UK - Alesha MacPhail, 6, raped & murdered, Ardbeg, Isle of Bute, Scotland, 2 Jul 2018 -*arrest* #4

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #881
I actually do believe the affair with TM and I don't know why. I've been thinking over it for the past while and my thoughts haven't changed. I know most people on here probably don't and that's understandable given who he is, but for some reason, I think it did happen. I could very well be wrong though.
 
  • #882
All of his youtube videos are now blacked out?
Perhaps youtube have realised that leaving them up and thereby identifying all the people also in them that aren't him isn't a great idea.
 
  • #883
Until he got to the top he had no way to know the key was in the door and thus no reason to conceal his hands?

Oh I thought the key had been left in the bottom door and the top door was just open anyway.
 
  • #884
  • #885
I actually do believe the affair with TM and I don't know why. I've been thinking over it for the past while and my thoughts haven't changed. I know most people on here probably don't and that's understandable given who he is, but for some reason, I think it did happen. I could very well be wrong though.

I believe there was something, yes. Just a hunch.
 
  • #886
  • #887
nevermind
 
  • #888
All of his youtube videos are now blacked out?

I can still see them, but earlier today I got a weird error when I tried to see them and I thought they'd been removed. Then I refreshed and they were there.
 
  • #889
All of his videos have a black square over his face for me. Some have the whole video blacked.

They're working normally for me on both channels. Strange. Maybe they're in the process of being removed.
 
  • #890
Ok sorry, it was my graphics card updating, all youtube videos black
 
  • #891
Hi Ciana,

Thanks for this. Yes the level of abuse aimed at those with differing opinions has been disproportionate imo. I too think there are people (on the island) who know more but are scared to speak out as they also know how retaliation works. I thought the neihbours were brave to take the stand and give evidence as they had already been told to mind their own business and obviously headed the warning. Yet posters on here ripped even their testimony apart (usually confusing theirs with the other witness in the car and vice versa). To be honest it made me think that a few posters on here had a vested interest in the case....if you know what i mean.

Yes, for sure, the mother of the poor girl deserves the utmost sympathy. How one continues with life after such an event is beyond me, it will haunt her every minute of the day no doubt.

The abuse will not stop me posting on here as we all know how the internet works and this case is very emotive to say the least. It's hard to judge someone via the internet, but i know i don't say things lightly and i'm certainly not contrary for the sake of it. I like to find the truth in things but once i realise i'm barking up the wrong tree i will gladly throw all of my suppositions out of the window. However, this case keeps throwing up more cause for doubt, even in the aftermath of a guilty verdict. All very strange indeed.

I look forward to sleuthing some more with you all in the future!

Strange user name for someone so articulate
 
  • #892
Ironic that he wanted to be popular on YouTube and in the past week his channel has doubled in subscribers and gained over 30,000 views while he's behind bars.
 
  • #893
Just been to check if the you tube videos are still visible. Certainly the 2 of him trampolining are very much still there and not blacked out. Interesting that his subscribers have increased/doubled in the last day or so. Not sure about the poison3d appl3 ones though
 
  • #894
I actually do believe the affair with TM and I don't know why. I've been thinking over it for the past while and my thoughts haven't changed. I know most people on here probably don't and that's understandable given who he is, but for some reason, I think it did happen. I could very well be wrong though.

Me too! I never doubted it for a second although there was every chance i was wrong as there was (and appears, still is) no proof. What i found intriguing was that many posters thought the idea ridiculous, as if TM was some high class, well heeled, successful older woman and AC a spotty, pathetic teenager trying to impress his friends. I'm not sure his friends would have been all that impressed but hey - ho.
 
  • #895
Hi Ciana,

Thanks for this. Yes the level of abuse aimed at those with differing opinions has been disproportionate imo. I too think there are people (on the island) who know more but are scared to speak out as they also know how retaliation works. I thought the neihbours were brave to take the stand and give evidence as they had already been told to mind their own business and obviously headed the warning. Yet posters on here ripped even their testimony apart (usually confusing theirs with the other witness in the car and vice versa). To be honest it made me think that a few posters on here had a vested interest in the case....if you know what i mean.

Yes, for sure, the mother of the poor girl deserves the utmost sympathy. How one continues with life after such an event is beyond me, it will haunt her every minute of the day no doubt.

The abuse will not stop me posting on here as we all know how the internet works and this case is very emotive to say the least. It's hard to judge someone via the internet, but i know i don't say things lightly and i'm certainly not contrary for the sake of it. I like to find the truth in things but once i realise i'm barking up the wrong tree i will gladly throw all of my suppositions out of the window. However, this case keeps throwing up more cause for doubt, even in the aftermath of a guilty verdict. All very strange indeed.

I look forward to sleuthing some more with you all in the future!

Many of us have been in the same position of having an opposing view to the majority and it is definitely not fun. In fact, I have an opposing view on a case that occurred in Europe, but there is no way I would ever say a word lol.
 
  • #896
Oh I thought the key had been left in the bottom door and the top door was just open anyway.
Hmm, i thought it was the other way round (bottom door open, top door with key in) but could be wrong.

Either way i guess it's possible he was deciding as he crept up the stairs (rail is LOW, so he was crawling/creeping to be using that instead of the banister) what he was going to do. I think he went looking for drugs, and i think he took the knife to protect himself from Rab, not to threaten Alesha. I think he probably just came across her quite near the door, given the squeaky door and many people in there sleeping who didn't wake. I read earlier someone's theory that the angles of the CCTV from the shore made it look like he was carrying something on his back in one image and something dangling in front of him in the other, the inference being that she was actually over his shoulder in both cases. Like a fireman's lift. So unconscious?
 
  • #897
  • #898
The six-year-old, from Coatbridge , had gone to Bute to stay with dad Rab, 26, a few days earlier but her granddad took her back to her hometown on Sunday, July 1, for a friend’s party.

The youngster had been “devastated” after arriving to realise it was the wrong day but her tears were short-lived when she was asked to join in another party with a friend.
Daily Record

Thanks for this. It seems even going to a party is not straight forward in this case.
 
  • #899
Until he got to the top he had no way to know the key was in the door and thus no reason to conceal his hands?

Does a 16 year old boy need to use a handrail up some stairs anyway??

Unless they were carrying something heavy....
 
  • #900
Does a 16 year old boy need to use a handrail up some stairs anyway??

Unless they were carrying something heavy....
Like a child. Coming down. We don’t know which way the palm print was facing (up or down), do we?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
133
Guests online
964
Total visitors
1,097

Forum statistics

Threads
632,391
Messages
18,625,727
Members
243,133
Latest member
nikkisanchez
Back
Top