Who Had Motive, Method & Opportunity?!

[screecher]

If Jonah's two older children were present when the accident occurred, wouldn't the Zahau's be aware of this as XZ was there and I find it hard to believe that she would have withheld that information from her family for so long. Also, Jonah reportedly drove his two older kids to the airport early that morning and there would likely be evidence to confirm that.

I guess my question about your theory would be, if the two older children were present, why would XZ not have told her family by now? And if she did tell them, why haven't they gone public with this as it would likely help them have a better chance of getting the investigation into RZ's death reopened? I'm not trying to be disrespectful with these questions just wondering what your thoughts on those two issues are.

Not only if there no evidence to confirm Max's older half siblings flew out early that morning, it is my understanding there IS evidence they didn't fly out until early after noon.

So there you go.

 

[Morag]

Not only if there no evidence to confirm Max's older half siblings flew out early that morning, it is my understanding there IS evidence they didn't fly out until early after noon.

So there you go.

Can this be why Dina thinks that DHS has some information to offer? Or am I confusing the TSA with the DHS?

 

[screecher]

Can this be why Dina thinks that DHS has some information to offer? Or am I confusing the TSA with the DHS?

You are not confusing anything.

LOL. DHS and TSA are not tracking two bratty teenagers of one very wealthy parent to another very parent.

Dina, imo, is at best, irrational in her thinking. And it didn't begin with her split with JS.

 

[screecher]

Besides, they ain't 'teenaged murderers on a spree', right?

 

[Mollyandme]

Not only if there no evidence to confirm Max's older half siblings flew out early that morning, it is my understanding there IS evidence they didn't fly out until early after noon.

So there you go.

where is the evidence that they didn't fly out until early afternoon?

 

[screecher]

Well, I guess you ain't read all the threads, therefore, nor as informed as you may think you are.

The info IS some where in these threads. Been stated many times.

 

[screecher]

Where is evidence the bratty kids flew out in the very morning?

 

[Jessica2012]

As Molly and Me wrote, wouldn't XZ have said something by now if the other kids were present? Wouldn't Mary would also have looked into that as a possibility to clear her sister's name?

 

[screecher]

XZ is a kid, I'm thinking she is very much supported by her loved ones AND is following advise from others.

XZ is not on trial here.

Dina Romano, Nina Romano and Adam Shacknai are..

 

[screecher]

Jessica, just why would RZ's sister need to "clear" her sister's name?

 

[screecher]

Let's not forget, this thread is who had MOTIVE, METHOD and OPPORTUNITY to MURDER Rebecca Zahau.

Seems to me, a very few are suggesting Dina Romano is/was justified in murdering RZ, because she was there in the residence.

Not doing the mother any favors by inferring he died at her hands, or even her negligence.

Just saying.

 

[screecher]

Just goes to MOTIVE.

 

[Jessica2012]

Sreecher, hi I am absolutely not blaming XZ. I know she has been through enough. Nor am i saying this case against DS, Nina, and Adam is about her. My response was to the question posed what is the proof that the Shacknai kids flew out in the morning? Those kids are not on trial here either right? I'm saying, if you guys believe that the Shacknai kids had something to do with Maxie's death, and it was covered up as written, why wouldnt XZ have said something by now? Why wouldn't Mary look into that to clear her sister's name (I meant Rebecca not XZ) from being blamed for the accident? Screecher, do you think my post was inferring that he died at her hands? Please re read my post, I am not saying that at all. I will state again, Rebecca did not deserve to die. It has been many years, there are alot of things I agree with you guys wholeheartedly about but even when I do agree, or ask a question everyone gets so defensive. I'm not attacking anyone And I have no cryptic meanings behind my messages. If it is proven murder, that person deserves to be punished to the maximum. And if it was suicide, and someone bullied her into committing suicide that person also should pay the consequences.

 

[*Lash*]

As Molly and Me wrote, wouldn't XZ have said something by now if the other kids were present? Wouldn't Mary would also have looked into that as a possibility to clear her sister's name?

Hi Jessica :wave:

Respectfully-- We don't know what XZ has said or not said. I agree with Screecher, XZ is a minor and is being protected by her loved ones, following their advice. Imo, there is a time and place this particular info should be made public. Not meant to be tit for tat, but can't the same thing be said about the Shacknai children? Why hasn't their mother or father produced evidence showing when their flight left that day, when they left the mansion? Prove the allegation wrong? Again, imo, they are kids, just like XZ. They are being protected by their loved ones.

 

[Mollyandme]

Let's not forget, this thread is who had MOTIVE, METHOD and OPPORTUNITY to MURDER Rebecca Zahau.

Seems to me, a very few are suggesting Dina Romano is/was justified in murdering RZ, because she was there in the residence.

Not doing the mother any favors by inferring he died at her hands, or even her negligence.

Just saying.

I don't think there's anything that could justify Dina killing RZ, and if she did, she should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. I don't think RZ was murdered and I think Max's death was an accident but that's just my personal opinion.

With that being said, I started reading this thread about who would have the motive, method, and opportunity to murder Rebecca because I was interested in seeing if there was anything that might change my personal opinion. That's why I asked about the time of the airplane flight and if there was evidence that the two older kids did fly out later than Jonah stated, because in my opinion, if he lied about that then there is a reason and that reason would be important to the case.

 

[Jessica2012]

Hi Jessica :wave:

Respectfully-- We don't know what XZ has said or not said. I agree with Screecher, XZ is a minor and is being protected by her loved ones, following their advice. Imo, there is a time and place this particular info should be made public. Not meant to be tit for tat, but can't the same thing be said about the Shacknai children? Why hasn't their mother or father produced evidence showing when their flight left that day, when they left the mansion? Prove the allegation wrong? Again, imo, they are kids, just like XZ. They are being protected by their loved ones.

Hi Lash I completely agree with you and Screecher. I think that none of us know exactly what has or has not been produced and children are and should be protected by their loved ones. Where my opinion differs is I don't believe the Shacknai kids were there that morning because it would have come out by now. Maybe their father/mother has produced that evidence and we just don't know about it. I agree that there is a time and place that information should be made public especially when kids are involved. I never take your posts to me as "tit for tat"-your posts always make me understand your point of view better and are worded in a way that is respectful towards everyone.

 

[Frigga]

As Molly and Me wrote, wouldn't XZ have said something by now if the other kids were present? Wouldn't Mary would also have looked into that as a possibility to clear her sister's name?

How do any of us know she didn't tell her family? How does Rebecca's name need to be cleared and for what exactly? That is the motive- right there... the Rebecca killed Max motive of DS. She had the opportunity as well- this many years later and she still has not proven her alibi.

Why?

Because she doesn't have one there is no other reasonable explanation.

 

[Frigga]

where is the evidence that they didn't fly out until early afternoon?

Where is the evidence they did? I'm not talking hearsay- I'm talking tangible proof they did?

 

[K_Z]

Is it true that JS is not being called as a witness for either side?

Where did you hear that?

Seems entirely logical he would be called as a witness-- doesn't matter which side officially "calls" him, IMO.

 

[Jessica2012]

Where did you hear that?

Seems entirely logical he would be called as a witness-- doesn't matter which side officially "calls" him, IMO.

Hi KZ I read it here. Post #336. You are right it does not make sense to me if he is not.