Will the Long Island Serial Killer ever be caught?

[LetThemEatCake]

If this is 1 killer who's been active since the early to mid nineties, the mid 40's to 50's is a logical age range.

He hasn't been active since the mid 90's, his oldest official victim disappeared in 2007.

 

[Blueeyedbrowngirl]

My assumption/opinion takes into consideration Peaches, whose legs were found in 1996 and were recently linked via DNA to body parts and a toddler's remains found near Gilgo.

 

[LetThemEatCake]

My assumption/opinion takes into consideration Peaches, whose legs were found in 1996 and were recently linked via DNA to body parts and a toddler's remains found near Gilgo.

Peaches is not a LISK victim.

 

[Blueeyedbrowngirl]

https://www.longislandpress.com/201...ubbed-peaches-linked-to-gilgo-beach-killings/

 

[LetThemEatCake]

https://www.longislandpress.com/201...ubbed-peaches-linked-to-gilgo-beach-killings/

Yes but Gilbo Beach has been used as a dumping ground for bodies by several killers, most of them not serial killers. Like I said, Peaches is not a LISK victim. She's a victim of SOMEBODY, just not LISK.

 

[DQN]

Yes but Gilbo Beach has been used as a dumping ground for bodies by several killers, most of them not serial killers. Like I said, Peaches is not a LISK victim. She's a victim of SOMEBODY, just not LISK.

I have to agree with that. A husband or significant other killed Peaches and the child. Then went on to lead a new life some where that is why she hasn't been reported missing. At the very least if another man father that toddler I think he would have known and reported them missing. If it was a boyfriend or a husband he may have told neighbors if they knew any neighbors they were moving and she went on ahead of him. Or maybe they never got to know thier neighbors enough to question what became of them. That should be ran on one of these crime shows, "If anyone had a female neighbor with a toddler child that suddenly left or was gone in June of 1997 with Peaches Description and explained away by someone else TO PLEASE REPORT IT!

Maybe jacobd83 can put this on the Facebook page that was created.

 

[LetThemEatCake]

I have to agree with that. A husband or significant other killed Peaches and the child. Then went on to lead a new life some where that is why she hasn't been reported missing. At the very least if another man father that toddler I think he would have known and reported them missing. If it was a boyfriend or a husband he may have told neighbors if they knew any neighbors they were moving and she went on ahead of him. Or maybe they never got to know thier neighbors enough to question what became of them. That should be ran on one of these crime shows, "If anyone had a female neighbor with a toddler child that suddenly left or was gone in June of 1997 with Peaches Description and explained away by someone else TO PLEASE REPORT IT!

Maybe jacobd83 can put this on the Facebook page that was created.

I agree, but all of the other victims read like that, the asian man, surely was some prostitute posing as female, the john found out, killed and dumped him, and same with all the others. I guess what's shocking here is that so many individual murders, whether accidental or premeditated, can be so easily disposed and no one find out.

 

[DQN]

Ocean Parkway the dumping grounds for dead bodies. It runs 15.59 miles and very desolate in most areas. Here are photos of it for those who are not familiar with the area. In the last photo with the spray painted arrow on the ground points to where one of the bodies was found on Gilgo Beach area of Ocean Parkway.

 

[DaisyChains]

There was a story in Sunday's NY Daily News about a serial killer of prostitutes. If you didn't know what you were reading you might think it is the LISK case. Girls go missing. Nobody seems to care. Girls reported to be running out of a house screaming for help. etc., etc.,.....cops are there investigating assaults and missing persons. One gal is seen running out when the cop is there.

Bottom line: Eventually the cops find 8 rotting bodies of prostitutes in the attic.

Very interesting. Was it this case?

http://www.the-line-up.com/kendall-francois/

 

[DQN]

Yes it was about Kendall Francois in Poughkeepsie, NY

 

[Mimimak]

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-human-equation/201701/serial-killers-in-2016

 

[Aslan]

If this is 1 killer who's been active since the early to mid nineties, the mid 40's to 50's is a logical age range.

He hasn't been active since the mid 90's, his oldest official victim disappeared in 2007.

Fire Island Jane Doe's legs were discovered in 1996. I think she is considered a LISK victim, isn't she?

 

[Hotpotato]

Fire Island Jane Doe's legs were discovered in 1996. I think she is considered a LISK victim, isn't she?

Depends on who you ask

 

[LetThemEatCake]

Fire Island Jane Doe's legs were discovered in 1996. I think she is considered a LISK victim, isn't she?

No, officially only the gilgo 4 are LISK victims and I agree with that assessment. The other victims are too random/disposed off to disorderly to be the work of LISK or other serial killer.

 

[Charlize]

I think LISK will turn out to be a team - at least 2 killers working together...I also believe LE know who they are.

 

[LetThemEatCake]

I think LISK will turn out to be a team - at least 2 killers working together...I also believe LE know who they are.

what are your basis for believing that?

 

[PictureSnatcher]

No, officially only the gilgo 4 are LISK victims and I agree with that assessment. The other victims are too random/disposed off to disorderly to be the work of LISK or other serial killer.

That is a difficult point to argue. Jane Doe, Jessica Taylor, and Peaches all had their torsos dumped on the mainland and exteriors dumped on Ocean Parkway. Jane Doe was found very close to Peaches daughter. So it's the same method for all 3, hardly random/disorderly. Jane Doe 1996's torso was never found, which means it was probably dumped on the mainland as well the others.

 

[LetThemEatCake]

That is a difficult point to argue. Jane Doe, Jessica Taylor, and Peaches all had their torsos dumped on the mainland and exteriors dumped on Ocean Parkway. Jane Doe was found very close to Peaches daughter. So it's the same method for all 3, hardly random/disorderly. Jane Doe 1996's torso was never found, which means it was probably dumped on the mainland as well the others.

Not necessarily, I live in a small country and we honestly haven't had a serial killer that we know of. There was this case were a girl was murdered in an apartment by an acquaintance, and he and his friend dismembered the body. They then dumped her in a box in the main city trash dump. They were not serial killers. What I'm trying to say is that, this scenario repeats itself, someone gets murdered, whether accidentally or in a crime of passion, and the killer quickly figures out that it's impossible to transport the body so they turn to dismemberment. So to me that's what happened. Peaches and the Asian male do not fit the rest of the victims so it's safe to assume they were individual cases, individual killings that both perpetrators figured out that dismemberment was the easiest way.

 

[PictureSnatcher]

Cool story bro. It's not the dismemberment that I was pointing out, it's the fact that each time the torso was dumped on the mainland, the skull/limbs were brought to Ocean Parkway, the same highway on the barrier island of Jones Beach. Yes I'm sure someone from your town dismembered someone once, but what's your point? The method was the exact same

 

[LetThemEatCake]

Cool story bro. It's not the dismemberment that I was pointing out, it's the fact that each time the torso was dumped on the mainland, the skull/limbs were brought to Ocean Parkway, the same highway on the barrier island of Jones Beach. Yes I'm sure someone from your town dismembered someone once, but what's your point? The method was the exact same

How do you know that? Peaches was dumped far away from her baby so the two wouldn't be connected in case one of them was found but that's it, what else does that tell you? I don't know how far away the other bodies were thrown, I believe only one other victim had her limbs and skull deposited elsewhere. That doesn't say anything. My point is that, two different people can reach the exact same conclusion when found themselves in a similar situation. The other killer may have thought the same thing the Peaches killer did. Or they may be the same person, there is no way to know with such little information so I honestly do not know how anyone can flat out say this is the work of more serial killers. So far we only have one and that's LISK.