Trinity Poague, Reigning Miss Donalsonville (GA) Facing Murder Charges in the Death of a Young Child - 19 Jan 2024

  • #281
I wondered the same thing. Granted I'm not expert, but I didn't understand not collecting items to be tested. Especially when cause of death was not immediately known.
That wasn’t a great moment regarding the diaper. The defense attorney did a good job on cross examination of the GBI crime scene tech. No weapon or blood was found, yet he didn’t process the scene with luminol to see if it was cleaned up.

Hopefully the states’s case gets stronger.

One thing for sure, after hearing Jake’s testimony today, it was a very toxic & immature relationship. Also not sure how Trinity ever earned that title, she was not a good person at all.
 
  • #282
That wasn’t a great moment regarding the diaper. The defense attorney did a good job on cross examination of the GBI crime scene tech. No weapon or blood was found, yet he didn’t process the scene with luminol to see if it was cleaned up.

Hopefully the states’s case gets stronger.

One thing for sure, after hearing Jake’s testimony today, it was a very toxic & immature relationship. Also not sure how Trinity ever earned that title, she was not a good person at all.
Not at all. I was also confused by how the investigator would not be familiar with a test to check fecal matter for blood. Then later said that he had a kit he could have checked for the presence of blood.

I also would have thought the sippy cup would have been checked for other substances. Again, im no expert. I just hope the state has more evidence. It is the states job to prove the case and at this point, IMO they are not doing a great job.
 
  • #283
I thought the bloody poop diaper was grasping at straws for a prior injury/reasonable doubt but once I saw the photo…. I definitely lean that’s a bloody poop diaper (unless the baby was just eating beets or strawberries or something). No points for the police who left it behind and didn’t test it.
 
  • #284
I thought the bloody poop diaper was grasping at straws for a prior injury/reasonable doubt but once I saw the photo…. I definitely lean that’s a bloody poop diaper (unless the baby was just eating beets or strawberries or something). No points for the police who left it behind and didn’t test it.
I agree, my opinion changed after seeing the diaper.
 
  • #285
Southern girl here. I'm curious about this pageant title. There are scholarship pageants and there there beauty pageants. There are different types that lead to different paths, so to speak. Some are preliminaries that qualify the contestant to participate at a higher level which often involves sholarships along the way or only if you win the state title, such as in the case of the Miss America or Miss USA organizations. There are a few others like this. Then there are the "others" and those are really very often just a pay-to-play type thing. The title really doesn't go anywhere and there are usually no scholarships other than maybe a cash prize. The winner is often the contestant who raised the most money by selling ads in a program. On the surface it looks like the contestant is just selling ads to family, friends, local businesses to get their picture in the program book as many times as possible. In reality, the person who sells the most is awarded the title. I don't see these "organizations" in my community as much these days as I did 10-15 years ago, but when my girls were growing up we would see the least likely kids we knew crowned "queen" of our town when no one had even heard of the event. No idea where it was held and they were definitely not kids who were excelling at school or in the community. I don't mean to sound harsh, but I have a firm understanding of how the traditional pageant system works and these others are not the same even thought they put a lot of money into the crowns, sashes etc. These types are seen as scams by people who understand how the system works. Ever since I saw this story, I have wondered about what "system" her title was in.
 
  • #286
Donalsonville is a very small town. I believe the title she won was a traditional pageant, not a pay to win pageant. But with it being such a small town, the contestant pool was probably quite small and that could be why she won. I’d also be interested in knowing if her parents were influential citizens as well.
 
  • #287
Southern girl here. I'm curious about this pageant title. There are scholarship pageants and there there beauty pageants. There are different types that lead to different paths, so to speak. Some are preliminaries that qualify the contestant to participate at a higher level which often involves sholarships along the way or only if you win the state title, such as in the case of the Miss America or Miss USA organizations. There are a few others like this. Then there are the "others" and those are really very often just a pay-to-play type thing. The title really doesn't go anywhere and there are usually no scholarships other than maybe a cash prize. The winner is often the contestant who raised the most money by selling ads in a program. On the surface it looks like the contestant is just selling ads to family, friends, local businesses to get their picture in the program book as many times as possible. In reality, the person who sells the most is awarded the title. I don't see these "organizations" in my community as much these days as I did 10-15 years ago, but when my girls were growing up we would see the least likely kids we knew crowned "queen" of our town when no one had even heard of the event. No idea where it was held and they were definitely not kids who were excelling at school or in the community. I don't mean to sound harsh, but I have a firm understanding of how the traditional pageant system works and these others are not the same even thought they put a lot of money into the crowns, sashes etc. These types are seen as scams by people who understand how the system works. Ever since I saw this story, I have wondered about what "system" her title was in.
So I am not sure what she received by winning her local pageant other than making her eligible to participate in Miss Peanut. The queen of Miss Peanut does receive a scholarship. The Peanut festival and pageant is huge to do around here.
 
