Still Missing Australia - Amber Haigh, 19, still missing, NSW, 5 June 2002 *Arrests*

Welcome to Websleuths!
Click to learn how to make a missing person's thread

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

"Notebook Amber Haigh left behind

reveals loneliness and hurt in final days before disappearance.


In a notebook found after Haigh disappeared,
she had written in careful printing:

'When will I get someone to love me.
I feel so lonely'."

 

A retired married couple have been found not guilty of murdering 19-year-old mum Amber Haigh, who disappeared more than two decades ago from regional NSW.

Robert and Anne Geeves, both 64, will walk free after Justice Julia Lonergan acquitted the pair today following a lengthy judge-only trial in the Supreme Court at Wagga Wagga.

*****
 

A retired married couple have been found not guilty of murdering 19-year-old mum Amber Haigh, who disappeared more than two decades ago from regional NSW.

Robert and Anne Geeves, both 64, will walk free after Justice Julia Lonergan acquitted the pair today following a lengthy judge-only trial in the Supreme Court at Wagga Wagga.

*****
How on earth
 

A retired married couple have been found not guilty of murdering 19-year-old mum Amber Haigh, who disappeared more than two decades ago from regional NSW.

Robert and Anne Geeves, both 64, will walk free after Justice Julia Lonergan acquitted the pair today following a lengthy judge-only trial in the Supreme Court at Wagga Wagga.

*****
Wow, did not see that coming...........:mad::(
 

Amber's case would have been better heard before a jury. imo

From your link, the two things that the judge couldn't be sure of beyond a reasonable doubt are:

398 (i) that the Geeves had the shared motive to kill Amber in order to assume full parental control of Ben
398 (ii) that they did not take her to Campbelltown Railway Station on 5 June 2002, (and as part of this, Amber could not have withdrawn money from her bank account in Campbelltown).
 
Amber Haigh: Couple accused of killing teen to steal baby acquitted - the first I'd heard of this case was this BBC article today, what a pity there apparently wasn't enough evidence to convince the judge, as while they may be viewed not guilty by the court, there's definite conclusions I can reach from the circumstances. Seems more than a little implausible that she should somehow come by an accident/random unconnected murderer while briefly away from those who, IMO, groomed her. And this is a man who already seems lucky to have escaped conviction over another dead girlfriend. Either he's the unluckiest man on earth with what happens to his partners, or....
 

"Amber Haigh murder trial:

how a ‘red herring’ witness

and poor policing

hampered the hunt for answers.


On Monday,
Robert Samuel Geeves, 64, and his wife, Anne Margaret Geeves, also 64,
were each found not guilty of murder in the NSW supreme court.

They had spent more than two years in prison awaiting trial,
but are now free.

They have consistently maintained they never harmed Haigh,
nor had anything to do with her disappearance.

1726604846097.png


The verdict was a moment of acute intensity inside the packed, hushed courtroom,
and the decision was met with anger from some:

one member of the public gallery stormed out of court and screamed wildly.

Family members of Amber Haigh
were seen in tears outside the court,
consoling each other with hugs."

 
I don't know how Australian courts work but is there a place for a civil suit? Next of kin who sue. Lower threshold.

Something, anything to validate Amber's story, reality, life...

She mattered.

JMO

Wrongful death suits in Australia involve this ... Anyone who is a relative of a deceased person whose death was caused by a wrongful act, neglect or default of another person pursuant to the Act has a claim for damages.

I sure as heck would want to try something. An appeal, a lawsuit. The judge found reasonable doubt because he wasn't sure that the Geeves didn't drop Amber at the station. Then where did she go? No further sign of life from Amber after that.

And he didn't think it was proven that the Geeves wanted Amber's baby. Despite Robert Geeves tying Amber up and having sex with Amber. Despite the Geeves keeping the baby in their bedroom ... forming an attachment. And Amber telling multiple people that the Geeves wanted her baby. imo

 
Last edited:

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
161
Guests online
3,495
Total visitors
3,656

Forum statistics

Threads
604,613
Messages
18,174,538
Members
232,757
Latest member
Tillygirl
Back
Top