GUILTY UK - Ellie Butler, 6, brutally murdered, Sutton, 28 Oct 2013 #2

  • #761
Thank you Michelle.

Not sure I would have been able to restrain myself from shouting at her. Although maybe risking contempt of court would have done it!

Thinking back about when I was in court, it is true that it's hard to reconcile her 'hard' behaviour there with a woman that writes love spells?!
 
  • #762
Thanks Cottonweaver for you kind comments! And I`ll take your good advice when writing a message so I don`t have to yell in frustration when a message disappears into cyberspace!
The reason that I go to the courts when I have time is to study the people..their behaviour..their relationships. I try to work out who they are, what they`re thinking, where they`re coming from. Do they believe their own lies? Do they feel? What is their own background?
Just think - BB and JG stood to make SO much money out of Ellie - they were suing left right and centre - damage to reputation, wrongful arrest, wrongful imprisonment, him unable to work because of what was "done to him", deprivation of years of family life etc etc. And they may not care about Ellie - but they sure as heck must have cared about all that lovely dosh that was coming their way in compensation. And yet, still...still with all that money at stake..he still couldn`t control himself. I`m sure he curses himself - not because of what he did to his own daughter, but because he`s lost his lottery win.
Yes, she was smoking right outside the door in court where the defendants, jurors etc go in. Quite relaxed. Quite fine.
On a different note, on Monday PM one of the jurors on the case was ill so there was no court. I ended up going to another (very different) case that I am also interested in. Perversely it is at the opposite end of the spectrum. It is how a mother ended up committing a crime for her adult son. Her son is in prison serving a long sentence for a drugs gang, drive by shooting. He (they) are from a very wealthy family and he attended the best private schools but his ambition from when he was a teenager was to be a "gangsta". His mother and girlfriend and a (corrupt) police officer are on trial for illegally accessing police files with details of protected witnesses who gave evidence against her son. Really shocking breach of security which should never have happened.
The mother, Diana Lank, (girlfriend Lydia Lauro, police officer Hayden Cheremeh) in this case simply cannot accept what her son is and what he did.
A very different case but very interesting and the same self denial of truth!
Regards
Michelle

Thanks Michelle, I fell asleep so I didn't see your reply.
I think I have heard of the "gangsta" boy case in the press- it rings a bell.

You know that if you find a UK case, that you feel will be reported and capture interest, you can, yourself, start a new thread on it.

Anyway, I think we have been very lucky on this thread to have you, Tortoise and Flutterby, all going down to court to report on this. It will be great when you can all share "notes" together and maybe those others from the public gallery who might join WS after verdict is given. ( Wouldn't that be great.)

The £ angle is an interesting one as that has never been brought up before on this thread. I did try and look , last month, how much "compo" he would get for wrongful conviction but I noticed the rules had changed sometime around 2013 so they must have felt thwarted. I've also joked about that typical "compo face" he has put on in the earlier press interviews he gave in 2012!.
Right from the start of thread 1 I found it fascinating how he justified not working in his interviews, in relation to the earlier case, the fights. The dates didn't match , if you like. He never gave up a job to look after Ellie, he never went to work when Ellie was removed yet he used the kids and then the "fights" to justify staying home. ( I also didn't think that an unskilled job would be that hard to find somewhere like Sutton area, admittedly low paid. ) I think OLive(?) poster is from here, so she would know better.

From reports we know he has worked - removals man, car salesman, office work- I presume he was sacked TBH , or was forced into these brief temp roles even at risk of losing his benefits.
Also have always wondered if JG paid him pocket £, even if they weren't dating, to look after E & I, at different points, to top up his benefits? IDK, it's hard to work out their co-hab and financials as they did so much lying.

Smoking right outside the front- as brazen as she first appeared- I presume you saw the early photos of her filming the press LOL.
 
  • #763
Thank you Michelle.

Not sure I would have been able to restrain myself from shouting at her. Although maybe risking contempt of court would have done it!

Thinking back about when I was in court, it is true that it's hard to reconcile her 'hard' behaviour there with a woman that writes love spells?!

Look at what she's asking for in the spells though. She's not asking for world peace and an end to all suffering ... nope she's asking for things for herself.

"Please don't let Ben leave me but make him learn to like me. Stop violence and make him WANT ME and be there at the birth if I have a baby boy."

My bold. Me, me,me! Her spells don't surprise me at all. She's always put her own wants and needs first and her spells reflect that. To be fair, she does also mention being happy together as a family "Please make my home .. Ellie, Ben and I all happy together as a family." but even that is about what she wants, for them to be a "happy family' rather than what would be best for her daughter, which would have been to get the hell away from BB.
 
