> When Blodgett arrived, he noticed a few drops of blood on the boat and asked Millard about it.
Millard said his girlfriend was menstruating and the toilet was broken, which made sense to Blodgett.
"We're talking about drops of blood," Blodgett said. "It seemed completely reasonable."
So the little drops of blood were either on or near the toilet. Sounds pretty menstrual to me. Perhaps thats why the girl was taken back to the dock as she was feeling unwell due to menstruation and seasickness combined. makes sense.
Copied from the article itself, Mr Blodgett did not say
"we're talking about drops of blood", nor did he say it was near the toilet.
When Mr. Blodgett came aboard to fix the problem, he noted a quantity of blood around the boat, which he questioned. Receiving a satisfactory answer, Mr. Blodgett fixed the problem and departed back for Little Current. During his visit, the woman was not in sight. Thinking about the encounter now, Mr. Blodgett said it was “troubling.” While tales of the encounter have grown and morphed into tales of a blood soaked boat and a missing woman, the proprietor said this is not the case, nor can he claim that the second woman on the boat did not return with Mr. Millard, as he did not see his client depart from the boat upon its return to Little Current.