WI - Erik Metzig charged with murdering parents David and Jan Metzig - 3/24/23

I saw this case when I had just been looking up the peculiar phenomenon of young men murdering their parents and sometimes a sibling as well. I looked up EM's age, and sure enough, he's 25.

Within just an hour before seeing this Metzig thread, I had been researching why young men are committing parricide.

This is from the local Green Bay paper. It has some videos.


These are the two other cases I've followed recently:

#1 Convicted Florida, no parole, Grant Amato

#2 Convicted Wisconsin, no parole, Chandler Halderson

Yep, Wisconsin. And the Halderson case was not only spellbinding, but exemplary for a court case. Wisconsin has every which kind of forensic specialist, and they are all really good at their jobs! The whole trial is worth watching for all the forensics, but also the thoughtfulness of the judge and the preparation of the prosecution. Brilliant all around. We also have recorded interviews of Chandler and his girlfriend. We even have tapes of their rides in (separate) patrol cars to "downtown". His girlfriend was in no way responsible for the murder, just so it's clear.
Here is the Halderson case; definitely worth a watch while waiting for the Metzig case to evolve. All you need is the prosecutor's opening to get a clue, but the whole trial is on the Law and Crime network on YouTube:

Do you have any new insights into why young men are killing parents and families?
 
Unbelievable. This family living the American dream- third generation Metzig to own and operate a cheese company. Their son Erik pleads no contest to murder of his parents.



10/30/2024
 
Court activities
Date Time Location Description Type Court official
02-10-2025 09:00 am Branch 4, 2nd Floor, Room 211 Status hearing Court Gibbs, Michael


Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
11-21-2024 Order Gibbs, Michael
Additional text:
Order Regarding Investment Account (routed to MLS)

11-20-2024 Proposed Order
11-20-2024 Video conferencing
11-20-2024 Status hearing Gibbs, Michael Hunt, Erin
Additional text:
1:17pm Defendant ERIK TYRRELL METZIG appeared by video, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan appeared by video for ERIK TYRRELL METZIG. Prosecuting attorney Adam Joseph Levin in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. Victim's family in courtroom and by zoom. Atty. Hogan updates court--received file from previous counsel and needs to review. State indicates defendant has not had contact with with investigators regarding defendant being victim of crime. State request sentencing date. Court sets status hearing. Regarding defendant's investment account. Defendant does have account. State request funds be turned over to the court. No objection by defense. Court finds under 814.29(2) that defendant claim of poverty was untrue. Court orders funds from account be deposited to the COC for reimbursement of attorney fees and other expenses for this case--any balance to be returned. Atty. Hogan to prepare order. Bond continues
Status hearing scheduled for February 10, 2025 at 09:00 am.

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 
Just a docket update.

Court activities
Date Time Location Description Type Court official
02-10-2025 09:00 am Branch 4, 2nd Floor, Room 211 Status hearing Court Gibbs, Michael


Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
02-06-2025 Motion
Additional text:
Defendant's Motion to Withdraw No Contest Pleas

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 
Monday, February 10th:
*Status Hearing (@ 9am CT) – WI - David (72) & Kathryn Jeanne “Jan” (Mosson) (71) Metzig fatally shot by their son, Mar. 18, 2023, Wolf River. - *Erik Tyrrell Metzig (25/now 27) arrested & charged (3/21/23) & arraigned (4/17/23) with 2 counts of 1st degree intentional homicide. Plead not guilty by reason of mental disease/defect. $1M Cash bond. Winnebago County
Trial was set to begin on 10/14/24 but was vacated with a guilty plea [on 8/26/24]. [Now on 2/6/25 wants to withdraw no contest plea].
Judge Michael Gibbs presiding. DA Adam Joseph Levin. Defense attorney Timothy Edward Hogan.

Case & court info from 3/18/23 thru 10/31/24 reference post #39 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ts-david-and-jan-metzig-3-24-23.671487/page-2

11/12/24 Docket update: Notice of status hearing 11/20/24 @ 1:15pm. 11/15/24 Docket update: Transcript of proceedings (plea hearing) held before Judge Gibbs on 8/26/24-e. Hunt court reporter.
11/20/24 Update: Status hearing held with Judge Michael Gibbs presiding. Metzig appeared by video, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan appeared by video for Metzig. Prosecuting attorney Adam Joseph Levin in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. Victim's family in courtroom & by zoom. Attorney Hogan updates court--received file from previous counsel & needs to review. State indicates defendant has not had contact with investigators regarding defendant being victim of crime. State request sentencing date. Court sets status hearing on 2/10/25 @ 9am. Regarding defendant's investment account. Defendant does have account. State request funds to be turned over to the court. No objection by defense. Court finds under 814.29(2) that defendant claim of poverty was untrue. Court orders funds from account to be deposited to the COC for reimbursement of attorney fees & other expenses for this case--any balance to be returned. Attorney Hogan to prepare order. Bond continues. 11/21/24 Docket update: Order regarding investment account (routed to MLS). Scott Ceman replaced attorney Tim Hogan as defense attorney. But Ceman filed a second motion requesting permission to withdraw from his role as Metzig's lawyer due to a conflict of interest. Withdrawn on 10/30/24.
2/6/25 Docket update: Defendant's Motion to Withdraw No Contest Pleas.
 
