GUILTY VA - Helen Hargan, 23, Pamela Hargan, 63, Staged Murder-Suicide, McLean, 14 July 2017 *Guilty again in 2023*







Fairfax County Police
@FairfaxCountyPD


UPDATE: We have arrested 35-year-old Megan Hargan for the murders of her sister Helen Hargan and mother Pamela Hargan in 2017. She was taken into custody this morning in West Virginia. Detectives are currently interviewing her. More details at our 1:30 news conference.


Image


6:13 AM · Nov 9, 2018·

Interesting replies to the tweet...
 

MEGAN ELIZABETH HARGAN​

Custody Record
Age39
GenderFemale
RaceWhite

Date of Birth Jan **, ****
ID Number2089***

Custody Status Date Aug 27, 2019 05:41 PM EDT
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Fairfax County Adult Det Center
Book Date Aug 27, 2019 05:06 PM EDT

 

Jan 10, 2019

[..]

Fresh information about the case was revealed in a recently unsealed search warrant seeking data from Megan Hargan's phone. For the first time, authorities offered a detailed account of the moments leading up to the double slaying and a possible motive in the case.

Despite Helen Hargan's call to her boyfriend, Fairfax police announced in the days that followed the double killing that it appeared the case was a murder-suicide. They said Helen Hargan probably took her mother's life before turning the gun on herself.

It would take a 16-month investigation and the work of a special multi-jurisdictional grand jury before authorities finally pointed to Megan Hargan, 35, as the alleged killer. The grand jury indicted her on two counts of first-degree murder in November. Detectives said it appeared she had staged the home to make the crime look like a murder-suicide.

The unsealed search warrant reveals a possible motive for the crime: Megan Hargan's mother discovered that someone had attempted to wire "large amounts" of money from her bank account on the day before her slaying. Pamela Hargan notified her bank that the transfer was fraudulent.

On the day of the killings, a second transfer was initiated to send money to a title company that was handling the purchase of a home by Megan Hargan in West Virginia. Detectives wrote in the search warrant that she initially lied about attempting the transfers before admitting in an interview that she was behind them.


Tammy North said her sister Pamela had recently bought Helen a home.

Detectives also wrote in the search warrant that Megan Hargan was given a polygraph about a week after the killings in which she was asked whether she was involved. The test indicated that she was being deceptive when she denied involvement, the warrant said.

Hargan was arrested in Morgantown, W.Va., shortly after the indictments were issued in November and extradited to Fairfax County, where she is being held without bail.

The Fairfax County public defenders who are representing Hargan declined to comment. County prosecutors declined to comment because the case is pending.

North said the killings were a blow to the family, especially because a cloud hung over her younger niece for over a year after authorities initially named her as the perpetrator.

"Helen was very intelligent, hard working, beautiful inside and out," North wrote in a Facebook message to The Washington Post. "She was truly innocent in this and didn't deserve to be labeled as a murderer."

North said Helen Hargan graduated from Southern Methodist University in Dallas in 2015 with a double major that was engineering-related. North said her niece loved riding horses and traveling, and had spent six weeks with a host family in the Australian Outback when she was 16. North said she had a promising life ahead of her.

[..]

Maj. Ed O'Carroll of the Fairfax County police said in an interview last month that authorities were premature to label the case a murder-suicide but did not publicly correct the record because it allowed them to investigate the killings without raising Megan Hagan's suspicions that she was a target of the probe.

Megan Hargan is scheduled to stand trial in September. If convicted, she could face up to life in prison.
 

March 6, 2022

Megan Hargan is slated to stand trial Monday on two counts of first-degree murder in a case that captured widespread local attention and could last as long as six weeks. Fairfax County Police Major Ed O'Carroll summed up authorities view of events succinctly in 2018.

"This is a tragedy — domestic violence at its worst," O'Carroll said.

Hargan maintains her innocence and is pleading not guilty to all charges.

The public defenders representing Hargan declined to comment or discuss her defense, but in a filing her attorneys assert that time-stamped video evidence shows Megan Hargan's car leaving her mother's home possibly before the second killing.

[..]

The incident played out in 2017 on July 13 and 14, with part of it captured in a series of chilling phone calls between Helen Hargan and her boyfriend.

Evidence indicates Megan Hargan called one of her mother's banks impersonating her and requested nearly $420,000 be transferred from her mother's account to a title company handling the closing of Megan's new home on July 13, according to a prosecution filing in the case.

The bank alerted Pamela Hargan, who put a freeze on the transfer, the filing states.

About 11:30 a.m. the next day, Helen Hargan's boyfriend told authorities she called him sobbing hysterically, prosecutors wrote.

Helen told her boyfriend that Megan had come into her room and told her "she just shot her mother," according to the filing. "Megan is downstairs somewhere on the computer transferring funds," Helen told her boyfriend, the filing states.

