GUILTY WI - Michael Meager, 8 of La Grange, IL Killed by Stepfather, Steven D. Merkel Jr., in Lake Geneva 20 January 2025

  • #21
Just a docket update

Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
08-11-2025 Demand for Discovery and Inspection - Defendant

08-11-2025 Stipulation
Additional text:
to Substitute Counsel

08-11-2025 Public defender order appointing counsel
Additional text:
Attorney Tyler Jochman

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 
  • #22
Wednesday, August 27th:
*Plea Hearing (@ 1:15pm ET) - WI - Michael Meagher (8) shot by stepfather on Jan. 20, 2025 in Lake Geneva. *Steven D. Merkel, Jr. (52/now 53) arrested (1/20/25) & charged (1/21/25) with 1st degree reckless homicide & use of a dangerous weapon. Held in Walworth County jail. Cash bond $250K. Walworth County
Judge Kristine E. Drettwan assisgned judge. Judge David M. Reddy presided over initial appearances. Prosecutor Attorney Zeke S. Wiedenfeld. Defense attorneys Joshua Ryan-Polczinski & Makenzie Renner, public defenders.
Case info from 1/20/25 thru 6/17/25 reference post #19 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...kel-jr-in-lake-geneva-20-january-2025.735356/

7/1/25 Docket update: Notice of competency hearing from 7/8/25 to 7/29/25 @ 8:30am. 7/3/25 Docket update: Letters/correspondence from Brooke Lundbohm re extension. 7/18/25 Docket update: Competency report filed.
7/29/25 Update: Competency hearing held. Attorney Zeke S Wiedenfeld in court for State of Wisconsin. Defendant Merkel in court, in custody appearing via video from Walworth County Jail. Attorney Mackenzie Renner & attorney Joshua Ryan-Polczinski in court for Merkel. Court inquired if victim wished to be heard; no statement made. Defense is in agreement with competency report. Defendant is in agreement with competency report. State is in agreement with competency report. Attorney Ryan asked for a Plea hearing. Plea hearing scheduled for 8/27/25 @ 1:15pm.
8/11/25 Docket updates: Public defender order appointing counsel attorney Tyler Jochman. Stipulation to substitute Counsel. Demand for discovery & inspection by defendant.
 
  • #23
Court activities
Date Time Location Description Type Court official
11-20-2025 09:00 am Walworth County Judicial Center - Room 3045 Sentencing hearing Court Drettwan, Kristine E.


Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
08-27-2025 Other papers
Additional text:
Temporary Commitment

08-27-2025 Plea hearing Drettwan, Kristine E. Vorpahl, Jennifer
Additional text:
Defendant Steven D Merkel in court, in custody. Attorney Joshua Ryan-Polczinski in court for Steven D Merkel. Attorney Sempf in court for State of Wisconsin.
Court inquires if any victims present, victim present.
Defendant argues he is competent to proceed.
Attorney Ryan states discovery has been reviewed.
Plea questionnaire/waiver of rights filed.
Court has colloquy with defendant; pleads guilty to Count #1
Court gives WARNINGS regarding deportation, felon prohibited from firearm possession pursuant to Sec. 941.29, ineligibility to vote until civil rights restored
Plea is freely, knowingly, voluntarily made.
Court finds factual basis, accepts plea and adjudges defendant guilty on Count #1
PSI Ordered .
BOND REVOKED PENDING SENTENCING
Sentencing hearing scheduled for November 20, 2025 at 09:00 am.

08-27-2025 Plea questionnaire, waiver of rights
Additional text:
with Agreement

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 
  • #24
Docket updates:

Court activities
Date Time Location Description Type Court official
11-20-2025 09:00 am Walworth County Judicial Center - Room 3045 Sentencing hearing Court Drettwan, Kristine E.

Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
11-19-2025 Jury instructions
11-18-2025 Memorandum
Additional text:
Deft Sentencing Memo

11-18-2025 Victim impact statement
11-18-2025 Victim impact statement
11-18-2025 Victim impact statement
11-06-2025 Pre-sentence investigation filed

09-16-2025 Stipulation
Additional text:
and Consent to Substitute Counsel

09-16-2025 Demand for Discovery and Inspection - Defendant
09-16-2025 Public defender order appointing counsel
Additional text:
Attorney Tyler Jochman

09-02-2025 Order for pre-sentence investigation Drettwan, Kristine E.

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 
  • #25
Thursday, Nov. 20th:
*Sentencing Hearing (@ 9am ET) - WI - Michael Meagher (8) shot by stepfather on Jan. 20, 2025 in Lake Geneva. *Steven D. Merkel, Jr. (52/now 53) arrested (1/20/25) & charged (1/21/25) with 1st degree reckless homicide & use of a dangerous weapon. Held in Walworth County jail. Cash bond $250K. Bond revoked after pleading guilty (8/27/25). Walworth County
Judge Kristine E. Drettwan assisgned judge. Judge David M. Reddy presided over initial appearances. Prosecutor Attorney Zeke S. Wiedenfeld. Defense attorneys Joshua Ryan-Polczinski & Makenzie Renner, public defenders.
Case info from 1/20/25 thru 7/29/25 reference post #22 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-in-lake-geneva-20-january-2025.735356/page-2