  • #764
Just think - BB and JG stood to make SO much money out of Ellie - they were suing left right and centre - damage to reputation, wrongful arrest, wrongful imprisonment, him unable to work because of what was "done to him", deprivation of years of family life etc etc. And they may not care about Ellie - but they sure as heck must have cared about all that lovely dosh that was coming their way in compensation. And yet, still...still with all that money at stake..he still couldn`t control himself. I`m sure he curses himself - not because of what he did to his own daughter, but because he`s lost his lottery win.

Yes, I keep forgetting that. That additional possible motive for wanting Ellie back, JG staying with BB, not getting Ellie medical treatment for her shoulder,not calling the ambulance till a cover up was completed. BB not only risked going back to prison if it was revealed he was harming Ellie, he(they) risked losing out on a massive payout. Worrying thought... would he still be able to pursue that compensation if he's found not guilty?
 
  • #765
Hi - yes I was at court this afternoon.
I have been going for quite a few afternoons over the past couple of weeks. I actually wrote a long post yesterday but when I pressed send it got lost and I couldn`t face rewriting the whole thing!!!
This PM was the judge`s summing up of all the medical witnesses. It really was damming. The few witnesses for the defence which came after those for the prosecution seemed so weak by comparison. It was daunting listening to it.
Re the behaviour of BB and JG over the days I have been there. This sounds strange and it is only my opinion but BB - at times anyway - seemed to show at least some pain/shame whereas JG showed none whatsoever. She was busy listening intently, nodding like a Churchill dog when it suited her, and scribbling copious notes to pass to her counsel, no doubt over petty, minor things - the actions of a desperate woman who is in total self denial. He hung his head a lot, or had his head in his hands as various times e.g. when the defence were discussing how he went out for a walk "to clear his head" instead of calling 999. Also when the unbelievable catalogue of injuries/fractures that Ellie had sustained were listed and dissected at length and in many different ways today, with numerous graphic details of the different impacts on the brain. To hear a seemingly never ending roll of damages sustained by repeated trauma and to hear the impact of these......well....for him to be forced to sit through that and listen to the actual effects of his gross violence in real medical terms....there was nowhere for him to run. He just had to sit there and hear it all.
Actually, on Friday his own defence pointed out to the jury that he was "a thoroughly unpleasant man".....followed of course by "..but that`s not what you are judging him on..". I guess that his counsel felt it was damage limitation to state the obvious so that he could soften it by his follow up remark.
She (JG) stood next to me outside having a cigarette just before going in after lunch. It felt surreal to watch her standing there so calmly, knowing who she was and what she had done.
Just to add that the judge is finishing his directions tomorrow - the defence of BB and JG. He hopes to be finished by lunch time. He plans to sent the jury home for the afternoon then and sent them out on Friday morning to consider their verdict.
Hope my post is helpful and.....I did warn you that I wouldn`t be as good as Tortoise!!! Are you going to be there tomorrow or Friday, Tortoise?
Best wishes
Michelle

Thanks for the feedback Michelle, I have also lost long posts in the past and it is so frustrating!

Glad to hear the medical evidence is damning. Combined with their own non-believable testimony of the day Ellie died, and the evidence of the preceding 11 months, I have a hunch the jury will be back with a verdict before you can turn around.

I'm going to come back and do a longer post about the behaviour of BB and JG, take my time over it and explain how I see it.

I'm not sure if I'll be there tomorrow for the verdicts (look at that for confidence in the jury! :D), but I will try to be.
 
  • #766
Ah, summing up must have finished as Michelle said. Case adjourned to 10am tomorrow.

Sleep on it jurors.
 
  • #767
Another case in today's paper - what on earth is going on in the UK?

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news...-killed-attention-seeking-toddler-court-hears



No doubt "lessons will be learned" after a "Serious case review", once again, forever.....
You can't shut the gate once the horse has bolted.

There has got to be a Stronger plus possibly backup with Police. That if these children aren't keeping appointments. Whether doc health visitor school or dentist. And they're not taking visits by the Social worker. Then they need to get a warrant. So they can physically see the child in question.

Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
 
  • #768
Yes, I keep forgetting that. That additional possible motive for wanting Ellie back, JG staying with BB, not getting Ellie medical treatment for her shoulder,not calling the ambulance till a cover up was completed. BB not only risked going back to prison if it was revealed he was harming Ellie, he(they) risked losing out on a massive payout. Worrying thought... would he still be able to pursue that compensation if he's found not guilty?