Helen's boyfriend then asked her why Megan shot the sisters' mother. Helen replied that Megan told her "she got caught doing an escort service deal" and Pamela Hargan was going to take away Megan's then 8-year-old daughter who also lived with them, according to the prosecution filing.

The boyfriend urged Helen to get Megan's daughter out of the home and call police, but Helen kept stammering, "I can't believe this," prosecutors wrote.

A short time later, Megan Hargan transferred nearly $420,000 from another bank account of her mother's to the title company handling the closing for her home, prosecutors said in the filing.

The frantic phone calls between Helen and her boyfriend continued over the next hour.

The video evidence highlighted by the defense shows Megan Hargan's car leaving the home at 12:58 p.m., according to a defense filing. The boyfriend received texts from Helen's phone after that, but prosecutors wrote in their filing they believe Megan Hargan sent the messages. The defense disputes that.
 

Megan Hargan was found guilty in March on all counts, including first-degree murder, in the shooting deaths of her mother, 63-year-old business executive Pamela Hargan, and her sister, 23-year-old Helen Hargan. Prosecutors said Megan Hargan staged the crime scene as a murder-suicide committed by Helen Hargan.

Hargan's attorneys argued a juror told a defense team investigator that she used her rifle at home to try to determine if it would have been physically possible for the younger sister to shoot herself.
 

In March of this year, Megan Hargan was found guilty on all four charges by jurors in Fairfax County, Va.

But at least one of those jurors appears to have inappropriately taken the case into their own hands while away from the confines of the courthouse. According to the defense filing obtained by the Washington Post, the juror in question used her own rifle at home in order to test out some of the evidence submitted at trial.

Specifically, the defense stuck by the narrative that the bloody scene at the McLean, Va. home once shared by the three Hargan women was the result of a murder-suicide committed by the youngest.

An affidavit signed by a defense investigator says the juror “stated that she was unable to figure out a way that the sister [Helen Hargan] could have committed suicide” with a .22 caliber rifle – because of how long that particular gun is – and how much it weighs. In order to essay the defense’s theory, the juror allegedly told the investigator, she used her own rifle to gauge the plausibility of that claim and then shared the results of her experiment with the rest of the jury.

“Clearly, a juror may not properly receive any information about a case he is hearing except in open court and in the manner provided by law,” Senior Assistant Public Defender Bryan T. Kennedy wrote.
 
This is horrible. What an idiot juror. Now this family has to suffer through this all over again.
“Someone put the gun to the top of her head and pulled the trigger, and it went straight down to her neck. That’s how you get a wound like that,” the prosecutor said.

Megan Hargan’s defense attorneys told jurors that Helen put the gun to her own head and
fired using her toes. She wore a sock to avoid leaving evidence on the trigger, they said.

The defense's theory alone was enough to demonstrate not even a contortionist could accomplish this via a gloved (sock) foot! I don't know why the juror thought it was her place to attempt to reenact this and share her results. Guess she didn't listen to the judge. MOO

 
Last edited:
At least MH still appears to be in custody and was not released pending the retrial.

MEGAN ELIZABETH HARGAN​

Custody Record
Age40
GenderFemale
RaceWhite

Date of Birth Jan **, ****
ID Number2089***
Custody Status Date Aug 27, 2019 05:41 PM EDT
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Fairfax County Adult Det Center
Book Date Aug 27, 2019 05:06 PM EDT

LOCATION
Fairfax County Adult Det Center

 

11/10/22

Sentencing was set for Nov. 18, [2022] but officials say it does not appear that will happen.

Fairfax County Commonwealth’s Attorney Steve Descano released this statement on the situation:

"We are disappointed that a juror’s inappropriate actions led to this double murder conviction being vacated. We are still committed to getting justice for the victims of this crime. My office will move forward and prepare for the new trial."
 
On Nov. 9, 2022, a judge overturned Megan Hargan's double murder conviction, citing juror misconduct. The ruling came after a juror tried to re-enact Helen Hargan's shooting using a rifle, and during deliberations told other jurors that the defense's theory of the case was not possible. Hargan's retrial is scheduled for Sept. 5, 2023.

RETRIAL DATE
 
I can’t believe she’s getting another trial. She’s absolutely guilty of killing her mother and sister.
 
I can’t believe she’s getting another trial. She’s absolutely guilty of killing her mother and sister.

I just saw this on 48 hours- absolutely stunned that her case was overturned- yeah, I believe she did it: now they have to try her again.

It's not a question of guilt as the jury convicted MH of double homicide. The new trial is due to juror misconduct.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
196
Guests online
527
Total visitors
723

Forum statistics

Threads
625,593
Messages
18,506,777
Members
240,819
Latest member
Berloni75
Back
Top