8/11/25 Docket updates: Public defender order appointing counsel attorney Tyler Jochman. Stipulation to substitute Counsel. Demand for discovery & inspection by defendant. Plea hearing on 8/27/25.
8/27/25 Update: Plea hearing with Judge Kirstine E. Drettwan presiding. Defendant Merkel in court, in custody. Attorney Joshua Ryan-Polczinski in court for Merkel. Attorney Sempf in court for State of Wisconsin. Court inquires if any victims present, victim present. Defendant argues he is competent to proceed. Attorney Ryan states discovery has been reviewed. Plea questionnaire/waiver of rights filed. Court has colloquy with defendant; plead guilty to Count #1. Court gives WARNINGS regarding deportation, felon prohibited from firearm possession pursuant to Sec. 941.29, ineligibility to vote until civil rights restored. Plea is freely, knowingly, voluntarily made. Court finds factual basis, accepts plea & adjudges defendant guilty on Count #1. PSI Ordered. Bond revoked pending sentencing. Sentencing hearing scheduled on 11/20/25 @ 9am. Plea questionnaire, waiver of rights with Agreement. Other papers-Temporary commitment.
9/2/25 Docket update: Order for pre-sentence investigation filed by Kristine E. Drettwan. 9/16/25 Docket update: Public defender Order appointing counsel-attorney Tyler Jochman. Demand for Discovery & inspection by defendant. Stipulation & consent to substitute counsel.
11/6/25 Docket update: Pre-sentence investigation filed. 11/18/25 Docket updates: Victim impact statements (3). Defendant's sentencing memo. 11/19/25 Docket update: Jury instructions filed.
 
  • #26
Not too sure what "IC" or "ES" stands for in the Sentencing line....

Charges
Count no. Statute Description Severity Disposition
1 940.02(1) 1st-Degree Reckless Homicide Felony B Guilty Due to Guilty Plea
Modifier: 939.63(1)(b) Use of a Dangerous Weapon

Court record
Date Event Court official Court reporter Amount
11-20-2025 Written explanation of determinate sentence
Additional text:
given to defendant in court.

11-20-2025 Other papers
Additional text:
Temporary Commitment form filed

11-20-2025 Dispositional order/judgment Drettwan, Kristine E.
11-20-2025 Notes
Additional text:
BOND QUASHED

11-20-2025 Sentencing hearing Drettwan, Kristine E. Vorpahl, Jennifer
Additional text:
9:15 am case called. Appearance made. Attorney Zeke S Wiedenfeld in court for State of Wisconsin. Defendant Steven D Merkel in court, in custody. Attorney Obi Uzowulu in court for Steven D Merkel. Attorney Tyler A Jochman in court for Steven D Merkel.

State in compliance with victim rights.
Court addresses the guilty plea questionnaire and jury instructions 990.
Atty Jochman makes record as to Defendant recalls reviewing and signing JI 990 with previous attorney.
Defendant does not object with the court proceeding with today's hearing.
Court has colloquy with Defendant in re of JI 1020 & JI 990.
Defendant recalls discussing elements from JI 1020 & 990 with previous attorney and recalls the judge reviewing this with deft at Plea hearing.
Defendant recalls signing elements with previous attorney.

Atty Jochman states has has reviewed PSI with his client.
Court has reviewed victim impact statement.
Court has reviewed Defendant memorandum, recites corrections on record.
Atty Jochman makes statement as to jail credit form and no objection.

M.M. makes statement.
M.M-K. makes statement.
Exhibit #4 is marked and identified as copy of photos of victims from Mother.
No objection by Atty Jochman for publication of photos.
Court grants publication and receives exhibit #4.
Exhibit #1 is identified as copy of photos of victim; Exhibit #2 is identified as photo copy of firearm; Exhibit #3 is identified as photo copy of bathroom.
Atty Wiedenfeld asks to move Exhibit #2 into evidence.
Atty Wiedenfeld asks to move Exhibit #3 into evidence
Atty Wiedenfeld asks to move Exhibit #1 into evidence.
No objection by Atty Jochman.
Court receives exhibit #1, #2, #3.
Atty Wiedenfeld gives sentencing argument and sentencing recommendation.
Atty Jochman gives sentencing argument and sentencing recommendation.
Defendant does make statement.
Court gives sentencing factors and sentence Defendant.
Court takes short recess.

SENTENCE:
Ct1:
35 years, PRISON/PROBATION, Bifurcated,
25 IC
10 ES

CONDITIONS OF PROBATION/EXTENDED SUPERVISION:
Costs, DNA, Restitution
Not to possess any weapons. No Firearms. No Ammunition.
No alcohol.
Defendant is not to enter any bars, taverns, or liquor stores.
No illegal drugs or drug paraphernalia.
No contact with victim or their residences with out the victim and probation's agent consent.
No contact with any minors without probation agent's approval.
Counseling as recommended by Probation Agent.
Not eligible for programming.
303 days dead time credit.

11:02 am case adjourned.

11-20-2025 Other papers
Additional text:
Application for Jail Time Credit

link: Wisconsin Circuit Court Access
 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
120
Guests online
1,496
Total visitors
1,616

Forum statistics

Threads
635,382
Messages
18,674,867
Members
243,190
Latest member
sherlocknothere8989
Back
Top