Court activities
Date Time Location Description Type Court official
03-19-2025 08:30 am Branch 4, 2nd Floor, Room 211 Motion hearing Court Gibbs, Michael


Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
02-10-2025 Status hearing Gibbs, Michael Hunt, Erin
Additional text:
9:13am Defendant ERIK TYRRELL METZIG in court, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan in court for ERIK TYRRELL METZIG. Prosecuting attorney Amanda Lynn Folger in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. The Court notes there is no victim present that wishes to make a statement. Victim's family in courtroom and by zoom. Defense motion to withdraw plea. State objects and requests 2 weeks to file response and not requesting evidentiary hearing. Bond continues
Motion hearing scheduled for March 19, 2025 at 08:30 am.

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 
Wednesday, March 19th:
*Motion Hearing (@ 8:30am CT) – WI - David (72) & Kathryn Jeanne “Jan” (Mosson) (71) Metzig fatally shot by their son, Mar. 18, 2023, Wolf River. - *Erik Tyrrell Metzig (25/now 27) arrested & charged (3/21/23) & arraigned (4/17/23) with 2 counts of 1st degree intentional homicide. Plead not guilty by reason of mental disease/defect. $1M Cash bond. Winnebago County
Trial was set to begin on 10/14/24 but was vacated with a guilty plea [on 8/26/24]. [Now on 2/6/25 wants to withdraw no contest plea].
Judge Michael Gibbs presiding. DA Adam Joseph Levin. Defense attorney Timothy Edward Hogan.

Case & court info from 3/18/23 thru 11/15/24 reference post #49 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ts-david-and-jan-metzig-3-24-23.671487/page-3

11/20/24 Update: Status hearing held with Judge Michael Gibbs presiding. Metzig appeared by video, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan appeared by video for Metzig. Prosecuting attorney Adam Joseph Levin in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. Victim's family in courtroom & by zoom. Attorney Hogan updates court--received file from previous counsel & needs to review. State indicates defendant has not had contact with investigators regarding defendant being victim of crime. State request sentencing date. Court sets status hearing on 2/10/25 @ 9am. Regarding defendant's investment account. Defendant does have account. State request funds to be turned over to the court. No objection by defense. Court finds under 814.29(2) that defendant claim of poverty was untrue. Court orders funds from account to be deposited to the COC for reimbursement of attorney fees & other expenses for this case--any balance to be returned. Attorney Hogan to prepare order. Bond continues. 11/21/24 Docket update: Order regarding investment account (routed to MLS). Scott Ceman replaced attorney Tim Hogan as defense attorney. But Ceman filed a second motion requesting permission to withdraw from his role as Metzig's lawyer due to a conflict of interest. Withdrawn on 10/30/24.
2/6/25 Docket update: Defendant's Motion to Withdraw No Contest Pleas. 2/10/25 Update: Status hearing held before Judge Michael Gibbs. Defendant Metzig in court, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan in court for Metzig. Prosecuting attorney Amanda Lynn Folger in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. The Court notes there is no victim present that wishes to make a statement. Victim's family in courtroom & by zoom. Defense motion to withdraw plea. State objects & requests 2 weeks to file response & not requesting evidentiary hearing. Bond continues. Motion hearing scheduled for 3/19/25 @ 8:30am.
 
Court activities
Date Time Location Description Type Court official
05-29-2025 09:00 am Branch 4, 2nd Floor, Room 211 Status hearing Court Gibbs, Michael


Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
03-19-2025 Order appointing counsel Gibbs, Michael
Additional text:
Order Appointing Counsel--Atty. Aaron Schenk

03-19-2025 Invoice/Statement
Additional text:
Court appointed attorney invoice--Atty. Hogan (sent to MLS--use funds from defendant's investment account)

03-19-2025 Order Gibbs, Michael
Additional text:
Order for Withdrawal of Counsel--Atty. Hogan

03-19-2025 Notice of hearing
Additional text:
Status hearing on May 29, 2025 at 09:00 am.

03-19-2025 Motion hearing Gibbs, Michael Hunt, Erin
Additional text:
8:34am Defendant ERIK TYRRELL METZIG in court, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan in court for ERIK TYRRELL METZIG. Prosecuting attorney Amanda Lynn Folger in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. Victim's family in courtroom and by zoom. Defense motion for withdrawal of counsel--Atty. Hogan now has conflict on case. State takes no position. Court grants motion to withdraw. Court appoints Atty. Aaron Schenk. Bond continues
Status hearing scheduled for May 29, 2025 at 09:00 am.

03-06-2025 Motion to withdraw as counsel

03-04-2025 Response/reply
Additional text:
State's Response to Defendant's Motion to Withdraw Pleas
Appendix A part 1.
Appendix A part 2.
Appendix B.
Appendix C.

