GUILTY UK - Nicole Smallman, 27 & Bibaa Henry 46, Archdeacon's daughters, murdered London park, 7 June 2020

  • #621
  • #622
In his closing speech, Mr Glasgow QC told jurors: “Given the weight of the evidence against him, only someone who actually believes that an agreement with a demon will work could refuse to accept any aspect of the case against him.

“Perhaps he still believes that Lucifuge Rofocale will come to his aid, but unfortunately for the defendant, there are no deals to be had in these courts and the devil (if he is anywhere) is in the detail.”

Outlining the tragic circumstances, he said: “For Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman, Friday, June 5 was supposed to be a celebration of life; a birthday party, a night where you reflect on the year you have had and look forward to the year that will be.

“It was supposed to be an evening of friendship and love; a chance to spend time with those closest to you.

“And it was supposed to end with both sisters returning home to their loved ones with smiles on their faces and fond memories to look back on.

“For this defendant, however, the celebration he had planned was quite different

“It was a celebration of death, not of life; it was a night of sacrifice and violence, not of shared emotions; and it was the start of his planned campaign of vengeance that would see part of his twisted bargain fulfilled and leave him looking forward to the riches he believed would soon come his way.

“It is hard to imagine that anyone could do to another human being what this defendant did to Bibaa and Nicole; but to have planned it, to have prepared it and to have performed it with such ruthless selfishness is truly terrifying.

“He did not care what he had to do to get what he wanted, and these two women were nothing more than a means to a very disturbing end.

“Indeed, the last few minutes of Bibaa and Nicole’s lives must have been truly terrifying.”

The defendant’s claim that someone else wrote the agreement to sacrifice women for a lottery win was almost as ridiculous as the document itself, the lawyer asserted.

“The person responsible for this perverse document and the person responsible for the brutal slaying of two women are one and the same individual: this defendant,” Mr Glasgow said.

He also dismissed the suggestion by the defence that the crime scene could have been contaminated, saying there was no evidence from Hussein to explain how his blood and DNA got there.


Earlier, trial judge Mrs Justice Whipple warned jurors not to be drawn into speculation or influenced by emotion as they assessed the evidence.

On the central issue of the case, she said the prosecution say the evidence shows the killer was Hussein while the defendant asserts that the jury “cannot be sure of that”



'A night of sacrifice and violence' court hears
 
  • #623
Central Criminal Court 9 T20207198
Danyal Hussein
Details: Trial (Part Heard) - Resume - 10:32
Trial (Part Heard) - DANYAL HUSSEIN; Defence Closing Speech - 10:34
Trial (Part Heard) - Case adjourned until 11:40 - 11:28
Trial (Part Heard) - DANYAL HUSSEIN; Defence Closing Speech - 11:42
Trial (Part Heard) - Case adjourned until 13:45 - 12:31
Trial (Part Heard) - Resume - 13:45
Trial (Part Heard) - Resume - 14:58
Trial (Part Heard) - Case adjourned until 10:00 - 15:34

https://www.thelawpages.com/court-hearings-lists/Central-Criminal-Court.php
 
  • #624
Sisters' murder trial likened to a 'leaky ship' by defence lawyer

On Friday (July 2), his lawyer Riel Karmy-Jones QC told jurors to consider the evidence against him carefully and not be swayed by sorrow or anger at the tragic loss of life.

She suggested the police considered the case a “slam dunk” after identifying Hussein as a suspect and then closed down other avenues of investigation, leaving “many loose ends”.

Ms Karmy-Jones described the case against Hussein as a “leaky ship”, which on closer inspection had holes in it.

She told jurors: “Just remember another leaky ship, the Titanic. Beautiful, shiny and new as it set sail. A ship that could not sink. But it did.”

The defence lawyer said there were problems with some of the evidence as it was initially presented.

One example she gave was that three lottery tickets seized from Hussein’s bedroom were presented as being tucked into the alleged demonic agreement to sacrifice women to win a jackpot - when they had been found nearby.

Ms Karmy-Jones said: “So look at the evidence yourselves and decide what the evidence tells you and what inferences you can draw from it.”

