GUILTY UK - Steven Donaldson, 27, murdered, Loch of Kinnordy, Scotland, 6/7 June 2018

  • #101
I'm finding Callums evidence more believe by far than Dickies!
Me too. Dickie was trying way too hard to try and seem like he wasn't bothered about Donaldson and make out that him and Tasmin weren't really a thing. I believe Callum was involved more than he's saying but his version is much closer to the truth by a long way.

Plus, I always appreciate when someone mentions the word "rammy". Just find that word so funny. :D
 
  • #102
I think Davidson’s version of events is what happened but I think he has diluted his involvement. Also don’t believe that he’s the type to be intimidated by Dickie to do things on his command. Think they are both as bad as each other.

Wonder if TG will defend herself? She seems to be getting off lightly because the other two are intent on blaming each other.
 
  • #103
Murder accused Callum Davidson has admitted putting on a show for the cameras in a 2am bike ride through an Angus town as his alleged victim’s battered corpse lay beside his smouldering BMW at a nearby beauty spot.

The 24-year-old farmhand was captured on CCTV in Kirriemuir just hours before Steven Donaldson’s body was found at the Kinnordy nature reserve.

In the witness box at the High Court in Edinburgh yesterday, Davidson said he had gone there under the orders of co-accused Steven Dickie — but denied it was to “clean up” a murder scene.

Jurors also heard Dickie, 24, had bragged to a fellow prisoner that he stabbed Mr Donaldson 26 times – the exact number of wounds revealed in an autopsy report – when the pair were in a cell together at Perth.

Davidson, Dickie and a third co-accused Tasmin Glass, 20, all deny murdering Mr Donaldson on June 6 or 7 2018.

The trio are accused of assaulting the 27-year-old oil worker from Arbroath at the Peter Pan children’s play park in Kirriemuir.

Prosecutors allege they then took him to the car park at Loch of Kinnordy where he was beaten, before his body and his car were set on fire.

Giving evidence in his own defence for a second day, Davidson rejected a suggestion by Dickie’s defence counsel, Ian Duguid QC, that he was a “gratuitously violent man” who would get involved in violence for no reason.

However, he told Crown prosecutor Ashley Edwards QC he had hit Mr Donaldson three times at the Hill, before Dickie stepped in.

The trial has heard the pair went there after Glass had arranged to meet Mr Donaldson, her ex-boyfriend.

On the 17th day of evidence yesterday, the court heard Dickie, who was in a relationship with Glass, then ordered him to drive the oil worker’s BMW to Kinnordy.

Jurors were told Mr Donaldson was in the back, covered in blood after a frenzied attack by Dickie, who had a knife.

“Did Steven Donaldson start to come to, to fight back?” asked the advocate depute.

Davidson said: “The whole time he was shouting, the two of them were shouting at each other and Steven (Dickie) would hit the other lad to keep him quiet.

“I thought he had died through the time I was driving,” he said.

Davidson denied he had collected a weapon from his Ford Ranger parked elsewhere in Kirrie as he and Dickie made their way to the Hill to meet Mr Donaldson, or that he had used it at Kinnordy.

“You were standing next to Steven Dickie assaulting Steven Donaldson with your axe or machete?” suggested the advocate depute.

“No, incorrect,” replied the accused.

Davidson has told the trial he fled from the nature reserve car park before Dickie beat Mr Donaldson with a baseball bat, but admitted he went back there on his bike to try to find the broken weapon.

“When you went back to the car park did you see Steven Donaldson’s body?” the prosecutor asked.

“The tyres were still burning but there wasn’t enough light to see that,” said Davidson.

Asked about the town centre CCTV footage, he said: “Steven knew I had to get past the cameras so I was to act normal.”

Under re-examination by his defence counsel, advocate Jonathan Crowe, Davidson accepted he and best friend Dickie had been a “team”.

Mr Crowe said: “There comes a point in any team where the rules of the game are gone beyond?”

“That was on the night of the sixth,” Davidson replied.

The trial also heard from 34-year-old Gary Paterson, who said he met Dickie while on remand.

Mr Paterson, who is serving a 30-month sentence, said: “He told me he was in for murder. He said he had stabbed the boy 26 times.

“He said that Callum punched him in a car, he pulled Callum out of the way and Steven had stabbed him 26 times.”

When asked if Dickie had given a reason he said it was “because of his girlfriend being pregnant or something like that.”

