GUILTY TX - Sherin Mathews, 3, Richardson, 7 Oct 2017 #9

[Yellow Rose]

His testimony was complete poppycock, and made zero sense to anyone. Least of all the jurors. And Sini escaping prosecution absolutely floors me and will til the day I move on.

 

[MissMalowe]

I'm surprised they didn't get her for SOMETHING. Even if we assume her claims of not being awake at the time it occured are actually true, she had knowledge that Sherin was dead and that Wesley had disposed of her. But allowed a bogus "missing child" investigation to continue.

 

[nannymo]

I will always feel her death was earlier than what they have speculated and that Sini was involved way more than Wesley. It has always been my opinion Sini was the most abusive and Wesley is taking the fall for her, but I could never prove it! JMO

 

[TristanP]

I too feel that the verdict is bitter/sweet. IMO, there will be no complete justice until Sini gets her due.

Please tell me she’s not working as a nurse.

Is there any kind of civil action that can be brought against her??

 

[Ksprincess2]

Please tell me she’s not working as a nurse.

Is there any kind of civil action that can be brought against her??

I couldn't find an active nursing license for her when I looked one day recently.

Side note: Just now looking at the date in the title of this thread I realized why I was so late following little Sherin's case, because my own sweet baby girl was born on October 7th, 2017, the same day sweet Sherin died

 

[TristanP]

I couldn't find an active nursing license for her when I looked one day recently.

Side note: Just now looking at the date in the title of this thread I realized why I was so late following little Sherin's case, because my own sweet baby girl was born on October 7th, 2017, the same day sweet Sherin died

Awww maybe Sherin is her guardian angel.

 

[Rocco]

I thought the judge in this case did an excellent job. No playing to the cameras as some judges do when thy preside over a high profile case that's being live streamed. Shame on the people who were apparently more interested in what she looked like than they were in the case.

Dallas County Judge Responds to Criticism About Shaved Hairstyle and Bold Makeup

 

[altojack]

I thought the judge in this case did an excellent job. No playing to the cameras as some judges do when thy preside over a high profile case that's being live streamed. Shame on the people who were apparently more interested in what she looked like than they were in the case.

Dallas County Judge Responds to Criticism About Shaved Hairstyle and Bold Makeup

I've just watched the video and seen some of the comments made. Judge Givens was brilliant, very focused on the case.

She's done her time to get where she is, I just thought some comments were very childish and nasty.

 

[blue22]

I thought she was wonderful as a judge. I was very impressed with her demeanor and command during the trial. People are idiots. Her response was total class.

 

[Deleted member 158085]

I've just watched the video and seen some of the comments made. Judge Givens was brilliant, very focused on the case.

She's done her time to get where she is, I just thought some comments were very childish and nasty.

The only two things I noticed about her appearance were 1- I remember thinking I loved the collar she wore on the day of the verdict and 2- I thought, wow, if judges are this young, I’m getting old. (I’m at that age where I’ve started realizing a lot of professionals, like doctors, are younger than me - and it’s unsettling for me.)

I’m sorry other people can be so vile. None of those comments were called for.

 

[altojack]

The only two things I noticed about her appearance were 1- I remember thinking I loved the collar she wore on the day of the verdict and 2- I thought, wow, if judges are this young, I’m getting old. (I’m at that age where I’ve started realizing a lot of professionals, like doctors, are younger than me - and it’s unsettling for me.)

I’m sorry other people can be so vile. None of those comments were called for.

My thoughts exactly. I never expected to see such a young looking judge, and as to modern and up to date, wow. Let's see more.

 

[Doghairrules]

Officers' body cam footage :
J.D. Miles on Twitter
J.D. Miles on Twitter

* Thanks, JerricaBenton, for the live feed.

That footage of him casually strolling around with no urgency makes me want to vomit.

 

[Doghairrules]

She manages to say ''Dadda, Dadda'' while she's coughing? Sure she did. This 'milk' story is nonsense. I wonder what really happened.

And I am not a medical person but have training in infant. And toddler cpr and choking. His description doesn’t match anything I’ve been told about what happens when a child chokes. And his response is to do NOTHING? Unbelievable.

 

[Doghairrules]

He wanted to place her by the trees but he spotted the culvert. His heart spoke to him, told him the culvert looks dark and I bet there is a snake in there that will bite me so I can go to my Lord with my child. So he shoved her in.

I call BS On this.

 

[Doghairrules]

YOu never mentioned a piano before
WM - I dont remember what I told the police
Pros- its hard to keep up with lies, huh?
WM - can you repeat that?

Let me rephrase so he can understand: YOU, “SIR,” are a LYING LIAR WHO LIES.

 

[AvidListener]

Just thought to let you all know it would have been Sherin Matthew's 5th birthday today (July 14th). I can't say good night to her thought just yet.

 

[altojack]

Just thought to let you all know it would have been Sherin Matthew's 5th birthday today (July 14th). I can't say good night to her thought just yet.

5 years old, oh my. She could have had such a wonderful Birthday if she had gone to a family that was full of love for her.

 

[Laughing]

She would start Kindergarten in a few weeks....

 

[WichitaFalls]

Wesley Mathews Files Legal Challenge Over Life Sentence
The defense attorney for Wesley Mathews is expected to file a legal challenge on Friday after Mathews was sentenced to life in prison for his daughter's death in 2017, NBC 5 has learned. More at link.

Wesley Mathews Files Motion for New Trial

 

[Laughing]

Sooooo...the pictures of what he did to that precious baby, photographic images of his actions, were prejudicial & shouldn't have been shown to the jury???

Um, gee, that sounds like evidence to me, and aren't all juries presented with evidence???

I'm not a lawyer, or a nurse answering a pediatric helpline, but I don't see a problem with those pictures.

"Our" Sherin, with the other injured party:



JMHO YMMV