She said Hussein had only just turned 18 at the time of the killings and had no previous convictions.

On his arrest, he told police he had autism, a bad memory and that he had been robbed in explanation for cuts to his hand.

His lawyer asked: “Why must you assume he was not telling the police the truth and he was not robbed that night and that was not how his injuries occurred?”


On his demeanour, she said: “You have seen how he has behaved in court. You may think at times his behaviour has been odd.

“Please judge him on the evidence, not on his behaviour in court if you have noticed something out of the ordinary.”

The trial continues.


BBM
 
  • #625
She told jurors: “Just remember another leaky ship, the Titanic. Beautiful, shiny and new as it set sail. A ship that could not sink. But it did.”
Sounds like they've resorted to the Chewbacca defence.
 
  • #626
Central Criminal Court 9 T20207198
Danyal Hussein
Details: Trial (Part Heard) - Resume - 10:32
Trial (Part Heard) - DANYAL HUSSEIN; Defence Closing Speech - 10:34
Trial (Part Heard) - Case adjourned until 11:40 - 11:28
Trial (Part Heard) - DANYAL HUSSEIN; Defence Closing Speech - 11:42
Trial (Part Heard) - Case adjourned until 13:45 - 12:31
Trial (Part Heard) - Resume - 13:45
Trial (Part Heard) - Resume - 14:58
Trial (Part Heard) - Case adjourned until 10:00 - 15:34

https://www.thelawpages.com/court-hearings-lists/Central-Criminal-Court.php


Am I missing something ? It's only 13.45 hrs now ?
 
  • #627
  • #628
  • #629
  • #630
  • #631
I think the timings shown on the Law Pages - above - indicate the Jury is out
 
  • #632
It's from Friday.

I posted it so we would not be too surprised in case of an acquittal... always good to hear both sides of the case, even if one side is lacking.

:rolleyes:
 
  • #633
  • #634
I posted it so we would not be too surprised in case of an acquittal... always good to hear both sides of the case, even if one side is lacking.

:rolleyes:
Thanks for posting. The defense found themselves dead in the water in the middle of a gale.

Even on a leaky ship, the necessary preparation, supplies and actions will be more than sufficient to reach port safely.
:rolleyes:
 
  • #635
  • #636
The defence lawyer said there were problems with some of the evidence as it was initially presented.

One example she gave was that three lottery tickets seized from Hussein’s bedroom were presented as being tucked into the alleged demonic agreement to sacrifice women to win a jackpot - when they had been found nearby.

Ms Karmy-Jones said: “So look at the evidence yourselves and decide what the evidence tells you and what inferences you can draw from it.”

She said Hussein had only just turned 18 at the time of the killings and had no previous convictions.

On his arrest, he told police he had autism, a bad memory and that he had been robbed in explanation for cuts to his hand.

His lawyer asked: “Why must you assume he was not telling the police the truth and he was not robbed that night and that was not how his injuries occurred?”

On his demeanour, she said: “You have seen how he has behaved in court. You may think at times his behaviour has been odd.

“Please judge him on the evidence, not on his behaviour in court if you have noticed something out of the ordinary.”


Sisters' murder trial likened to a 'leaky ship' by defence lawyer
 
  • #637
If I was on the jury, I'd be ready to return a verdict within 60 seconds. Make it 5 minutes for coffee and biscuits as well. There literally is no defence case.
 
  • #638
If I was on the jury, I'd be ready to return a verdict within 60 seconds. Make it 5 minutes for coffee and biscuits as well. There literally is no defence case.
Same, the DNA is extremely strong evidence.

I don’t understand why this guy hasn’t claimed mental illness as a defence because he’s clearly not right. He needs to be locked up in a hospital rather than a jail imo.
 
  • #639
  • #640
Finding it a bit worrying that there is no verdict as yet with what is - seemingly - such clear evidence.

11 jurors only, could that be causing a problem ?
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
88
Guests online
2,755
Total visitors
2,843

Forum statistics

Threads
633,217
Messages
18,638,068
Members
243,449
Latest member
100K
Back
Top