The witness added: “Steven Dickie told me that he had offered Callum £10,000 to take the blame.

Mr Paterson said he felt Dickie was “bragging about it” and he told him he was “out of order”.

“Fair enough I’m in for a serious assault, but murdering someone, it’s no nice,” he said.

The trial continues.

Steven Donaldson murder accused admits 2am CCTV 'act' as trial hears friend 'bragged' of stabbing man 26 times - The Courier

Murder...it's no nice.
 
  • #104
Tasmin now on the stand. She wasn't there apparently.
______________

Mr Donaldson, 27, had been offered a new job in Qatar and 20-year-old Glass told the trial they had discussed going there together.

The jury heard there were also difficulties in the relationship, including one row in which Mr Donaldson has slapped her in the face.

She said they had also previously argued about his use of steroids.

“He took them. His moods would change — one minute he would be happy and the next minute he would be in the worst mood ever,” said Glass.

She said the last time she saw Mr Donaldson was April 2018, before he went to Ireland for a motorcycle road race.

She was also asked about repayment of £5,470 from the insurance payout for a written-off car Mr Donaldson had bought her and said she paid him back several sums in cash, including one of £2,000.

There was £1,000 outstanding and the plan had been to use that for a holiday fund for them to go away together.

“He wanted to maintain the relationship. I wanted to maintain the relationship,” she said.

Steven Donaldson murder trial: Tasmin Glass tells jury she discussed moving to Qatar with man she is accused of killing - The Courier
 
  • #105
Tasmin Glass - full of 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬! Absolutely full of it .. I SO hope the jury can see through her doe eyed act!
 
  • #106
Final evidence being heard today before summing up begins.

Urgh, I was wondering how long it would be before she managed to drop "the father of my child" into it for sympathy.


Steven Donaldson murder trial: Tasmin Glass tells court she 'still loved' man she is accused of killing - The Courier

The Steven Donaldson murder trial has heard the alleged victim told accused Tasmin Glass “If I can help you I will”, just weeks before his death.

Day 18 of the trial at the High Court in Edinburgh on Monday heard his pledge came after the then 19-year-old girlfriend, with whom he was trying to get back together, had sent a text saying she had f***** everything up”.

The court heard this was in reference to her falling behind with the rent for her flat in Glasgow, where she moved to in order to cut down on travel for rehearsals with her band.


Tasmin Glass.
The text was one of several jurors were told about during cross-examination by Crown counsel Ashley Edwards.

However, Glass told the court: “I was never with him for his money.”

She also said she would never have allowed Mr Donaldson to travel to Kirriemuir if she believed he was going to come to any harm on the night of the alleged attack last June.

Glass was initially asked by the prosecutor if she was “quite a confident person, someone that deals with stress quite well”.

“No, not at all,” she responded.

Turning to financial matters, Glass was asked if she was in “a little bit of conflict” with her parents about money by the period around April 2018.

She said: “A little bit. I had money troubles, had overspent on a credit card and that led to an argument.

“I know my mum and dad would have helped me. I just didn’t want to disappoint them,” she added.

The court heard Glass had begun seeing murder co-accused Steven Dickie at the beginning of May and Mr Donaldson had sent her a message telling her to transfer money she still owed him, or he would message Glass’s mum directly.

“I told him not to,” the accused said.

She said she still harboured a hope that her relationship with Mr Donaldson would continue.

It was put to her that one of the reasons for this was that money would not become an issue.

“No, not at all,” she said. “If I wanted the money I would have just gone to my mum and dad and they would have just given me it.”

Jurors also heard about another text conversation on May 22 in which Mr Donaldson revealed the “crazy money” he had been offered in a new job, amounting to a package worth around £135,000.

In response to questioning by the advocate depute, Glass repeated her position that she had known nothing about any weapons on the night of June 6.

“If I knew there was any chance of that, I would not let Steven Donaldson come through, especially with him being the father of my child,” she said.

The QC put it to her: “There was a plan for the three of you to act together.”

“No,” Glass replied.

She described June 6 as a “nice night” and said she had just wanted to go swimming with her friends.

“I didn’t want to argue with Steven Donaldson,” she said.

“I think me and Steven would have got back together. I still loved him.”

Asked about her vehicle movements in the minutes after 11pm, she said she had gone into the car park at the Peter Pan playpark and saw a red Ford Fiesta sitting there with a single male driver inside, but no other vehicle.

