would admit there was a fight, or Casey said something about Caylee that was strange. I highly doubt he would come out with it though.

Casey and Cindy....not a chance in the world. Casey will die never saying a word about what happened. God knows she pretends like nothing ever happened and never even had a daughter. If she ever talks about this trial again, she will just proclaim her innocence, and how she is such a victim.

Cindy will never say anything about what happened either. She is going to do the same thing, and pretend nothing ever happened, and pretend to move on from it. She might try to make money off of it, but I'm not even sure if she will do that.

They are all cowards.
 
I don't think any of them will 'fess up to what really happened.

I'm really puzzled by Lee Anthony however. You know that feeling, you just can't put your finger on it.

Which reminds me .... I've always wanted to know about Caylee's name. It's clearly a combination of Casey/Lee. Has there been a discussion on this particular issue? I was thinking the other day that I could imagine that Cindy chose that name. I can visualise that domineering woman making every decision and alternative suggestions are non-negotiable in her mind.

They're an odd bunch. Very strange.
 
I just noticed how I had voted when this poll was originally posted: George will crack. Casey will crack. WTH was I thinking? One of the Anthonys tell the truth? Never. End. Of. Story.
 
I'm thinking one of the dogs (are they still alive?) might be interviewed by a dog psychologist and may tell the truth. lol!
 
What really happened is KC left the house on June 15th and when George left, she returned to the house and killed Caylee and put her in the trunk and left her there, not thinking of decomposition, until two days later and she returned again, thinking she would bury her in the back yard (insane) - why she had to borrow the shovel, I will never know, since George had them in the shed (and why she had to have Tony break the lock, I will also never know, since the key was in the kitchen (as said by Cindy and George) (she likes to see what people will do for her - but still the shovel boggles the mind). So she bagged her up and taped her up and threw her away. and that is what happened.

I don't understand why people wonder who will tell the truth. George told the truth - he said 1 and 1 equals 2. That is his answer. Cindy will lie, Lee will lie and KC will lie.
 
None of the Anthonys could tell THE TRUTH at gunpoint. It seems they are allergic to THE TRUTH.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
163
Guests online
755
Total visitors
918

Forum statistics

Threads
626,342
Messages
18,524,609
Members
241,024
Latest member
boooo.boo
Back
Top