  • #288
Pageants aren’t something in my orbit from Colorado,
JonBenet Ramsey’s murder was the first up close peek into that world, still gives the shivers
 
  • #289
I thought the bloody poop diaper was grasping at straws for a prior injury/reasonable doubt but once I saw the photo…. I definitely lean that’s a bloody poop diaper (unless the baby was just eating beets or strawberries or something). No points for the police who left it behind and didn’t test it.

Me too. What the heck? Is that actually the diaper from the dumpster that Julian threw out in the morning BEFORE anything happened with Trinity? It's confusing because that's how it was presented but the photos showed the diapers on a brown carpet which wasn't the flooring in the dorm and obviously wasn't the flooring at the dumpster site. But the GBI expert said he took the diapers out of the dumpster, took pictures of them, and threw them back in the dumpster.
 
  • #290
Me too. What the heck? Is that actually the diaper from the dumpster that Julian threw out in the morning BEFORE anything happened with Trinity? It's confusing because that's how it was presented but the photos showed the diapers on a brown carpet which wasn't the flooring in the dorm and obviously wasn't the flooring at the dumpster site. But the GBI expert said he took the diapers out of the dumpster, took pictures of them, and threw them back in the dumpster.
I am confused. I thought it looked like brown carpet! I would like to see the pictures of the rest of the trash now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nao
  • #291
My next poop question… if the poop was bloody from internal bleeding… you’d think that there would be blood in the digestive tract at autopsy but there wasn’t any? No food either
 
  • #292
My next poop question… if the poop was bloody from internal bleeding… you’d think that there would be blood in the digestive tract at autopsy but there wasn’t any? No food either
The problem is all the defense has to do is create enough doubt that she may not have done it to the jury.
 
  • #293
Mountain Dew in a sippy cup and Fritos for breakfast? OMG
This prosecutor seems right out of central casting😳
just started reading this thread...this alliance had a lot of issues (!) and the idea that you could care for a child in a dorm room for very long is crazy if you think about no child food/no proper bed/ no proper bathroom- was he going to go in the ladies' shower? And his bio mother left the country... no excuse for murder, but this was not really a sensible arrangement. Did the father have a job and a home?
 
  • #294
just started reading this thread...this alliance had a lot of issues (!) and the idea that you could care for a child in a dorm room for very long is crazy if you think about no child food/no proper bed/ no proper bathroom- was he going to go in the ladies' shower? And his bio mother left the country... no excuse for murder, but this was not really a sensible arrangement. Did the father have a job and a home?
Yes, he lived in colquitt and worked in Bainbridge. He was visiting the dorm for the weekend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nao
  • #295
just started reading this thread...this alliance had a lot of issues (!) and the idea that you could care for a child in a dorm room for very long is crazy if you think about no child food/no proper bed/ no proper bathroom- was he going to go in the ladies' shower? And his bio mother left the country... no excuse for murder, but this was not really a sensible arrangement. Did the father have a job and a home?

Trinity's dorm was set up such that there was a private bathroom/shower for her and her roommate (named Paris) to share. The boyfriend and his baby used that bathroom/shower. I only imagine that was probably uncomfortable for the roommate, though. I know I'd be uncomfortable if I was the roommate in that situation.

Here is a picture of the layout of the dorm, from the college website. Trinity had the bedroom on the left and Paris had the bedroom on the right. Southwestern Oaks


Screenshot 2025-12-03 at 11.49.40 AM.webp
 
  • #296
Trinity's dorm was set up such that there was a private bathroom/shower for her and her roommate (named Paris) to share. The boyfriend and his baby used that bathroom/shower. I only imagine that was probably uncomfortable for the roommate, though. I know I'd be uncomfortable if I was the roommate in that situation.

Here is a picture of the layout of the dorm, from the college website. Trinity had the bedroom on the left and Paris had the bedroom on the right. Southwestern Oaks


View attachment 628357
my dorm many years ago had a shared bathroom down the hall and not much in the way of amenities.
there really was not what you would consider privacy; no close by stores- feeding a child would have involved stealing milk from the dining hall, I guess and no one carried water bottles in those days. of course there were apartments for upper classes but they were small too. four or five people in a two bedroom and one shared bath.
 
  • #297
I understand what the defense is doing, but there is no way IMO that baby fell off the bed or the chair and received the injuries he had.
 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
132
Guests online
1,466
Total visitors
1,598

Forum statistics

Threads
635,427
Messages
18,676,168
Members
243,225
Latest member
ScoobydoobyDont
Back
Top