It was put to Glass that a period of around a minute which she said she spent at the junction on the road leading to the playpark was “a convenient lie” to account for earlier phone and CCTV evidence.

Glass responded: “Steven Donaldson wasn’t there, Callum Davidson wasn’t there and Steven Dickie wasn’t there.”

The advocate depute also asked if she had been in contact with Dickie on
June 7.

She told the trial they had discussed whether she was going to the Angus Show that weekend.

The trial has already been told that two days after the discovery of Mr Donaldson’s body, Glass went to a Marti Pellow concert in Fife with her boss.

When asked how she was, Glass replied: “Upset. I’d put a face on it. I wasn’t going to go crying all night. That wouldn’t have been very good for her birthday night.”

Glass “missed out lots” in statements to police
Tasmin Glass admitted she had been a “coward” on the night of June 6 last year when she failed to tell Steven Donaldson she did not have the £1,000 she was supposed to hand over to him at Kirrie Hill.

Under cross-examination by Dickie’s senior legal counsel, Ian Duguid QC, she also admitted she had “missed out lots” in witness statements given to police before she was charged with murder.

The first was taken on the day her ex’s burned and beaten body was found at the Loch of Kinnordy Nature Reserve.

She agreed she had told police Dickie – with whom she was having a sexual relationship – had been in her car for a river swimming trip to Cortachy that night, when he had in fact been riding his motorbike to and from Kirriemuir.

Turning to details of phone calls made around 11pm that night, Glass agreed she had spoken to Dickie within 53 seconds of stopping a phone call to Mr Donaldson, in which she said their alleged victim had told her she was “taking the ****” because she had not appeared at the Peter Pan playpark as agreed.

Dickie and the third co-accused Callum Davidson have both said they saw Glass and Mr Donaldson’s cars parked side by side there, but that she sped off before Davidson lunged at their alleged victim through his driver’s window.

“You can understand how these events look unfortunate for you?” said Mr Duguid.

Glass replied: “I can see what you’re putting in front of me.”

The QC added: “What do you say to Steven Dickie’s evidence that you phoned his phone and asked to speak to Callum?”

“Absolute rubbish,” replied Glass.

In response to questioning by advocate Jonathan Crowe, for Davidson, Glass accepted neither of her co-accused had known Mr Donaldson prior to June 6 last year.

Asked why she would have phoned Dickie to say Mr Donaldson was not at the car park, she said it was “the right thing to do, to let him know he wasn’t there and I was just going home”.

Mr Crowe put it to her: “You were there and you’re scared to venture there in case it implicates you in the murder of Steven Donaldson?”

“I was not there, Steven Donaldson’s car was not there,” she said.



Police questions led Glass to believe ex’s death was being considered as suicide
Tasmin Glass wept in the dock as she recalled receiving a message from Steven Donaldson’s sister which led her to fear the body found at Loch of Kinnordy Nature Reserve might be that of the boyfriend she had been due to meet the night before.

After going to work as normal in the café and takeaway where she had worked since being a Saturday girl there, the former Webster’s High School pupil also told Court Three of the High Court in Edinburgh that her initial involvement with police led her to suspect they were considering Steven Donaldson may have taken his own life.

Glass said she also became quickly aware of rumours sweeping Kirriemuir which linked her and the two co-accused to the killing, as well as suggestions that her father may have been involved.

She told her defence counsel, Mark Stewart QC, of going to work in Lee’s café in the centre of the Angus town as normal at 8am on the morning of June 7.

As news of the grim find began to sweep the community, Glass went to a police cordon set up on the edge of Kirrie at the road leading to the loch.

It followed a message from the deceased’s sister expressing concern that the family and none of his friends had heard from him and could not reach him on his phone.

“She asked me to ask about the registration of the car,” Glass said.

She said police confirmed a body had been recovered but they could not give her details of the vehicle involved.

“Basically they were putting it to me that it was suicide, the questions they asked me were to do with suicide,” the accused added.

THE CHARGES
Tasmin Glass, 20, Steven Dickie, 24 and Callum Davidson, 24, all from Kirriemuir, face a charge of murdering Mr Donaldson at Loch of Kinnordy between June 6 and 7 2018.

