trial day 48: REBUTTAL #145

[Softail]

HA! Love it! Ms. Arias decided to lie on the test! :gavel:

:liar:

 

[JustMeDeb]

DeMarte is everything JA wanted to be - Pretty and smart

 

[JRS_JD2L]

BOOM! Just more evidence that JA decided to lie on a test!

 

[Ari]

Someone enjoys approaching. It's tiresome.

 

[newsjunkie]

JW is testy with that objection.

 

[leebee52]

SOMEONE.....who shall remain nameless is irritating the &^$% out of me!

 

[fran]

Snap!

Ms Arias decided to lie on the test.

Objection!
:floorlaugh:

What's new?
fran

 

[Frigga]

Oh here goes Jennifer stomping her way to the approach!

 

[Weebles]

 

[Snoopy1]

THAT just made my day!!

"Ms Arias chose to LIE on a test!"

BOOM!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Charterhouse]

Stomp stomp, strut strut JW

 

[JusticeJunkie]

whhhoa - is willmott pizzed or whart??

 

[TigerBalm]

Objection don't you dare call my self admitted lying client a liar
:lol:

 

[LotusPawprint]

Poor WS, having a meltdown... it's okay, Uncle Juan is back in control, everything's gonna be okay.... shhhh... calm down....

 

[wenwe4]

Did you receive report/dcs from Cheryl ? . . . .and test data . . . did it contain a diagnosis?
yes
this diagnoss she had something youconsidered in this case
Cheryl carp - psychologist - administered tests - clinical interview . . . . her diagnosis was also that of PTSD . .. correct - triggering eventof the PTSD from Cheryl Carp? . . . Dr Carp said she developed PTSD from the details of her abusive relationship . . . abuse detailed in Dr.Carp report and other documents . . . very different

she reportedto Dr. Carp significantly more abuse than to demarte or to Dr. samulels or ALV . . .
how many incidents of phys. abuse did she tell you? . .. 4 . . .. to Samuels? . . 4 . . . .ALV - 4 . . .Cheryl Carp - how many events did JA indicate toher? . . . can' even count - significantly more to Carp than to witness.

form of document or interview?
part testing
believe it is called partnr/abuse scale --need to review records

Dr. Carp concluded JA had PTSD as part of all of the events in this abusive relationship - not just one event.

Demarte did testing . . . related to Cheryl Carp gave . . . . Trauma Syndrome Inventory (TSI) . . . self report- 100 questions . . .general emotional distress - exposed to some sort of trauma . . . do you have nightmares or intrusive thughts?
DeMarte administered this test twice . . . .. back to back . .. didn't go back another time . . . .on the test . ... follow the protocol Dr. Carp did last 6month . . . .and again one

all 3 tests (2 Demarte and 1 Carp) were similar in (score?)

#620 - she reviews is - previous 6 mon - while in jail . . . exhibit . . . experiencing depression, anxiety, a varity of sympoms . .. nothing different than she being in jail . . .

JD (demarte) wanted her to reflect back in Jan before TA died -he started making remarks she didn'tlike . . . .TSI for Jan 2007 .. . . similar results -except she was havig sexulconcers. . anxity deptression, nightmares intrusive thought,

relatively same as the one for Jan 2007 (reflected) and the one within th last 6 mo.

Trauma Symptom Inventory . . .

Mr. Samuels . . . objection - he is Dr.
allright Ms. Demarte
objection
Did he administer PDS?
Post Tramatic Stress diagositic . . . . raw data - essentially a bubble sheet . . . Samuels gave - typically the answer sheet - person being evaluated . . .they fill it out themselves

when you give this test do you provide the bubble sheet . .. . is MMPI also a bubble type test? yes . . . do you write that down on a legal pad . . . or give them a bubble sheet . . .why not just ask them and write it down?
not protocol - human errorcould be involved. . .. bubble sheet was filed out by whom?. . . I was under the impression Ms. Arias did. . . . unless there was an extreme reason for that to occur.

can't think of extreme reason ok for that.
bubble sheet wasn't scored - just raw data . . . a

bubble sheet . . . .compare with bubble sheet . . .triggering mechanism w/PTSD ...an event that occurred with a stranger . . . not a stranger - it was TA . . . . .it would invalidate it .. . . PTSD is the only diagnosis we can explain the exact etiology . . . . .the specific trauma . . .nightmares aou the car wreck.

PTSD . .. . from an event occurred with a stranger .. . . invalidates test if not specific event.

if she says she still has trauma . . . but not related to a stranger . . . . invalidates the test

does this validate
No because it is just another thing Ms. Aras chose to lie about

Objection JUDGE . . . JW stomps . . . approaching

 

[rose222]

Music to my ears!

 

[Mr.Midnight]

Man Crush on Juan!... Love this Man! if anything were to happen to me Id want him defending my honor

 

[HarvestMoon]

The Judge holds her head !

 

[SunnyinMO]

aaawwwww Jw didn't like the witness saying JA LIED!

 

[Davia18]

WHAT ! JA lied again,, nnooo way