02-14-2025 Other papers
Additional text:
Defendant's writings from Dr. Lundbohm regarding 2-5-24 Order

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 
Thursday, May 29th:
*Status Hearing (@ 9am CT) – WI - David (72) & Kathryn Jeanne “Jan” (Mosson) (71) Metzig fatally shot by their son, Mar. 18, 2023, Wolf River. - *Erik Tyrrell Metzig (25/now 28) arrested & charged (3/21/23) & arraigned (4/17/23) with 2 counts of 1st degree intentional homicide. Plead not guilty by reason of mental disease/defect. $1M Cash bond. Winnebago County
Trial was set to begin on 10/14/24 but was vacated with a guilty plea [on 8/26/24]. [Now on 2/6/25 wants to withdraw no contest plea].
Judge Michael Gibbs presiding. DA Adam Joseph Levin. Defense attorney Timothy Edward Hogan [withdrew as counsel] now has Aaron Schenk.

Case & court info from 3/18/23 thru 11/15/24 reference post #49 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ts-david-and-jan-metzig-3-24-23.671487/page-3

11/20/24 Update: Status hearing held with Judge Michael Gibbs presiding. Metzig appeared by video, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan appeared by video for Metzig. Prosecuting attorney Adam Joseph Levin in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. Victim's family in courtroom & by zoom. Attorney Hogan updates court--received file from previous counsel & needs to review. State indicates defendant has not had contact with investigators regarding defendant being victim of crime. State request sentencing date. Court sets status hearing on 2/10/25 @ 9am. Regarding defendant's investment account. Defendant does have account. State request funds to be turned over to the court. No objection by defense. Court finds under 814.29(2) that defendant claim of poverty was untrue. Court orders funds from account to be deposited to the COC for reimbursement of attorney fees & other expenses for this case--any balance to be returned. Attorney Hogan to prepare order. Bond continues. 11/21/24 Docket update: Order regarding investment account (routed to MLS). Scott Ceman replaced attorney Tim Hogan as defense attorney. But Ceman filed a second motion requesting permission to withdraw from his role as Metzig's lawyer due to a conflict of interest. Withdrawn on 10/30/24.
2/6/25 Docket update: Defendant's Motion to Withdraw No Contest Pleas. 2/10/25 Update: Status hearing held before Judge Michael Gibbs. Defendant Metzig in court, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan in court for Metzig. Prosecuting attorney Amanda Lynn Folger in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. The Court notes there is no victim present that wishes to make a statement. Victim's family in courtroom & by zoom. Defense motion to withdraw plea. State objects & requests 2 weeks to file response & not requesting evidentiary hearing. Bond continues. Motion hearing scheduled for 3/19/25 @ 8:30am. 2/14/25 Docket update: Defendant's writings from Dr. Lundbohm regarding 2/5/24 Order. 3/4/25 Docket update: State's Response to Defendant's Motion to Withdraw Pleas. Appendix A part 1, Appendix A part 2, Appendix B & Appendix C. 3/6/25 Docket update: Motion to withdraw as counsel.
3/19/25 Update: Motion hearing with Judge Michael Gibbs presiding. Defendant Metzig in court, in custody. Attorney Timothy Edward Hogan in court for Metzig. Prosecuting attorney Amanda Lynn Folger in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. Victim's family in courtroom & by zoom. Defense motion for withdrawal of counsel--Attorney Hogan now has conflict on case. State takes no position. Court grants motion to withdraw. Court appoints Attorney Aaron Schenk. Bond continues. Next status hearing scheduled for 5/29/25 @ 9am. Order for withdrawal of Counsel for attorney Hogan-granted. Court appointed attorney invoice for Hogan. Order appointing Counsel attorney Aaron Schenk.
5
/20/25 Docket update: Demand for Discovery by defendant.
 
Court activities
Date Time Location Description Type Court official
07-31-2025 01:30 pm Branch 4, 2nd Floor, Room 211 Motion hearing Court Gibbs, Michael

Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
05-29-2025 Notice of hearing
Additional text:
Motion hearing on July 31, 2025 at 01:30 pm.

05-29-2025 Status hearing Gibbs, Michael Hunt, Erin
Additional text:
9:02am Defendant ERIK TYRRELL METZIG in court, in custody. Attorney Aaron Walter Schenk in court for ERIK TYRRELL METZIG. Prosecuting attorney Amanda Lynn Folger in court for the State of Wisconsin. Court is in compliance with Marsy's Law/Victim Rights. Victim's family in the courtroom and by zoom. Defense ready to proceed with scheduling motion to withdraw plea and will rely on briefs submitted. Bond continues
Motion hearing scheduled for July 31, 2025 at 01:30 pm.

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
69
Guests online
447
Total visitors
516

Forum statistics

Threads
626,109
Messages
18,520,639
Members
240,941
Latest member
sesnse
Back
Top