It is alleged they assaulted him at Kirriemuir’s Peter Pan playpark, having arranged to meet him there, repeatedly striking him with weapons before taking him to Loch of Kinnordy, where they repeatedly struck him with a knife and baseball bat or similar and a heavy, bladed weapon and set fire to him and his car.

Dickie and Davidson face a number of other charges including two of threatening men by following them and presenting weapons on dates between 2014 and 2018.

They are also accused of staring at a woman and kicking her car in the town of Kirriemuir between August 1 2017 and April 31 2018.

Davidson faces a further charge of assaulting a man between June 1 2017 and December 31 2017 at a house in Glengate, Kirriemuir.

Dickie is accused of assaulting a woman at the Ogilvy Arms pub in Kirriemuir between February 1 and 28 last year.

Final defence evidence will be led on Tuesday, before summing up in the case gets under way.
 
  • #107
Steven Donaldson murder trial: Lesser charges against Steven Dickie and Callum Davidson are dropped

The jury in the Steven Donaldson trial will consider only the charge of murder.

At the conclusion of Crown and defence evidence on the 19th day of the Edinburgh High Court trial against Steven Dickie, Callum Davidson and Tasmin Glass, Crown prosecutor Ashley Edwards QC indicated she was dropping five charges on the indictment against the two male accused.

An allegation against Dickie and Davidson that they abused a kitten at Lochore in Fife was dropped.

Dickie and Davidson had also faced two charges of threatening men by following them and presenting weapons on dates between 2014 and 2018, and staring at a woman and kicking her car in Kirriemuir between August 2017 and April last year.

Davidson had been accused of assaulting a man at the house in the Angus town’s Glengate, and Dickie of assaulting a woman in the Ogilvy Arms pub between February 1 and 28 last year.

Trial judge Lord Pentland formally acquitted Dickie and Davidson of the five charges.

He told the jury that although the charges against the two men had been withdrawn, the panel of eight women and seven men were entitled to take evidence before them into account in their deliberations on the remaining charge of murder.

All three accused continue to deny murdering 27-year-old oil worker Mr Donaldson on June 6 or 7 last year after attacking him at Kirriemuir’s Peter Pan playpark, and then further attacking him with a baseball bat and knife and a heavy bladed instrument at Loch of Kinnordy, near Kirriemuir and setting fire to him and his car.

The advocate depute will begin her summing up in the case on Tuesday afternoon, followed by submissions by counsel for the three accused.

Following an address by Lord Pentland, the jury will then consider to retire to consider their verdict.
 
  • #108
I do not believe that Tasmin is innocent.

She sounds spoilt, immature and reckless at best and at worst a manipulative 'murderer'.

The details of this case have been horrific! I dread to think what will confess to light after the verdict
 
  • #109
I'm also not too shocked at the other charges being dropped.

They'll be going down anyway for Steven's murder and dropping them leaves less work for the jury. They can focus on justice for Steven.
 
  • #110
I do not believe that Tasmin is innocent.

She sounds spoilt, immature and reckless at best and at worst a manipulative 'murderer'.

The details of this case have been horrific! I dread to think what will confess to light after the verdict

*Come to light*
 
  • #111
Heading to work or heading to a concert a couple days later is not the normal behaviour of someone grieving. Even if she felt nothing towards the victim, I believe if she was genuine that she would be grieving for her unborn child that was now without a father. Carrying on as normal just seems so detached and callous.

Hope the 3 of them go down for a very long time.
 
  • #112
  • #113
The trio accused of the killing of Steven Donaldson were each involved in a “murderous plan” hatched on the evening before the 27-year-old’s body was found charred and beaten at an Angus nature reserve, High Court jurors have been told.

In a two-hour closing speech on the 19th day of the trial of Steven Dickie, Callum Davidson and Tasmin Glass, Crown prosecutor Ashley Edwards QC said all three played their part with “wicked disregard for the consequences “ on the night of June 6 last year.

She said Davidson was not the “simple country lad” he might have the jury believe, and she told them Glass had “facilitated” Mr Donaldson’s arrival at the Peter Pan play park on Kirrie Hill after she used her two co-accused to “stop her web of lies unravelling” around the state of her life at the time.

Parts of the case featured an “obvious flashing red light to signal the guilt of the accused.”

The advocate depute said it also included smaller bits of evidence which drew together to make a “full and complete picture” of all three being responsible for the “brutal” death of the Arbroath oil worker. She urged the jury to reject any submission which may come forward that a charge of culpable homicide should be considered for Glass.

