I noticed that some people were asking about the connection between dance studios, but there would be no connection between the girls and Elevations School of Dance. Elevations was not around in 1999. Back then I believe the area shown as the studio on maps was a church. There was at least one other studio here at the time, but I am not sure where it/they were located.
Thanks for that bit of info EmKD and welcome to the forums.
Feel free to express any opinions you might have about this case when they come to you, or any rumors you might have heard for that matter.
As you can see were at a bit of a stand still at the moment.
I second LR1's post: Welcome EmKD, and thank you for this post. Ruling out a possible Elevations connection is extremely valuable in terms of forward progress. This is exactly the kind of information we need. And yes, as LR1 said, please feel free to contribute any thoughts you have. Thanks again!
But if they came to Ozark on purpose, then why did they ask Marilyn for directions at the Big/Little store? There was absolutely no reason for them to do this unless they were really lost.
That alone is reason for me to doubt they came to Ozark on purpose.
Respectfully snipped.
KR, from the beginning I have thought along these exact same lines. If the girls were not truly lost, they had no reason to ask Marilyn Merritt for directions. If the girls were being deceptive, they needed only mislead one party the only party expecting them that night: Tracie's parents. We know this because we know the girls' plan was for J.B. to spend that night at Tracie's house and attend church with Tracie's family the next morning, thus leading us to the conclusion that even J.B.'s mother was not also expecting a call concerning the girls' whereabouts that night.
So why, then, would the girls bother with trying to convince Marilyn Merritt, a total stranger, they were lost when they were not?
After spending a little time away from this case recently and now looking at it again, a new scenario popped into my mind, and I believe it's pretty feasible:
What if Marilyn Merritt overheard Tracie on the phone telling her mother (untruthfully) they were lost and would be home later than expected, and just took it upon herself to give J.B. directions
without being asked?
We know of at least one source that states Ms. Merritt gave J.B. directions while Tracie was on the phone. If Ms. Merritt simply happened to notice the two girls standing there, overheard one of them telling someone on the phone they were lost, and decided to be helpful, she likely would've approached J.B. (since Tracie was on the phone, and possibly because she had noticed J.B. was driving) and given her directions to Dothan, no questions asked.
Why would it ever occur to Ms. Merritt that Tracie was lying to the person on the other end of the line? And why would J.B. interrupt Ms. Merritt's helpful but unnecessary giving of directions to say, "We don't really need directions home, we're lying"?
I believe we may very well have read in media reports that the girls
asked for directions from Ms. Merritt, but in my mind it would be incredibly easy for this issue to become confused. Ms. Merritt may have simply stated, "I gave the girls directions." This could easily lead one to assume that Ms. Merritt
gave the directions because the girls first
asked. But this assumption could so easily be wrong.
It's incredibly common for reporters to misquote people, even eyewitnesses. So a reporter could've gotten this detail wrong.
Additionally, I believe it's entirely possible Ms. Merritt may have forgotten such a small detail after all, when she encountered the girls at the Big/Little Store, she had no idea what was about to happen to them. She would only have searched her memory of the encounter later on, after her mind has been subjected to the shocking news of the murders. So Ms. Merritt could have remembered or, perhaps by being unintentionally vague, even unknowingly stated this detail inaccurately.
And, maybe most important of all, it never would have occurred to Marilyn Merritt that the girls were lying; if indeed they were, this is a secret that would've been known only by J.B. and Tracie and possibly a third party who may also be the killer(s).
Either the girls asked for, and were given, directions OR
the girls were overheard and given directions. In terms of the everyday, the difference is very slight, almost imperceptible. After all, why would it matter whether the girls asked first or not?
But when the girls are subsequently murdered, and major questions arise as to what really brought them to Ozark, this difference suddenly becomes extremely important.
Is it known where he was when our girls were killed?
A search for any information that reveals Vaca would have had a reason to be in Alabama during the summer of 1999 has turned up nothing so far.
At one point I found a message board conversation where one poster claims to have encountered Vaca in the '90s. Vaca, described by the poster as "a friend of a friend," "weird" and "odd," bought acid during the encounter. I checked the poster's profile on the off-chance that he was located in Alabama, but found instead that he's in "T-County, OH" Tuscarawas County, where New Philadelphia is located which points to the most likely scenario: that Vaca never lived anywhere else and is not J.B. and Tracie's killer.