GUILTY UT - Michele MacNeill, 50, found dead in bathtub, Pleasant Grove, 11 April 2007 - #5

[Coldpizza]

Stopping in to say Hello. I don't think I have posted here since I joined in 6/2011. I hope to post in the current trial threads. Forgive my ignorance if I make a few mistakes along the way.

:welcome: to WS Dovey!!!

 

[Leilei]

Stopping in to say Hello. I don't think I have posted here since I joined in 6/2011. I hope to post in the current trial threads. Forgive my ignorance if I make a few mistakes along the way.

Welcome, Dovey! This is a super interesting trial, and everyone here is pretty darned awesome, in my humble opinion :loveyou:

 

[Hope4More]

Lordy. Its been months since I watched HLN. Half an hour of watching it now, which means 25 minutes if commercials reminds me why I swore never to watch it again. Too much data used to livestream on droid phone tho...

 

[CUCKOOHEAD]

LOL! Settled back in but kitty wants no part of me now. Too bad cuz it's chilly here today and she was keeping me warm. Oh well, still have the M&M's.

That Judge should hear about the distress HE is causing poor sweet meows! Chelly make sure you embellish, I mean add to the story and tell him his shouting caused your precious to leap from your lap into a tub full of water that you were running and your kitty panicked so badly that you were unable to get him out of the tub (you lost eight pints of blood due to the scratching!) and he, he accidently drowned! :tantrum:

 

[mytime]

I went back and listened to it again. I did not hear the words paralegal. I am not sure why I thought I did. My apologies.

 

[Dovey]

I have been reading here on and off for years and I love all the information everyone provides. I think this is a sad case as I do think MM did murder his beautiful wife and left the children motherless. I'm not sure MM will be found guilty but I am hoping.

 

[Leilei]

We're back!

 

[minor4th]

I went back and listened to it again. I did not hear the words paralegal. I am not sure why I thought I did. My apologies.

Ben Winslow tweeted that it was the paralegal

 

[minor4th]

State did say the word "bathtub" was said in the report

 

[Leilei]

That Judge should hear about the distress HE is causing poor sweet meows! Chelly make sure you embellish, I mean add to the story and tell him his shouting caused your precious to leap from your lap into a tub full of water that you were running and your kitty panicked so badly that you were unable to get him out of the tub (you lost eight pints of blood due to the scratching!) and he, he accidently drowned! :tantrum:

(Spencer can help with the embellishing... just sayin')

ddsmiley:

 

[minor4th]

So Spencer wasn't lying. There was nothing in there that would be prejudicial in any way.

 

[Chelly]

That Judge should hear about the distress HE is causing poor sweet meows! Chelly make sure you embellish, I mean add to the story and tell him his shouting caused your precious to leap from your lap into a tub full of water that you were running and your kitty panicked so badly that you were unable to get him out of the tub (you lost eight pints of blood due to the scratching!) and he, he accidently drowned! :tantrum:

Too funny! :floorlaugh:
:loveyou::loveyou::loveyou:

 

[bsk]

State did say the word "bathtub" was said in the report

I was surprised to hear that given the reaction of the gallery.

It didn't go nearly as far as what they played.

 

[minor4th]

No mistrial, carry on ...

 

[Chelly]

State did say the word "bathtub" was said in the report

Ok......I take it back. Spencer was not lying......at least about what he thinks he heard.

 

[minor4th]

I was surprised to hear that given the reaction of the gallery.

It didn't go nearly as far as what they played.

Spencer must have bionic ears

 

[scorekeeper]

judge ruling

they listened to the video

reference to Michele being found in bathtub

and Alexis' testimony

they listened to 30 seconds of tape

think it was only really played 10-15 seconds

judge doesn't think jury heard anything more than 10-15 seconds
or that it got to part about Alexis

Mistrial DENIED

 

[CUCKOOHEAD]

Judge 'Even if the jury was to hear all of that report...

Sounds like the trial will continue.

 

[Softail]

No Mistrial says the judge! :judge:

Carry on!

:gathering:

 

[Dmacky]

So is ♫ Gypsey, Tramps and Thieves next ♫ ♪