“All three were responsible for the death of Steven Donaldson in the full knowledge that weapons were to be taken to a meeting with him.

“What followed was a brutal and sustained attack by the first and second accused,” added the prosecutor, reminding the jury of evidence indicating Mr Donaldson had been “fighting for his life” at the Kinnordy Loch RSPB reserve where his body was discovered just before 5am on June 7.

She said the other charges, dropped at the conclusion of evidence, showed a “pattern of behaviour of Davidson and Dickie following a course of conduct centred around partners and current and ex-girlfriends of Steven Dickie.”

Glass, she added, knew of the reputation of Dickie and Davidson, the trial having heard how she believed then boyfriend Dickie would “go mental” if he knew Steven Donaldson had called her that night.

She said Glass had wanted to spend the night of June 6 in a different way, with friends and away from the issues that had led to Mr Donaldson contacting her.

“Pregnancy, money, financial pressures, dealing with an ex-partner did not figure,” continued the advocate depute.

“She wanted the compartments of her life to remain separate, and you might think that when the plan was formulated that she was using Steven Dickie and Callum Davidson to that effect, and to stop her web of lies unravelling.

“Her evidence is incredible and unreliable,” said the advocate depute.

Of Davidson, she said: “You might think with his evidence he tried to portray a simple country lad.”

The prosecutor said it was her submission that was not the case, the trial having heard evidence of a web search for a steel machete, and Davidson’s “eye for a business opportunity” after offering to “sort out” someone for £400.

“Piece by piece, the evidence goes towards that final complete picture of the guilt of all three of the crime of murder. Of the murder of Steven Donaldson,” said the advocate depute.

Today will see submissions by counsel for the three accused and, following an address by Lord Pentland, the jury will then retire to consider their verdict.

Steven Donaldson murder trial: 'No scientific or forensic evidence' linking Steven Dickie to crime scene, court told - The Courier
 
  • #114
Tasmin Glass was no “Machiavellian character from the underworld of crime” but a teenager from a good home who was not responsible in “any way, shape or form” for what happened to Steven Donaldson, the Kirriemuir murder trial was told yesterday.

In his closing submission on the 20-year-old’s behalf, senior counsel Mark Stewart QC also asked the jury to reject the notion she was a “gold digger”.

And he told them the death of the Arbroath oil worker had been driven by “the oldest motive in the world – jealousy of a woman”.

Mr Stewart said: “This is a 19-year-old girl with no record of violence or any criminality.

“On what hypothesis do we assume that some like that suddenly becomes involved in an attack like that on her former boyfriend?”

He told the jury they had heard how Steven Dickie, who was in a sexual relationship with Glass, and Callum Donaldson had previously committed acts of violence against people.

“It is not just any people, and that is important in this case,” he said.

“The people they visit violence on are the current boyfriends of their ex-girlfriends, or the ex-boyfriends of their current girlfriends.”

'Gold-digger' theory dismissed by Tasmin Glass QC in closing address - The Courier
 
  • #115
Jurors in the Steven Donaldson murder trial have retired to consider their verdicts.

Following 19 days of evidence during a case which got under way at the High Court in Edinburgh on April 1, the panel of eight women and seven men were sent out by trial judge Lord Pentland shortly after noon on Thursday to begin their deliberations.

Steven Donaldson murder trial: Jurors sent out to consider verdict - The Courier
 
  • #116
I hope the 3 different stories hasn't thrown up too much confusion for the jury.
 
  • #117
I hope the 3 different stories hasn't thrown up too much confusion for the jury.

I can see the two men getting convicted but I’m really unsure of TG. Her lawyers closing was strong with the fact that CD and SD have previous for harassing exes.

Hope they keep in mind that without her there would be no murder and have been able to see through her manipulation.
 
  • #118
The most similar case I can think of was that of Jordan McKay's killers. The female clearly instigated the attack. She was found guilty of culpable homicide only and got 9 years. I don't know if that option is possible here.

Man guilty of murdering joiner
 
  • #119
Think we'll have verdicts before the weekend?
 
  • #120
Think we'll have verdicts before the weekend?

Hope so. For the family’s sake. Otherwise it could be Tuesday with the bank holiday weekend.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
100
Guests online
2,456
Total visitors
2,556

Forum statistics

Threads
633,066
Messages
18,635,849
Members
243,397
Latest member
Gaz00
Back
Top