I think he'll try and get more money if he's found not guilty!
 
  • #769
Hi - quick post just to say that we should have a competition - "Guess the reaction of the accused when found guilty"!! My guess is (screaming hysterically), "It`s another f...ing miscarriage of justice. You won`t get away with this.." Anyone else?
I think that the judge has been extremely careful throughout the trial to ensure there is absolutely no possibility of an appeal. BB and JG have been a real gift to the taxpayer - not! Their case(s) have cost a fortune.
Michelle x
 
  • #770
By the way, some of you may find this interesting - lots about the Butler`s original appealhttp://www.4pb.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Re_Litigation_in_Family_Cases_-_the_emerging_law_and_practice_JD_FLJ_Jan_2013.pdf
 
  • #771
Thank you Michelle.

Not sure I would have been able to restrain myself from shouting at her. Although maybe risking contempt of court would have done it!

Thinking back about when I was in court, it is true that it's hard to reconcile her 'hard' behaviour there with a woman that writes love spells?!
Umm errrmmm I'd be the type of clumsy person.. you know what's her name on 'gimme gimme gimme' Lynda.
I'd cough n trip n craftily tips some itching powder down her top as she looked down. At my stiletto heel. I'd flinch a sneeze and oooo I'm so sorry bout that. N standing on her mary jane shoe. (That my MOTHER wore when due was 80 years old!)

[emoji102]


Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
 
  • #772
I'm getting utterly bored waiting n waiting. Huff!
I'm sure BW wasn't like this. Someone from the press was there everyday tweeting


Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
 
  • #773
Hi - quick post just to say that we should have a competition - "Guess the reaction of the accused when found guilty"!! My guess is (screaming hysterically), "It`s another f...ing miscarriage of justice. You won`t get away with this.." Anyone else?
I think that the judge has been extremely careful throughout the trial to ensure there is absolutely no possibility of an appeal. BB and JG have been a real gift to the taxpayer - not! Their case(s) have cost a fortune.
Michelle x

my guess

BB will kick the chairs or kick the dock, and be restrained and taken out
JG will rant and shout at the jury

I hope they beef up the security.
 
  • #774
  • #775
my guess

BB will kick the chairs or kick the dock, and be restrained and taken out
JG will rant and shout at the jury

I hope they beef up the security.
My guess

BB will beat his fists on the glass dock. Shouting "you've stitched us up yr all barstewards " we said this from the start. You all jump to conclusions. ( as she sits there rocking backward n foreword scribbling in her diary as she bobbles her Churchillian head)
"Shouting BB is a wonderful dad. He loved Ellie and our other daughter none of you will listen to us so you make a date in yr DIARY for 3 months time when WE APPEAL!"
Meanwhile BB (BustaBloodvessel)
Has a right rage going on. As JG passes him notes on paper he's eating them. As he's so paranoid there's cameras everywhere. His face is a nice tomato red colour........

Ahhhh it's Friday. Now where is my cup of tea?

[emoji23]

Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
 
  • #776
Just quoting this to see if I can make the link work
Link works fine Squish ty

Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
 
  • #777
I've been working too hard this week and haven't posted much. But be been reading and waiting as have all of you.

As for how they will react? He will pound his fists and claim we have it all wrong and yes she will be writing notes and nodding her annoying head. Ugh I can't stand either of them. Want them to go away for a long long time.
 
  • #778
Hi - quick post just to say that we should have a competition - "Guess the reaction of the accused when found guilty"!! My guess is (screaming hysterically), "It`s another f...ing miscarriage of justice. You won`t get away with this.." Anyone else?
I think that the judge has been extremely careful throughout the trial to ensure there is absolutely no possibility of an appeal. BB and JG have been a real gift to the taxpayer - not! Their case(s) have cost a fortune.
Michelle x

I am pleased he has been careful , we know how these 2 like an appeal! It will be interesting to see if any family arw there today!
 
  • #779
I don't care what their reactions are to a guilty verdict as long as there IS a guilty verdict, but no doubt they'll keep up their miscarriage of justice act.

Horrible pair. Praying today for a guilty verdict on all charges :please::please::please::please:
 
  • #780
CourtNewsUK ‏@CourtNewsUK [video=twitter;743741739739951104]https://twitter.com/CourtNewsUK/status/743741739739951104[/video]
Jury trying Ben Butler, accused of murdering his six-year-old child in a moment of volcanic rage, retires to consider its verdicts
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
69
Guests online
1,305
Total visitors
1,374

Forum statistics

Threads
632,471
Messages
18,627,214
Members
243,163
Latest member
420Nana
Back
Top